3 ms·
But if I put a human in the black box, that somehow now matters to your argument, because you're saying that it only holds for machines.
by stavros 4y ago
But if I put a human in the black box, that somehow now matters to your argument, because you're saying that it only holds for machines.
- ubercow13 4y agoIf you transcribe a copyrighted book by hand, that doesn't give you the right to publish it. I don't think being a human currently gives you a legal loophole to copy works so why make the comparison?
- wokwokwok 4y agoI don’t care if there’s a human in the box. If the box spits out training input as output it is copying it. It doesn’t matter if there is a human doing it or not. For your supposition to work, the input to the box would be only an abstract summary of the logical steps, and the output an exact copy of some other thing that was never an input. In that case, yes, it would not be copying. ..but, is that the case? Hm? Is that what we care about? Is it possible to randomly generate the exact sequence of text with no matching training input? Along with the comments? It seems fabulously unlikely, the point of being totally absurd.
- chmod775 4y agoHumans (and their creativity) have special status and privileges in law. Machines don't. It doesn't matter how fancy they are. The law doesn't care. So yes, a human in a black box is different from a machine in a black box until laws change.
- patates 4y agoI'm a proponent of not restricting (well, or trying to restrict) machine learning models and not considering them a lossy database but it must be said here if humans can recreate copyrighted works from memory and publish them, they are in trouble too.
- stavros 4y agoI agree, I'm not saying that machines don't produce copies of existing data, I'm saying that's not all they produce.
- dkersten 4y agoI agree. The problem is that a human has ethical deterrents to avoid copying data while a machine doesn’t, so we have to rely purely on legal incentives to avoid copies from being produced.
- patates 4y agoI think the best argument here is that having the work in memory is not illegal, and human brains are not bound to copyright even when they can also be considered lossy databases. The question is where do we draw the line for a lossy database.