3 ms·
I am thinking should I flag this. And thinking how low can ieee get? ieee publishing 20+ years ago were not great, but they wont bad. Right now this piece has n
by ksec 4y ago
I am thinking should I flag this. And thinking how low can ieee get? ieee publishing 20+ years ago were not great, but they wont bad. Right now this piece has no engineering insight into it, zero understanding of how MNOs across the planet earth work, no idea of 5G upgrade cycle both backend and front end, and zero mention of Pandemic / COVID delaying upgrading work. So what is the point of this article? Or are they now simply another marketing / PR company to downplay the 5G and hype 6G next?
Are we still at the stage people think Real 5G = mmWave? Which is what I believe 99.99999% of the internet comments were suggesting and at least 90% of HN believes in 2022.
- Mistletoe 4y agoWhy would you flag this? That’s not what flagging is for and is one of the asbolute worst features of HN. It amounts to censorship based on user preferences. It’s a real article from IEEE, just because you don’t like it or agree with it doesn’t mean you flag it. > What does [flagged] mean? >Users flagged the post as breaking the guidelines or otherwise not belonging on HN.
- jnsaff2 4y agoIf you think that flagging amounts to censorship then I guess you don't believe that there are bad faith actors who exploit vulnerabilities in human cognition? I don't think this ieee article is nowhere near flagging territory but there are plenty genocide and fossil fuel shills around here.
- Mistletoe 4y agoI think that's what the flag button should be for, things encouraging harm to other people or out and out lies or going to malware sites, but the IEEE article is none of that, it's a well-reasoned article with sourced facts.
- silisili 4y agoI'm not going to argue with you, but it would be really helpful to me or us if you could be more informative and perhaps less insulting to the crowd. After all, most mobile tech is done in the dark and few are truly versed in all of it. I for one didn't think 5g == mmWave, but I specifically chose TMobile because their initial 5g rollout plan made way more sense for me, as it wasn't mmWave, where others seemed to be focusing there.
- makeitdouble 4y agoTo me this piece can be summed up as "5G isn't performing well, this can be due to many reasons". Your comment seem to come up with more reasons it isn't doing as well as it could, while basically going into the same direction as the article. Why would you flag it for being basically right, even in a boring way ?