13 ms·
US crypto mining used more power last year than all the computers
- Greg433 4y ago[flagged]
- varelse 4y ago[dead]
- willcipriano 4y agoCrypto miners are computers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yccs27 4y agoIt‘s pretty clear they mean other computers.
- mdkdog 4y agoso quiet here...
- AustinDev 4y agoTo put this into perspective US manufacturing used 4.69e12[3] Kwh where crypto mining used 0.05e12 Kwh. Even more interesting is the comparison to the US dollar which ostensibly is backed by all US Energy consumption less maybe residential consumption which was 2.86e13[2] kwh less residential at ~21% = 2.28e13. Now let's compare the USD energy consumption to bitcoin which was 1.29e11[1] kwh in 2021 which would make Bitcoin ~200x more efficient than the USD in terms of energy required to secure. [1]: Bitcoin Energy usage 2021 - https://rmi.org/cryptocurrencys-energy-consumption-problem/#:~:text=Bitcoin%20alone%20is%20estimated%20to,fuel%20used%20by%20US%20railroads https://rmi.org/cryptocurrencys-energy-consumption-problem/#.... [2]: US energy usage 2021 - https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/ https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/ [3]: US Manufacturing energy usage 2021 - https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/industry.php#:~:text=In%202021%2C%20the%20industrial%20sector,of%20total%20U.S.%20energy%20consumption https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/industry.p....
- whydoineedthis 4y agoany data sources? or just wishful thinking?
- woodruffw 4y agoThe other half of that perspective is that US manufacturing is a critical, productive part of our economy. The US dollar is backed by a complex of factors, including our willingness to invade or otherwise bring to heel countries that threaten the US dollar. Trying to do math on the "efficiency" of bitcoin versus the US dollar is a category error.
- AustinDev 4y agoIt very well could be a category error to claim bitcoin is 200x more efficient than the USD. I did the comparison for my own purposes to try to bring some sort of perspective to the number 50 billion kwh because it's so large it doesn't mean much to me without meaningful comparisons. It's also worth noting that most mining power consumption happens where & when energy is cheap. Bitcoin as a whole uses more renewable energy than the US economy by a factor of 2x @ 58.9%[1] vs Total US usage from renewables @ 23%[2] [1]: https://www.globalxetfs.com/bitcoin-mining-is-set-to-turn-greener/#:~:text=The%20Bitcoin%20Mining%20Council%20(BMC,36.8%25%20estimated%20in%20Q1%202021 https://www.globalxetfs.com/bitcoin-mining-is-set-to-turn-gr.... [2]: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2023/03/01/clean-energy-hits-record-us-2023-sustainable-energy-factbook/11324041002/#:~:text=Energy%20from%20renewable%20sources%20produced,23%25%20of%20U.S.%20electricity%20in%202022 https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2023/03/01/clean-energy-....
- peteradio 4y ago> Bitcoin as a whole uses more renewable energy than the US economy by a factor of 2 You say that like its a good thing.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe "unit" of value backing the US dollar has dimensions that you can't factor into a meaningful comparison here; any comparison you do make is going to result in nonsense answers, regardless of your opinion of Bitcoin's value. Bitcoin does indeed use power where it's cheap[1]. The argument that justifies Bitcoin's use of renewables needs to account for Bitcoin's concurrent prolongment of nonreneweables. [1]: https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/2022-1-spring/notes-here-there/crypto-throws-coal-industry-lifeline https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/2022-1-spring/notes-here-t...
- humanrebar 4y agoAll the computers? Aren't smart TVs actually dumb home theater PCs these days? Don't cars have several computers in them these days? Watches and smartphones? I thought the stat about how crypto is using nearly as much power as lighting more meaningful and surprising.
- AustinDev 4y agoIt's just residential lighting which isn't all that much energy usage. What makes all these numbers surprising is if you look at the yearly output of a nuclear powerplant which is ~8 billion kwh / year. We should probably build a bunch more nuclear plants to replace all of our fossil fuel plants.
- Swenrekcah 4y agoI would probably rather describe smartTVs as capable spying equipment.
- tcmart14 4y agoThat is where it gets blurry. What are we defining as a computer? Some coffee machines run Debian, do they count as a computer? Smart TVs pretty much are computers. Or are we only counting computers as something that runs Windows, MacOS or Desktop linux?
- Phiwise_ 4y agoSounds like it's time to stop hyperventilating over the biggest nuclear non-disaster in American history and build more reactors. Fun fact: in 1962, the Atomic Energy Commission projected there would be almost ten times as much available energy in 2060 as there was at the time. Today, I understand we consume just about two times as much. Anyone think we'll get across that finish line thirty years from now with the status quo?
- Guthur 4y agoNot while we allow gangsters to rule the world.
- woodruffw 4y agoI think the consensus on HN is generally pro-nuclear. Building nuclear plants because of pointlessly induced demand, however, is ridiculous: we should build nuclear capacity to replace existing capacities that we'd like to phase out. In addition to pointlessly raising the US's energy profile, Bitcoin has also made that aspect of the US's long-term power profile worse than it needs to be[1]. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/feb/18/bitcoin-miners-revive-fossil-fuel-plant-co2-emissions-soared https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/feb/18/bitcoin-m...
- nscalf 4y agoWe should expand energy production where there is extra demand for energy. That new energy should likely be nuclear. To pass judgement on what the energy use should be is ridiculous, and very counter to the behavior of this country that let it grow.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoActually I think the idea of forcing crypto miners to use nuclear is brilliant. My proposal would require that they pay the full cost that nuclear charges to the grid, and also that they aren’t allowed to purchase power from any fossil sources or grid-connected renewables. I’m not sure this idea would be long-term economically sound but it would remove the major objection to crypto mining (carbon emissions) and if the crypto miners go out of business due to proof-of-stake becoming more common, they’ll hopefully have funded the construction of new nuclear plants for the rest of us.
- superkuh 4y agoIt does take a lot of resources to protect a cryptocurrency from attack by corporations and nation states. Typically the resources have to be significant enough that those entities don't find it a worthy trade to perform the attack. That's what proof of work does. It performs the same role as a standing army except it does it non-violently. And that's amazing. Well worth it.
- discreteevent 4y ago> That's what proof of work does. It performs the same role as a standing army So if I invent a token where I can prove to you that I burned electricity to mint it, will you accept it in return for some of your possessions or your labour?
- paulgb 4y agoHow do you reconcile that with the fact that 8/10 of the top coins by market cap do not use proof of work? (https://coinmarketcap.com/ https://coinmarketcap.com/; Bitcoin and Dogecoin are the only PoW ones IIRC)
- 1-more 4y agoThe market cap of the PoW coins is 127% of that of the PoS ones. But it probably matters more the daily trading volume of them? Not really sure.
- sharperguy 4y agoThe only thing that matters is how the system performs under a sustained attack. Any "cryptocurrency" system which depends on the lack of such an attack could be relpaced with a federated system and instantly be thousands of times more efficient. Coins like tether cannot continue to exist unless they are allowed to continue.
- superkuh 4y agoThe real metric here is how many people are buying and selling things (not coins themselves) with a cryptocurrency. For actually using it as a currency bitcoin is still unchallenged. Markets and traders are just an unfortunate side effect that now are more associated with the word "cryptocurrency" than the actual use of cryptocurrencies in the public mind.
- nivenkos 4y ago[flagged]
- detrites 4y agoWhy stop there? Why not regard online forums that speak about it as terrorism too, and round up everyone who's participated in any discussion about crypto online, on the basis of having aided proliferation of terror, and throw them in the slammer?
- alphanullmeric 4y agoFurther proof that most people would support the patriot act if it was worded differently. Just sprinkle in a little “to prevent tax evasion”, “to prevent domestic terrorism”, “to stop the spread of misinformation” and the Democrats would be tripping over each other to get it into law.
- pazimzadeh 4y agoA desktop computer uses about $20 a year of electricity, so this seems fine. https://news.energysage.com/how-many-watts-does-a-computer-use https://news.energysage.com/how-many-watts-does-a-computer-u... Let's get rid of television.
- Semaphor 4y agoI don't even have a high end gaming PC, and I'm at 275 kWh for the year already, over 100 €
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pazimzadeh 4y agoWhat kind? What do you do on it?
- Semaphor 4y agoRX6600, Ryzen 5 3600, 1 FHD and 1 WQHD monitor. Gaming and coding.
- tiedieconderoga 4y agoYour desktop PC uses almost 2kWh per day? Do you ever turn it off or put it to sleep?
- Semaphor 4y ago6-7h a day when I'm sleeping.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SoftTalker 4y agoMine runs 24x7 except for the screens, they sleep after 10 minutes of idle time. CPU sleep is too much of a crapshoot, I'd rather spend a few dollars on power than have to spend time getting my work environment restarted and back into a productive state.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoLest we forget ban of high spec PCs, but cryptomining is fine. OK then https://nichegamer.com/high-end-gaming-pcs-banned-in-six-us-states-after-california-energy-bill-limits-sales-on-high-performance-pcs/ https://nichegamer.com/high-end-gaming-pcs-banned-in-six-us-...
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Lest we forget ban of high spec PCs The ban from which high-spec PCs were specifically exempt? https://www.pcgamer.com/high-end-gaming-pcs-are-exempt-from-the-cec-power-regulations/ https://www.pcgamer.com/high-end-gaming-pcs-are-exempt-from-...
- chaxor 4y agoThis title is hilarious. S is a subset of U. Also headline: |S| > |U|. Incredible. But I suppose this pedantic point doesn't matter since HN hates cryptocurrency so much they lose their minds and start hating cryptography just out of spite as well.
- yccs27 4y agoComputing is not a subset of crypto mining.
- nostrademons 4y agoEnergy graph omits all of the biggest household energy consumers: EV chargers, electric HVAC (including heat pumps), electric water heaters, clothes dryers, ovens, ranges, and other kitchen appliances. Turning every single light on in my house at once is < 200W. So are all the other items in the list. Running all of them 24/7 is < 5kWh, not that you would ever do that. A single clothes dryer run is 5 kWh. A mid-size heat pump is about 8 kW.
- landoftheice 4y ago[dead]
- DethNinja 4y agoIt is so funny to me that every time BTC price rises, FUD articles come out of the woods. I wonder if somebody built an automated process for this, or there is still a human element to it.
- janalsncm 4y agoWould you also describe articles that denounce burning down the Amazon rainforest as “FUD”?
- flerchin 4y agoRising prices increases energy used, as miners are primarily constrained by energy costs, and higher prices allows them to use more energy and still be profitable. Higher BTC prices are bad for the environment.
- latchkey 4y agoNot necessarily true. There is limited power to go around and finding spaces is also difficult. At scale, this becomes a limiting issue. Just because the price goes up, does not mean that a company can take on the risk of allocating multi-year contracts to expand.
- yashg 4y agoBro tell me what are you planning to buy when your magic token hits a bazillion worthless dollars? Hope you continue to DCA so the whales can have liquidity or are you a whale yourself? Salute in any case.
- johndevor 4y agoFreedom ain't free.
- uoaei 4y agoIt won't be worth much once the consequences are borne out.
- johndevor 4y agoYou realize wars are funded with fiat currencies?
- yashg 4y agoWhat cool aid are you drinking?
- johndevor 4y agoWhy don't you want people to control their own money?
- yashg 4y agoWhy do you want people to exchange their hard earned money for worthless magic internet tokens?
- johndevor 4y agoFeel free to hold fiat paper. I'm sure inflation won't come to your country. I just ask that you allow me to make my own decisions in peace.
- yashg 4y agoRight. The coin that went from from 60K to 20K is a perfect hedge against inflation. Cool man. You control own money, who are we to say if you want to hand it over to a bunch of scammers selling you fairy dust.
- thrill 4y agoProof-of-work/capacity/importance and friends are simply shifts of proof-of-stake into illiquidity. They're unnecessarily wasteful.
- mjburgess 4y agoReminder: good estimates place the number of people in the cryptocoin system in the 100,000s. BTC can support c. 7 transactions/sec. Ethereum c. 20. This is a scam. It's a self-organizing pyramid scheme. There is no "there" there -- the vitamins really arent a cure for cancer, and your friend telling you to buy a warehouse full is part of a cult of pushers who are desperate that their warehouses of vitamin pills (ie., tokens) doesn't become entirely unsellable. All the numbers reported by the cryptocoin system are made up: these are manipulated markets with almost no buyers. "Market cap"s are inventions. The amount of actual liquidity in the system is tiny: people are looking for the exists. These exits are mugs called "hodlers", ideally, You, who'll buy their vitamins from them. Usually, HN comments ought be somewhat more sober -- but I think this is now out of line. Sobriety in this matter is enabling a system of exploitation which should not be entertained by decent people.
- Ferret7446 4y agoBTC protocol can handle transactions off-chain. I cannot take any post that doesn't address that simple fact seriously, since you're just repeating talking points without any research or technical analysis.
- kipchak 4y agoRegarding number of people actually using the system, do you have any good estimates in mind by chance? I'm seeing claims of 7% of Indians for example, which would be in the millions by itself. https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership-data/ https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership-data/
- mjburgess 4y agoKeep in mind that all the major source on crypto, including the top dozen popular textbooks I could find on amazon -- and many "academic" looking papers -- are written by people profoundly invested in selling crypto. All crypto news is press releases from crypto companies. All crypto ideas are rehearsed sales pitches with no arguments or evidence. You should assume anything written on crypto which hypes it is a lie. You should investigate the site/author, and -- I'd predict -- you'll find that every single time it links back to people with profound economic incentives to lie to you. For BTC, you have 400,000 addresses used daily transacting about 300,000 transactions. This is trivial to obtain as a public record. How many of those addresses are associated with only one individual? If i wanted to simulate millions of users I could do so only with a trivial amount of money. What is a "user"? It's just an address. There are no "users" on the chain. There are 70mil addresses on BTC, I believe. How fast could an interested party double that? Pretty quick. These numbers, absent hard-hitting empirical data, should be regarded as fraud. They're made up, either at the level of the press release, or by technical manipulation. Eg., by moving lots of money around a few accounts to manipulate figures. This is a system which maps, at least provably and publicly, to the entire daily economy of a small town. And it's energy usage is measured in 10^12
- ftxbro 4y agoThis is good for the environment. It encouraged green power like solar and wind, and if energy usage ever becomes a problem we can just turn off the miners.
- danaris 4y agoThis appears to be a classic example of the Broken Window Fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_window_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_window_fallacy
- verdverm 4y agoSounds more like we spend as much on cryptos, which have provided the tiniest fraction of value, compared to all other computers, which have provided immeasurable value. Turning off the cryptos is sound environmental policy, that energy will be needed for the electrification of transport.
- ftxbro 4y agoI'm just going by what the Texas Comptroller said https://comptroller.texas.gov/economy/fiscal-notes/2022/aug/crypto-tx.php https://comptroller.texas.gov/economy/fiscal-notes/2022/aug/... > "Despite its heavy power needs, cryptocurrency mining offers a potentially beneficial and symbiotic relationship between power usage and power generation. Miners can participate in demand response programs, incentives offered by ERCOT to quickly turn off miners’ power during periods of peak demand. When electricity prices are high or supply is straining to meet demand, miners can reduce their energy use. Supply and demand run in tandem, so if a miner stops using electricity, it’s the equivalent of a power plant producing extra electricity that could assist in meeting grid demand and help with grid stability." > "simple economic theory suggests that increased mining activity could spur additional energy infrastructure. Mining facilities often are located near wind and solar farms that provide access to cheap electricity prices" Do you disagree with the Comptroller?
- verdverm 4y agoIt is easy to find arguments to support either view. Better to be evidence based over cherry picking articles that confirm your bias. https://time.com/6193004/crypto-climate-impact-facts/ https://time.com/6193004/crypto-climate-impact-facts/
- EGreg 4y agoProof of work sucks, if the "work" is just running the same hash function over and over and wasting electricity. At Qbix, back in 2018 we were the first ones to implement Monero mining as an option to pay for an Calendars app that was on 50,000 computers, instead of a monthly recurring fee. But we quickly took it out. Back then it blew up and was all over the news, while I was finally taking a week vacation on a cruise with bad internet LOL: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43386918 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43386918 https://venturebeat.com/security/mac-app-calendar-2-misfires-on-cryptocurrency-mining-vanishes-from-app-store/ https://venturebeat.com/security/mac-app-calendar-2-misfires... https://mashable.com/article/apple-app-mining-cryptocurrency https://mashable.com/article/apple-app-mining-cryptocurrency https://www.newsweek.com/apple-your-mac-mining-cryptocurrency-app-store-caught-hosting-suspect-software-842663 https://www.newsweek.com/apple-your-mac-mining-cryptocurrenc... https://www.engadget.com/2018-03-13-apple-calendar-2-crypto-miner.html https://www.engadget.com/2018-03-13-apple-calendar-2-crypto-... https://9to5mac.com/2018/03/13/crypto-mining-calendar-app-ios/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/03/13/crypto-mining-calendar-app-io... The original article was from ArsTechnica, who interviewed me: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/theres-a-currency-miner-in-the-mac-app-store-and-apple-seems-ok-with-it/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/there... I told them: "We have decided to REMOVE the miner in the app. The next version will remove the option to get free features via mining. This is for three reasons: 1) The company which provided us the miner library did not disclose its source code, and it would take too long for them to fix the root cause of the CPU issue. 2) The rollout had a perfect storm of bugs which made it seem like our company wanted* to mine crypto-currency without people's permission, and that goes against our whole ethos and vision for Qbix. 3) My own personal feeling that Proof of Work has a dangerous set of incentives which can lead to electricity waste on a global scale we've never seen before. We don't want to get sucked into this set of incentives, and hopefully our decision to ultimately remove the miner will set some sort of precedent for other apps as well. Ultimately, even though we technically could have remedied the situation and continued on benefiting from the pretty large income such a miner generates, we took the above as a sign that we should get out of the "mining business" before we get sucked into the Proof of Work morass of incentives."*
- EGreg 4y agoThree years ago, I wrote a whole post on HN warning about this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26220992 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26220992 Earlier this year "Ordinals Theory" and now the "BRC-20" tokens have been taking off like crazy... https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/05/02/first-mover-americas-bitcoin-ending-week-on-positive-note/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/05/02/first-mover-amer... In anything that's NOT proof of work, I would be willing to engage and help the ecosystem. But with proof of work, I'm worried that the Bitcoin blockchain having MORE applications is bad for the world. I've spoken to people whose job it is to defend Bitcoin and they had to admit that, if market forces continue, then Bitcoin will start to cause blackouts for people around the world (in some parts, it already has). Ironically, the Bitcoin maxis probably hate that their beloved blockchain is now going to be overrun with degens bidding up their transaction fees to the moon: https://twitter.com/IntercoinOrg/status/1654355480569839616 https://twitter.com/IntercoinOrg/status/1654355480569839616 Anyway, I am wondering, maybe helping NFTs on Bitcoin and making degens have a mania and crowd out the Bitcoin transactions will actually make Bitcoin LESS attractive to the HODLers? In that case, I'd do it. I wish Bitcoin price would fall and make it uneconomical to mine it, while non-PoW projects like Polygon break free of it and see a lot more adoption.
- seu 4y agoSomething is not clear, or does not make sense. Do they compare the consumption of crypto mining in the US, with the amount of power consumed by all computers in the US? How can the first be bigger than the second, which is the upper bound for any computing task in the US? What is this crypto computed on, if not on computers?! (of course, the energy consumption is outrageous, but this article doesn't make much sense)
- dahwolf 4y agoSurely one can make the point that crypto mining is high energy, making it potentially contribute to CO2 output and e-waste. But when you do, at least try to do your homework. Not a single (linked) source is mentioned regarding the energy metric, other than a description that it's a guess with supposedly > 100% margin for error. Not a word on the energy mix. It draws a direct conclusion between energy consumed and CO2 output as if these are 1:1. The statement that BTC/ETH contribute nothing of value is surely one many agree with, but not factual. It implies that this author/magazine cares about energy use, which surely they do not. There's 5 million energy sucking ads on the page and it's a magazine that can't wait to tell you about the all-new 3 foot long GPU so that you can play your game at 8K on a 240FPS.
- danlugo92 4y agoSince Bitcoin can't effectively be banned, why doesn't all of the people complaining about it just move on? Do you enjoy feeling anger over something, something you or no one in the entire world cannot change?
- danaris 4y ago> Since Bitcoin can't effectively be banned What on Earth makes you think that? True, it would be difficult to get every country in the world to get together and ban it simultaneously—but if converting cryptocurrencies to USD and EUR were banned, you just watch how fast they would dry up and blow away.
- danlugo92 4y ago> converting cryptocurrencies to USD and EUR were banned Banks can't differentiate between consulting fees and buying bitcoin. Btw I don't have anything to win by telling you this, I'm only bringing information to light.