3 ms·
> Your vote counts in proportion to your expected remaining years left in society. So if you’re 95, you get 1 vote. If you’re 20 you get around 60 more, dependi
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Your vote counts in proportion to your expected remaining years left in society. So if you’re 95, you get 1 vote. If you’re 20 you get around 60 more, depending on the tables. If you’re an immigrant who arrived as an adult, eg a corporate expat, you get maybe 5 votes.
This is both a bad general idea and a ridiculous specific application, as immigrant citizens who arrived as adults do not, in fact, have particularly reduced future in society than any other citizen of the same age.
> There will be a table of stats about all sorts of things like this.
And…how detailed will those stats be? Will it take into account race, income, place-of-residence, and similar factors that correlate to expected lifespan in society? So that those who are most disadvantaged in the status quo have their voices systemically deweighted to protect the status quo elites?
> When you vote, it’s a quiz.
Other comments have addressed the problems with poll tests with regard to history, but structurally, this is just another way to deweight the voices of those least well served by the status quo system.
> Parliament is chosen by proportional representation.
This, OTOH, is a good idea.
> Term limits. Maybe just a single term of 10 years.
The form of PR suggested above (MMP with some by-district proportional method underneath) renders this mostly superfluous; while there may be a decent argument for term limits to mitigate problems in a system which denies effective choice because of FPTP, or denies effective specific candidate choice because of simple party-list PR, that really applies only to top-up seats in MMP.
> Large salary and large pension for the MPs.
“Large” is extremely vague this could be good or bad.
> Not sure about geographic seats. Maybe just assign each voter to a virtual MP, at random. Local geographies should have local government to deal with local matters. This also does away with gerrymandering.
You already suggested areas with proportional representation, with top up seats for finer-grained proportionality. Each voter than already has a set of MPs set by the side of the “area”, with a very high probability of having an ideologically largely aligned MP from that area. This also already solves gerrymandering, since once you get away from FPTP winner-take-all districts to multiseat proportional districts, (especially with at-large top-up seats for fine-grained proportionality) the ability to influence partisan balance or other features of the legislature by where you draw district lines is basically eliminated. All the random assignment suggested in this item (whether voters to an MP or addresses to an electoral district) is superfluous.