4 ms·
I believe any business with users or customers here are subject to our laws. Whether the US has any jurisdiction over Tanota to do anything is a docent story.
by _heimdall 4y ago
I believe any business with users or customers here are subject to our laws. Whether the US has any jurisdiction over Tanota to do anything is a docent story.
This is no different than sales tax problems where any online shop is technically supposed to follow all local tax laws for any customer. It's an insane requirement and effectively impossible to follow, but technically a small business is supposed to understand and follow every tax law on the planet.
- nottorp 4y ago> any online shop is technically supposed to follow all local tax laws for any customer Don't think that's true. I'm pretty sure US companies that sell to me don't have to charge me VAT nor pass it to my government. Same for EU companies that sell to the US, they don't have to charge sales tax. Ofc everything is muddied in the name of convenience. Let's take Amazon US. I can order from them with the cheap shipping, pick up my package from the post office and pay VAT on it to a customs agent. Unless it's under (i think) 40 eur in value, then no VAT. However, if I select expedited shipping Amazon will charge me the VAT and their shipper will pay it in my name to the local customs. But this isn't a legal obligation for Amazon US, it's a service they offer me for convenience. And incidentally I like it because I don't waste time at the post office, but that's unrelated. In the same vein, if Tutanota woudn't be an US entity this wouldn't apply to them. The US government would be free to forbid them to take US customers (maybe, IANAL) or complain to whatever jurisdiction they operate in. But that's all.
- _heimdall 4y agoIt varies by locality. A large majority of tax codes have a revenue threshold you have to reach before they you're required to collect and remit sales tax. For example, a few dozen customers with a $20 monthly subscription wouldn't trigger sales tax but hundreds of customers would. Some (most?) localities expect tax filings that show you collected revenue but we're below the threshold. In practice this is rarely done from what I've seen and I've never heard of a government cracking down on this. Where it gets annoying is the handful of localities that have no threshold and require tax remittance for any customer in their region. Agent of record services are Ina bit of a gray area too. Say I use a SaaS service to act as the official entity selling totthose customers. This a lot easier on me as I offloaded all the tax law concerns, but I don't know if it's clear yet whether the threshold for paying taxes is collective of every business using the same agent of record. --- This is just my understanding of the current state of things. I work pretty regularly with e-commerce businesses but am not directly involved in sales tax collection and compliance.
- nottorp 4y agoWhat you're missing - and what the point was - is that entities that have no business presence in the US are not subject to that. Same for emails.
- _heimdall 4y agoI may vary well be missing something there! My understanding was that part of the requirements for sales tax remittance is that a business must setup a tax entity once the total sales threshold is reached.