7 ms·
GP wrote > The idea is way too simplistic and lacks nuance. and you wrote > There is such a thing as bad faith arguments. Why is it a bad faith argument? GP
by funcDropShadow 3y ago
GP wrote
> The idea is way too simplistic and lacks nuance.
and you wrote
> There is such a thing as bad faith arguments.
Why is it a bad faith argument? GP clearly admitted that no straight forward solution that treats every case the same is going to be good. That is the same you argued for.
- nmilo 3y agoBecause pointing out that a slogan is simple and in-nuanced is unhelpful, and in bad faith. They're supposed to be simple. Slogans in a democracy are calls to action towards a general idea, and the more complicated they are the less people they can rally. Obviously the nuance will come when lawmakers actually put the thing into writing.