6 ms·
> Charlie Munger, the Berkshire Hathaway vice-chairman and Buffett’s right-hand man, echoed his concerns, telling the meeting: “I don’t think having a bunch of
by SoftTalker 4y ago
> Charlie Munger, the Berkshire Hathaway vice-chairman and Buffett’s right-hand man, echoed his concerns, telling the meeting: “I don’t think having a bunch of bankers, all of whom are trying to get rich, leads to good things. I think bankers should be more like an engineer, avoiding trouble rather than trying to get rich … It’s a contradiction in values.”
It's a good comparison. Engineers can be personally liable if they are negligent in their jobs. Why not bankers?
- markus_zhang 4y agoBecause we are living in a financial capitalism?
- candiddevmike 4y agoWhy stop at bankers, lets extend this to all sorts of job titles that should be held liable for their actions (or the actions of their subordinates).
- ekianjo 4y agoHow about politicians?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoHow about voters, and now we come full circle
- Lev1a 4y agoProblem with that is, politicians promise all kinds of things for their election campaigns, then do whatever TF they want anyway once they're elected and sitting pretty effectively untouchable by the peasantry that elected them, getting rich and fat for a few years before "retiring" to a cushy board position of some company they "incidentally" helped during their political "career". Politicians are mostly professional parasites and most political systems seem to attract, apart from the odd once-in-a-while genuine idealist, exactly that type of people.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt seems like the electorate prefers those who promise the moon over honest idealists. I find it very hard to imagine that there is a lack of honest grass-roots idealists in a country of 350+ million people, so it must be a lack of people willing to vote for them.
- esalman 4y agoProgrammers are not held liable. If you go to another industry, such as construction, it's not the case.
- mr_00ff00 4y agoMan, the crazy future where programmers are punished for bad code. The sheer amount of trails would break our legal system.
- mikrl 4y agoA lawsuit against the author, the intern who +1d the PR, the senior who approved the PR, the engineer who ran the linter, the engineer who changed a variable name, the engineers who got it into prod, the engineer who fixed it (and introduced a new bug)
- throwaway173738 4y agoThat can actually happen in medical devices, especially if you’re liberal with commentary.
- jsemrau 4y agoThat's not fully correct. If you look for example at the case of James Liang who got sentenced to 40 months in prison. O https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/26/vw-engineer-sentenced-to-40-month-prison-term-in-diesel-case.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/26/vw-engineer-sentenced-to-40-...
- CommitSyn 4y agoThat was a fraud scheme.
- usui 4y agoUh, no? The parent was talking about software engineers, whereas this guy was closer to the hard-engineering and construction aspects, and on top of that, he was involved in wire fraud... Huge difference versus just being a smaller actor with no intent to concoct a big scheme.
- throwaway894345 4y agoIt makes more sense for some professions to be high-risk/high-reward—e.g., a startup executive. But banks are innately conservative institutions—depositors need to be able to get their money on demand, so it makes more sense to take measures that make banking professionals more conservative.
- vladd 4y agoJust to remember that there are different sorts of liabilities and punishment. For example, losing one's net worth might be an example. Shareholders are already subject to it, while for employees, even when fired, they just lose the potential of future earnings, leaving their accumulated net worth untouched. Wikipedia calls this the principal-agent problem ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble... ). Should employees in a position of power be agents that are putting up some collateral as a guarantee to be forfeit in case things go south? Or otherwise would unwarranted risk-taking behavior in their job be enough to go to jail when the results of their actions impact others in the world at large negatively?
- schemester 4y agoBanks are a specific situation where employees can get one-sided rewards for increasing exposure to tail risks with other people’s money. It’s to avoid misaligned incentives with delayed (by years) feedback.
- humanrebar 4y agoEngineers (or at least engineering firms) also get rewards for exposure to tail risks. As do many other professions. I'm not convinced bankers are special in that regard.
- schemester 4y agoHow much more money do engineers or engineering firms make by designing dams that fail and boats that sink?
- riffraff 4y agoI'm not sure how we can quantify it but we've had the car emissions scandal, the Boeing scandal, perhaps a self driving one.. It seems engineers screw up on purpose often enough that the monetary incentives must be there.
- ISL 4y agoCan be quite a bit -- the low bidder gets the job and gets paid. The higher bidder doesn't get paid and gets to continue looking for work.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoSoftware engineers can make quite a bit at projects and companies that ultimately fail. Should we hold developers at uber criminally liable if the company fails? management? where does it stop?
- UncleEntity 4y ago> Should we hold developers at uber criminally liable if the company fails? Apparently not even if they design a system for thwarting regulators from doing their job.
- xracy 4y agoIt's a fair question. I think the necessity of this tends to drop off with power. So I don't know if it's really necessary for a grocery bagger... But it probably wouldn't hurt. Feels like a fine broad brush policy.
- frogpelt 4y agoRight on. If the waiter brings me salmonella, he should pay the price.
- xracy 4y agoI think this would more likely fall on the cook.
- gadders 4y agoPoliticians every time there is a recession.
- metaphor 4y agoTo be sure, Munger was specifically throwing shade at investment banking practices; here's where that discussion happened for context[1]. [1] https://youtu.be/5QBkn42PSxk?t=620 https://youtu.be/5QBkn42PSxk?t=620
- bagacrap 4y agoI really don't understand how this relates to the current banking crisis (yet). They're complaining about the amount of leverage in the investment banking system (seemingly unlimited when counting the leverage of derivatives) but all the banks that failed recently were doing normal banking (taking deposits and making loans).
- metaphor 4y ago> ...but all the banks that failed recently were doing normal banking (taking deposits and making loans). I feel like the term "normal" here is a bit loaded. To quote Buffett on First Republic Bank[1]: >> If you take First Republic, for example, you could look at their 10-K and you could see that they were offering non-government-guaranteed mortgages in jumbo amounts at fixed rates, sometimes for 10 years, before they changed to floating. That's a crazy proposition. Rubbing salt into the solvency wound, an overwhelming majority of First Republic's long-term assets were tax-exempt municipal bonds, and thus not eligible BTFP[2] collateral. In the case of SVB, it was an extreme outlier with respect to sector concentration of uninsured depositors where all it took was a single individual with influence in a tight-knit community to trigger historically unprecidented outflows, which in turn forced massive losses in long-dated securities to be realized in an attempt to quench the liquidity demand impulse, which in turn broke the bank's solvency...nevermind that their outsized duration risk wasn't hedged, or that their Chief Risk Officer stepped down almost a year before the bank's demise without proper regulatory disclosure. Then there's the matter of certain relaxations to the Dodd-Frank Act pushed during the Trump administration[3; see Title IV]...nevermind that Frank himself sat on the board of Signature Bank, or that SVB's CEO Becker sat on the board of the San Francisco Fed. I suspect it's not merely a coincidence that the assets of these failed banks skyrocketed shortly after deregulation yet remained under a certain $250 billion asset threshold "for strategic reasons". [1] https://youtu.be/5QBkn42PSxk?t=488 https://youtu.be/5QBkn42PSxk?t=488 [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/financial-stability/bank-term-funding-program.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/financial-stability/bank-term... [3] https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/2155 https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/215...
- bee_rider 4y agoHas anyone heard of a software engineer actually being held personally liable? I think it would be good for the field if this was a possibility, but as far as I know it this is only really possible for the classical “get a license or operate under an industrial exception” type engineers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Seattle3503 4y agoSomething that I found interesting moving into the financial sector is that some individuals at the bank can be held personally liable for bad decisions. For example, top compliance officers at a bank can be held liable if it later turns out terrorists (or the like) were able to bypass bank controls. This is supposed to engender good risk management around compliance risk. If we can do it for compliance officers, why not for CEOs? The average citizen is more likely to be harmed by financial collapse than a terrorist.
- whitemary 4y ago> If we can do it for compliance officers, why not for CEOs? CEOs are hired to be the public face of the company. The board who hires the CEO doesn't want the face of their company being a criminal, and in the U.S. corporate boards overwhelmingly dictate the law books. That's how capitalism works.
- kaycey2022 4y agoSo once a CEO is held liable for a bank collapse, then they can never be a CEO again because they would also be a criminal. It's perfect. What is wrong with that?
- csomar 4y agoYou are ceo for life in corporate America. Kidding aside, your mistake is assuming that the system works. It does, but not in your favor.
- soperj 4y ago> That's how capitalism works I don't think that's capitalism, I think that's corruption, which may be a big part of this implementation of capitalism, but I feel like it is separate.
- kevviiinn 4y agoCapitalism is defined by exploitation and corruption
- jollofricepeas 4y agoEngineers != Software Developers Considering the forum, it’s important to raise this distinction I think due to the lack of ethics and uniform professional standards in software. The question remains… Should a board of directors and other senior leaders be liable for software harms (eg. Breaches) caused by poor oversight, malfeasance or greed?
- spamizbad 4y agoEngineering is significantly more intellectually rigorous than banking and finance. I'm not trying to say bankers a dumb or anything - far from it. They're quite smart, and they know their industry well, but engineering enjoys the privilege of sitting on top of "hard science" and mathematic whereas banking has... economics? Imagine the field of engineering in a world where science still debated whether the world was flat or round, or whether empiricism was even worth the trouble in physical sciences (and if you felt strongly one way or another you were considered an ideologue) -- that's where economics is today.
- orange_joe 4y agosure, there are things that are uncertain about economics, but there are a great many things that are understood as well. Within Finance, its understood that some things are riskier than others. SVB blew up because they opted to buy highly risky long dated, low yield bonds even when there was good reason to believe that the economy was entering an inflationary period.
- rippercushions 4y agoLow yield bonds are pretty much by definition the safest instrument around, that's why they're low yield. (High-yield aka junk bonds are the risky ones.) In SVB's case, the risk was not in the bonds themselves, but in the facts that a) there was a yawning mismatch between the high interest they needed to pay out on deposits to stay competitive and the low interest they were getting on their locked-in capital, and b) their customers were heavily concentrated in a single industry, namely fickle VCs and their companies.
- ethbr0 4y agoParent is taking issue with SVB's long date preference for the yield bump, which from a risk standpoint wasn't appropriate for their depositor base, in an inflationary environment.
- heavenlyblue 4y agoI think you just conpletely misunderstood what risk here meant.
- Haga 4y ago[dead]