4 ms·
I discarded this guy's argument once I read this paragraph: And experiments such as the one my daughter, Jackie Cushman, is running in Atlanta—where poor child
by swombat 18y ago
I discarded this guy's argument once I read this paragraph:
And experiments such as the one my daughter, Jackie Cushman, is running in Atlanta—where poor children are paid the equivalent of working in a fast-food restaurant to study and do their homework—are examples of a more dynamic future.
How is being paid to study and do homework an example of early adulthood? One huge difference between adults and non-adults is adults tend to grab every opportunity to improve their skills, and understand that those don't come that often.
This article started with an interesting (if incendiary) premise, but then the author showed that he has poor logical skills. Perhaps he should go back to school himself.
In short, this article is a hodge-podge of potentially interesting half-ideas and downright nefarious illogical conclusions.
- tlrobinson 18y ago"This guy" is Newt Gingrich, btw.
- swombat 18y agoBeing famous doesn't preclude being illogical.
- JoelSutherland 18y agoNo, but his authorship gives this article a fascinating context.
- JesseAldridge 18y agoYou discarded all of it because you didn't like that one part? This type of behavior always annoys me. There are lots of interesting and important thoughts here. I agree that these ideas need to be closely examined and refined a great deal before being put into practice -- but I'm not just going to shout "FAIL" -- because while that may be gratifying to the ego, it is utterly counter-productive.
- swombat 18y agoI decided that once you took away that key step of "having a clue what an adult is", the rest of the argument fell away like a puff of smoke in the wind. There may be interesting ideas in there, but they are too closely interweaved with dangerous mistakes and incendiary "political linkbaiting".
- willchang 18y agoEducated people make for a better society. If that weren't the case, there'd be no point in giving out scholarships either.
- nostrademons 18y ago> One huge difference between adults and non-adults is adults tend to grab every opportunity to improve their skills, and understand that those don't come that often. Not most of the adults I know. Nor most of the teenagers either, for that matter. Actually, I think "grab every opportunity to improve their skills" describes children under 10 more than any other age group.