6 ms·
CRTC considering banning Fox News from Canadian cable packages
- incomingpain 4y agoTucker isnt even with Fox news anymore, but this isn't the point. For those not following Canadian politics. Bill C-11 recently became law and they are combining this with our lack of free speech. >The group said the Fox News “coverage aimed to provoke hatred and violence against 2SLGBTQI communities, particularly those who are Two Spirit, trans, nonbinary and gender non-conforming (2STNBGN).” This is about censorship. You claim your political opponents are 'inciting hatred' toward yourself or others and the government has the ability to censor your shared political opponents. I will be shocked if they don't completely ban Fox news from Canada.
- 908B64B197 4y agoHow is that not a clear-cut first amendment violation? The government literally banning what speech can reach it's citizens. To be fair, it's not really a surprise. The government decided at one point to suspend the constitution (because that's a thing over there?) during peaceful protests by truckers...
- pearle 4y agoWrong country.
- hanselot 4y ago[flagged]
- psychphysic 4y agoShhh, don't get em upset incase they decide to liberate Canada.
- SonicScrub 4y agoNot sure what the Manitoba Act has to do with this. Could you clarify what you mean?
- obblekk 4y agoThis might be one of those cases where “legal but regulated” is better than driving people to seek the product from completely unregulated markets. Canada has many reasonable regulatory alternatives including: - condition libel protection to retractions made with the same prominence if fox is made aware of falsity - create individual liability for libel in addition to corporate - require public broadcast messages on certain topics - require a fairness doctrine on certain topics
- BunsanSpace 4y agoFox news was already considered entertainment and barred from news packages. This recent complaint came from Tucker's weird Canada is under a dictatorship documentary. Given he spread blatantly false and harmful information, the CRTC is forced to review the complaint. People need to read beyond the headlines. This is the regulatory framework at work.
- hedora 4y agoThey should bar Fox News from using the "entertainment" loophole, and apply news regulations to them. "News regulations" should include all the stuff the comment you replied to listed, for everyone (as they used to, at least in the US). Ideally, they'd also include a few more good ideas the US used to enforce: Limits on market share, and bans against foreign ownership.
- pjc50 4y agoIndeed. They're basically the American version of Russia Today, a malign foreign propaganda channel.
- roenxi 4y agoIt'd be a reasonable guess that more people will hear about this on Joe Rogan's podcast than on Fox News. If Tucker Carlson starts a podcast it is plausible more people will be deciding their opinions based on what he says than based on what Fox News says. We are fortunate to live in an era when groups like the CRTC are incapable of silencing opinions that they disagree with. Still distasteful though.
- allanmacgregor 4y agoNot with Bill C-11 now being turn into law now the CRTC can do the same on the internet, so Spotify, Twitter, Facebook, Youtube can now be silenced
- rcme 4y agoFox news just settled a defamation case for over $700 million. At some point, you can't call what's being broadcast an "opinion." Clearly Fox agrees what they're broadcasting isn't an opinion and is instead a falsehood, because otherwise they would have argued their case.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 4y agoWe should note that they settled against Dominion Voting Systems which is one of the weakest points in the entire US democratic apparatus. There is a strong argument that DVS shouldn't have a market to sell to and that voting should be done entirely with pen and paper. Tracking whether their voting machines are secure and appropriately tamper-resistant is too hard and the use of electronic voting undermines confidence in the vote. So while lying about what is happening is supremely unhelpful; this is an area where the freest of free speech standards should be applied. Cracks in the technical foundations of how votes are tallied are extremely dangerous and all scrutiny should be invited. Voting processes should be held to an extremely high standard of transparency. My preferred outcome here is that Dominion gets its 700 billion from Fox News in settlement for all the lies then closes its doors and ceases trading.
- version_five 4y agoCanadians are too apathetic to care. It's one of those "they came for X but I wasn't one so I didn't care" situations up here. It's going to get way worse before it gets better.
- olalonde 4y agoYes and unfortunately, courts have already ruled that the CRTC had the right to shutdown radio stations because of insults and swear words[0]. So it wouldn't surprise me if they had the authority to ban Fox News. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CHOI-FM#Dispute_with_the_CRTC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CHOI-FM#Dispute_with_the_CRTC
- AlanYx 4y agoThis latest proposed ban is significantly more serious than the CHOI-FM dispute, in the sense that they're now considering banning an entire channel because of a complaint that one particular program on that channel was allegedly in violation of particular norms. At least with CHOI-FM the alleged offending content was peppered throughout the day. (I'm not saying either move is a sign of a healthy society, but this latest proposed ban is a step beyond. It's basically communicating to channel operators that absolutely all of their content has to fall in line, or they risk an end to their business. It doesn't even matter if the CRTC ultimately decides not to impose a ban here -- there is now a content-based sword of damocles over every channel.)
- bawolff 4y agoThere wouldn't be much point of a radio & television regulator that didn't have the ability to in theory shut down radio or television stations violating canadian law. Like that is basically the definition of what a regulator is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- version_five 4y agoSerious answer: there isn't a point anymore. I understand the relevance in a past model of spectrum allocation for channels, where there was both a will and a possiblity of controlling who got a broadcast slot. That ship has sailed - spectrum still needs to be regulated, but it's no longer relevant to "allowing" content. Crtc should be no more able to ban Fox than, say porn.
- psychphysic 4y agoIn 2015 this would be shocking but in 2023 it's not that surprising as government media control ramps up around the world. There is no longer any tolerance for anything but a narrow slice of views an opinions to be available to people. What's worse is that I generally agree with all the views of mainstream western media it still pisses me off that it seems to be biased in agreement with me... Unless I'm now part of the sheeple?
- uvnq 4y agoI think you can agree with the views of sheeple and not be a sheeple. You sound too self aware for me to assume you're a sheeple
- mschuster91 4y ago> There is no longer any tolerance for anything but a narrow slice of views an opinions to be available to people. Carlson literally disputed the results of an election, and that despite heaps of evidence that there never has been fraud. At that point, he and his gullible viewers become a threat to democracy itself - and that is not an exaggeration given the events of Jan 6th. It used to be the case that such events got classified and prosecuted as high treason.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- logicchains 4y ago>Carlson literally disputed the results of an election, and that despite heaps of evidence that there never has been fraud There's plenty of evidence of some fraud occuring, it was just never discussed by the regime-aligned media and tech companies, which is the vast majority of them. The same way they conspired to cover up the Hunter Biden laptop story, and claimed in unison that the covid vaccines could prevent transmission and infection when there was no evidence to support this. >At that point, he and his gullible viewers become a threat to democracy itself If all your sources of truth are partisan media outlets aligned with you regime, then if the fraud really was large enough to alter the election results, you'd never know. That's the real threat to democracy.
- fwungy 4y agoFox News just banned itself by getting rid of Carlson. He was their most popular host by far, and the rest of their popular evening lineup depended on his lead in. They're going to cellar to CNN.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoFox News just banned itself by getting rid of O'Reilly. He was their most popular host by far, and the rest of their popular evening lineup depended on his lead in. They're going to cellar to CNN. -- someone else, 6 years ago
- fwungy 4y agoFox doesn't have the same bench it did. There is no one with the credibility and charisma of Carlson left. When O'Reilly left they still had some talent.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoOn what planet did Tucker Carlson ever have a shred of credibility or charisma? The man was such a joke that it took Jon Stewart all of about 5 minutes to get him deleted from Crossfire. That job has two requirement: the ability to look directly into the camera and lie, and the ability to keep the elderly afraid of non-white and non-binary people. If you can do that, congratulations, you can have that job.
- olalonde 4y ago> “During the segment, Carlson made the inflammatory and false claim that trans people are ‘targeting’ Christians. To position trans people in existential opposition to Christianity is an incitement of violence against trans people that is plain to any viewer.” Interestingly, religious beliefs are a defense for "inciting or promoting hatred" in Canada[0]: "in good faith, the person expressed or attempted to establish by an argument an opinion on a religious subject or an opinion based on a belief in a religious text;" [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_in_Canada#Section_319:_Inciting_or_promoting_hatred https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_in_Canada#Sec...
- boomboomsubban 4y agoWould that apply? Saying "trans people are targeting Christians" doesn't seem like a religious belief.
- bawolff 4y agoThat doesn't sound like a religious opinion to me. Like its not based in the bible or anything. I don't think just because an opinion involves a religious group it counts as a religious opinion. As an example, the most obvious example of hate speech would be nazi stuff about jews being evil. They don't get a pass because they are making an opinion about a religious group.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThat's related but a qualitatively different thing from the quoted claim. He's not saying he hates trans people because he's christian, which would be protected I guess maybe. He's saying trans people hate christians because they are trans. These don't seem that similar to me but I also understand how they could be confused. I also agree with the assessment that the first one is personally shitty but the second is an incitement to violence.
- sophacles 4y agoIm not sure how that's relevant.
- bawolff 4y agoHeadline seems kind of misleading. Someone filed a complaint and CRTC is going through the process of handling the complaint. Its not like crtc just initiated these proceedings on their own.
- ColinCochrane 4y ago"Considering" might be a bit strong. All that's really happening is the CRTC is opening a public consultation in response to a formal complaint. A cursory look at the CRTC's website shows quite a few public proceedings that are open to comment [0], including the one from the featured article. I'm inclined to believe this is an example of the system working as intended. A complaint was filed and now the public has their opportunity to voice their opinions in response. [0] https://applications.crtc.gc.ca/instances-proceedings/Default-Defaut.aspx https://applications.crtc.gc.ca/instances-proceedings/Defaul...
- motohagiography 4y agoI would agree CRTC complaints are like lawsuits, anyone can file one. However, there is some risk that this is a trial balloon for more restrictive policies, and publicizing it like this is consistent with a playbook this government has been using. Fox is mostly harmless, and a good canary for what's going on up here. The whole picture is far too pessimistic for most people to even consider. One can be simultaneously supportive of the freedoms of LGBT people and against the malefactors who have co-opted this and other legitimate popular movements for some very insideous ends. The primary need of these actors behind the movements is for the majority of people to do nothing. It's called neutralization - where they don't have to actually defeat you if you don't resist. Bizarre behavior, extreme statements, disproportionate aggression over seemingly minor transgressons are all designed to cow people into not confronting their representatives or the activists who operate on their behalf. The reason they're going after Fox is because their commentators embolden viewers to become disagreeable to official narratives. In Canada, Fox News represents dissent, and dissent represents both hope and belief that can create resistance to the revolutionaries who have seized our institutions while we were being polite and civil. I've been watching the canaries pile up for years, but maybe this one will be the one that alerts the people in the cave.
- 1over137 4y ago>publicizing it like this is consistent with a playbook this government has been using... But it's not the government "publicizing it like this", it the National Post, probably the most right wing newspaper in Canada.
- noonething 4y agoWhats the difference between Fox News and CNN? I know there is one. I know there used to be more, I just can't quite put my finger on it now. Wasn't there an organization for standards in journalism? or can anyone start up a news org now and start reporting stuff?
- pjc50 4y agoOnly one of those recently had to pay $800m in libel settlements?
- dabluecaboose 4y agoCNN had to pay an undisclosed amount to that "Smiling MAGA Kid" after he sued them for libel, seeking $800m.
- tedunangst 4y agoMy default assumption is that any undisclosed libel settlement is usually for about $1.
- dabluecaboose 4y agoPithy remarks aside, the actual value has to be enough to convince the plaintiff to drop the case and low enough to convince the defendant that's it's cheaper than a trial. Like any true compromise, it's probably an amount that made both sides unhappy, so I'd estimate about half the requested 800m.
- tedunangst 4y agoWhat's smiling maga kid up to these days? Living a $400 million lifestyle?
- bawolff 4y agoThe difference is someone filed a complaint about fox news and nobody did for cnn. If you think cnn is deserving of a complaint, you can file one about them too.
- calimac 4y ago[dead]
- dirtyid 4y agoShouldn't have any non domestic news in packages TBH.
- iinnPP 4y agoThe group behind the complaint is Egale. The website for which couldn't be bothered with even basic accessibility requirements. None of which are difficult. The statement in question is also not entirely inaccurate. My entire friend group is LGBTQIA2+ and consistently makes comments against Christianity that would satisfy Carlson's statement. Frankly however, a lot of Christian's deserve it and the LGBTQIA2S+ community has been the target by a large sum of Christian's for long enough to warrant such a view in my opinion. With all of that being said, and with understanding of what the article is about, the CRTC should not be doing this. It doesn't serve anyone in the long run except some extremely well off, probably straight, probably white, and probably lifelong male persons. As well as the group. The same group that doesn't care about other disadvantaged people enough to comply with simple legislation enabling technology to assist those with differing ability to read and navigate the web.