2 ms·
not that i disagree, but could you elaborate on that please? as one commenter suggested, the problem is that job locations are too concentrated. we have alread
by em-bee 4y ago
not that i disagree, but could you elaborate on that please?
as one commenter suggested, the problem is that job locations are too concentrated. we have already proven that remote work is effective, so there is no need for that any more, and super high density is not necessary.
the environmental issue with low density is mostly cars, which can be solved with good public transport, which btw will also be needed in super high density areas because people will also want to go out of the city some times.
i also believe that environmental friendly construction affects the possible density a city can have. concrete is not exactly environmental friendly material. (for high density steel without concrete would be better, it's more lightweight too, so allows for higher buildings)
in short, there are a lot of factors that go into environmental friendly living. what are the factors that favor high density?
- dublinben 4y agoThis paper goes into great detail about how urban households have lower emissions than suburban ones.[0] This is made up of the different energy, transportation, food, goods, and services emissions of the different lifestyles associated with each area. For instance, going beyond transportation, climate control for buildings is one of the top uses of energy. Detached single-family homes are pretty must worst case, compared to attached housing, or even multi-story apartments, etc. [0] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es4034364 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es4034364
- em-bee 4y agoclimate control good point. i live in an area where climate control is not needed at all, so that changes the equation considerably here.
- Kalium 4y agoA few reasons, off the top of my head: First, only some jobs can be done efficiently in a remote way. We should not be in a rush to generalize this to every job. Second, public transit can be more energy and cost-efficient when in a denser context. In addition to public transit, there's also cargo transport for things like food, which given dense areas can be handled by more carbon efficient methods like water and rail instead of trucks. We haven't even touched on the efficiencies for water, sewer, and electrical infrastructure. Third, dense construction can be done with timber. We've now reached a point technologically where a 100m building can be constructed primarily out of wood (search "plyscraper"). Wood is a very ecologically friendly material, as using it means capturing carbon. Fourth and finally, building up instead of sprawling out means less deforestation, less draining wetlands, and less paving over prairies. In short there are a lot of factors that go into environmentally friendly living, and most of them favor higher density.
- em-bee 4y agocargo transport for things like food, which given dense areas can be handled by more carbon efficient methods like water and rail i am skeptical about that. at least with the existing huge high density cities like those in china. less density (well, actually small islands of high density, in relation to your point four) would allow space for local food production. and truck vs train is not a factor of distance. if anything longer distances are more efficient by train and water whereas the last mile likely will remain with trucks (which could be electric though) i agree with the other points, and i wasn't aware that wood construction went that far already. capturing carbon coincidentally i was just listening to a german audiodrama about capturing carbon.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rr808 4y ago> environmental issue with low density is mostly cars Suburban houses require more resources and energy to build, maintain, heat/cool. Transport is just a small part of it.