6 ms·
The New York hotel destination fee scam (2020)
- rottencupcakes 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230506035236/http://www.travelforaliving.co.uk/tips/know-about-new-york-destination-fee/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230506035236/http://www.travel...
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoResort fees are still everywhere. You gotta pay for that pool access and two water bottles per day! At least Marriott will start displaying them in the booking process: https://onemileatatime.com/news/marriott-display-rates-transparently-resort-fees/ https://onemileatatime.com/news/marriott-display-rates-trans...
- eli 4y agoIt took a lawsuit though. The FTC should just mandate the fees be shown up front.
- dfxm12 4y agoWe have a weird legal system where Marriott gets sued for something being done by many hotels and the outcome is that only Marriott has to be transparent about this. It's tough to even call this the bare minimum to help consumers who have such little power in this situation. I'm glad bills for the Junk Fees Prevention Act, which would address this, were introduced in March/April, but they haven't had any movement since. It's sad when stuff like this, which would appeal to any American that doesn't own a hotel can't get passed probably because people who do own hotels just have that much more political power... https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/916 https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/916 https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/2463 https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/2463
- eli 4y agoBiden called for the legislation in his State of the Union speech, so of course Republicans feel obligated to obstruct it.
- tristor 4y agoI've always hated the resort fees. They're an absolute scam. Hotels went from having free WiFi anyway, to having free WiFi and charging a "resort fee" for covering the amenity of free WiFi. Food and beverage credits are basically never worth it. At least you had something for loyalty in the past, HHonors Diamond would get you free breakfast at any Hilton property globally. No more, you get $10-$18/day in F&B credit, when it typically costs $35-60/day for breakfast. To add insult to injury, the locations you most likely will encounter resort fee scams are also locations that tax the ever-loving shit out of you. Nothing galls me more than visiting San Francisco and having to pay extra taxes on top of the normal already high taxes in California/SF because I'm city-center. Yep, definitely worth the extra money as I dodge mentally ill people, needles, and human feces to walk from my hotel past a luxury boutique to get a burger for dinner at a corner diner where it's only $25 for a simple burger instead of the $45 the hotel charges. I've traveled a lot, I've never once got my money's worth out of a resort fee. At least in Las Vegas there's a way to decline it, but they just won't let you connect to the WiFi from the room. If you're in Vegas for anything other than a business trip, you're probably not going to be spending much time on WiFi anyway, and I have unlimited 5G data on my mobile phone + tethering. It's absolutely a scam, and it's ridiculous you get taxed on paying bullshit fees, it's just a way for the government to scam you too at the same time they give businesses a pass for scamming you with bullshit fees.
- pxx 4y agoWait what? Afaik there's no way to decline a Vegas resort fee without being a member of the relevant casino rewards program in the requisite status tier.
- tristor 4y agoYes, you can decline them. I do this every single time at check-in if I'm not on a business trip. If you decline them, then you won't be able to use WiFi since you have to connect with your last name and room number through the captive portal at most properties. This may be property specific, I usually stay at MGM properties. If I'm on a business trip I don't care because it's not coming out of my pocket, and I usually can't choose the hotel I am staying at unilaterally. The resort fee basically covers access to specific amenities (theoretically), if you decline it you will be giving up access to those amenities, that are otherwise not "free". YMMV.
- yadaeno 4y agoWhen I stayed in New York, I was asked to pay a $95 a night “cleaning fee” after I paid for the room in advance. Definitely avoid “yotel” if you can.
- ghaff 4y ago??? I regularly stay at a Yotel in Manhattan and have never encountered that. It's recent if it's the case.
- zachruss92 4y agoI am pretty sure this is a way for hotels to appear competitive on deal websites/apps. When I use like HotelTonight the “Resort Fee” is not included in their price. It’s definitely a dark pattern and I wish they were just up front about it and allow consumers to make informed decisions.
- johnwalkr 4y agoUsing VPN to access European versions of booking sites will usually let you see listings with all fees included as required by law, although a shady hotel in New York can probably get away with adding a totally hidden fee for a while.
- avidiax 4y agoThis practice is more generally known as "drip pricing"[1], and it is definitely a dark pattern. My feeling is that the travel search engines should define a standard for a certain category of travel, and then show the price that achieves that standard. That this hasn't happened shows a sort of industry capture or lack of competition, IMO. If a hotel is said to be 4-stars, then amenities like WiFi, gym, and pool access should be included in the rate. If they have a resort fee, that should be included on the search engine. For airfare, economy class should have a reserved seat, printed ticket, with X inches of legroom, Y inches of width, 1 standard carry-on, 1 check-in bag, a soft drink and crunchy snack of your choice for short flights, and a meal at 4+ hours. Whatever price that ends up being is what is shown on the search engine. If it requires "economy plus" to achieve that level of service, then that's what you get if you search for "economy" class fares. Let the search engine have a "steerage" search class for the 2-star hotel experience at a 4-star hotel, and the "water costs extra" economy airlines. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drip_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drip_pricing
- CaptainZapp 4y agoI'm not opposed to unbundling for flight tickets. If you don't have checked luggage or don't need to eat, why pay for it? What riles me up is when airlines intentionally provide a shitty experience when you're not willing to pay the higher price. To me, as a status flyer this is s form of blackmail and I'm not willing to play. Their error of thinking (looking at you, Lufthansa Group, but others likely pull the exact same shit) is that I don't only buy cheap flights, but will sometimes splurge for a business ticket in long distance. Just this February my business went to the Omanis (which also offer the better product). Being treated like shit on short distance flights was not the only reason, but certainly a factor.
- throwaway22032 4y agoThe problem is that eventually it becomes ridiculous to the extent that the process feels, well, just mean. For example, budget flights in Europe have no cabin baggage included other than a very small bag. There's enough space in the cabin, and logically the cost of adding another 10kg to each person can't be more than 10-15% of the ticket, but it's way more than that to add a normal sized bag.
- jmyeet 4y agoI didn't know this existed in NYC. It's well known in Vegas (which the article mentions) where it's called a "resort fee". It's paid at check out and is mandatory. And yes, it's to have a lower sticker price for rooms. Airlines do it too. There are "fuel surcharges" and other fees that aren't really fees. It's just a way to make the ticket appear cheaper. Uber got in trouble some years ago by adding a "safety fee" to their fares. What did this buy? Absolutely nothing. They just pocketed it. And of course concerts are a big one for added on fees that may well double the price (or more). And let's not get started on AirBnB and their "cleaning fees". I hate this crap. The only price you should be able to quote is the all-inclusive price. And mandatory fees should be part of that price. It should be illegal (ie false advertising) to do otherwise. It just goes to show how feckless the FTC is.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoA few months ago President Biden announced his war on "junk fees" which should include this, but it appears the administration has ADHD and quickly forgot about it.
- FireBeyond 4y ago> by adding a "safety fee" Hell, a lot of these companies (even ISPs) tried to avoid the bad blood around things like this by actually listing them as taxes, until they were told they could not call anything a 'tax' that wasn't actually required by and paid to a government entity.
- nukeman 4y agoOne other thing with fuel fees is that they aren’t taxed the same way airline tickets are, so there is a tax benefit to charging for fuel fees as well.
- danpalmer 4y agoI’ve never seen a dual surcharge except on the final receipt breakdown where I learn the ticket price is only about half of what I paid. From Google Flights through to checkout it’s all inclusive of fees. I think this might be due to EU legislation requiring that. Maybe time for the US to crack down on it in a similar way.
- version_five 4y agoI was charged an "urban fee" by a business hotel (a Fairmont property) that I used to stay at regularly, because I once had to book it though a discounter because of a company's travel policy. I used to be an elite member at their hotels and they've now lost all my business for it, which obviously isn't important to them because they didn't even respond to the email I sent them complaining. They must be making enough scamming people this way that they don't care. Personally I'm not very price sensitive, I'm happy to pay to get my preference. But I'm very sensitive to getting ripped off. If someone wants to charge me a certain price, they better bake it into the up front cost. If they lie to me and make me pay more later, it's literally theft and I'm not giving business to criminals, like Fairmont. All that said, the airline industry used to have a much bigger problem with lying about the up front price and then adding in a bunch of extra fees when you pay. But ~20 years ago now I think there was some legislation, at least where I am, that required them to advertise the real price. The same should apply to hotels.
- gnicholas 4y agoWhat is an "urban fee"?
- xp84 4y agoSounds like a "The land is all used up here, so nobody will be able to build a non-ripoff hotel to compete with us" fee.
- version_five 4y agoIt was just something made up to tack onto the bill and make it higher.
- jamesdhutton 4y agoI have had the experience myself of getting an unexpected and mandatory “resort fee” added to my nightly rate in NYC, and I agree it’s a scam. I read somewhere that the practice came about as a result of price comparison websites. It gives hotels a way to appear near the top of the list when you sort by price, by displaying a bogus price that excludes the resort fee. They bury the resort fee in the small print. This is exactly how I got suckered. I think it reflects poorly on the price comparison sites as well as the hotels.
- tamaharbor 4y agoI have always been wary of the ‘safe fee’ also.
- gnicholas 4y agoThe room comes with a fully-stocked safe?
- xp84 4y agoI guess hotels are more evil than airlines now, since while they do the same "unbundling" of pricing, the whole things is a scam because you have no choice but to pay for all of it even when you don't want those amenities. At least with Spirit you could choose to fly in a middle seat, with no bags at all, no water, no snack, no windowshade, no using the lav, and pay the exact price they advertise. Although I remember at least 10 years ago staying in a few hotels which advertised in small print something like "A copy of the Chicago Tribune will be provided to you. If you do not want it, notify the front desk and we will credit 50 cents each day off your bill."
- walterbell 4y agohttps://www.hospitalitynet.org/opinion/4105700.html https://www.hospitalitynet.org/opinion/4105700.html > On September 3, 1988, the New York Times published an article titled “Hotels, Like the Airlines, Offer Discounts.” That article referenced a new “sophisticated computer technique known as yield management” ... In 1994, Sheryl Kimes of Cornell University, another early pioneer in the field, conducted research on consumer reactions to demand-based pricing practices, indicating that consumers were more accepting of those practices by airlines than by hotels. By 2001, Kimes’ follow-up research confirmed that there was no perceived difference between the two. Dynamic pricing was here to stay.
- voldacar 4y agoI don't get how this crap doesn't just fall under fraudulent advertising. The price of x is y iff (I give you x or more dollars -> you give me y).
- m463 4y agoHope that "food labels for broadband" comes to other commerce like airlines, hotels and rental cars.
- fwlr 4y agoDo note that the article is from 2020. I have some experience with Booking.com and Expedia from the other side of the check-in desk (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35591495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35591495). Both sites now try to include resort fees and other charges in the listed price, and I believe both also try to charge their 10-12% OTA commission on resort fees as well.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tpoacher 4y agoThe first price comparison website that manages to include these bullshit charges effectively will make a lot of money. (part of which will no doubt be spent on made-up lawsuits by the businesses involved)