3 ms·
This is simply not true. Laws can be written exceptionally clearly, and very often are. And the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy, which your sentence exposes w
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is simply not true. Laws can be written exceptionally clearly, and very often are.
And the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy, which your sentence exposes when you write:
> "the legislator is trying to accomplish"
Because yes, there is absolutely intent with a single legislator. But there is no such thing as intent or spirit for a legislature (or committee). A legislature can pass a law, say 51 to 49, where every one of the 51 majority legislators has a different intent for passing it. And this isn't even the exception, it's the norm -- laws are hashed out in subcommittees as inelegant compromises because each legislator wants a different thing out of it.
Legislation that gets passed has no "intent" and no, humans don't know "pretty well" what was trying to be accomplished, because it's a compromise between competing wings/individuals of a party or coalition, and the only "intent" that they could decide on was what got written in the law, and nothing else.
Again, the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy. It's an illusion people would like to believe, but it doesn't exist.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Again, the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy. It's an illusion people would like to believe, but it doesn't exist. You might want to tell that to multiple judges who rule daily on the spirit of the law. TBH, I don't think that you know how the law works better than judges and magistrates do. You know what a loophole is, right?
- crazygringo 4y ago> TBH, I don't think that you know how the law works better than judges and magistrates do. TBH, I don't think you do either, but I also know that kind of argument isn't useful here on HN. > You know what a loophole is, right? Yes, it's a layman's term that has no real legal meaning, and exists only in the eye of the beholder. What one person calls a tax loophole, another person recognizes as policy that a subset of legislators ensured existed in a bill. You think tax loopholes are there by accident?
- plandis 4y ago> You might want to tell that to multiple judges who rule daily on the spirit of the law. It’s not a judge ruling on a case that is sending this letter to Apple.
- howinteresting 4y agoYour position is one of many.