5 ms·
There are some software tools where the investment pays back, and has been over decades. Microsoft Office (in part because it's not reinventing itself, but rath
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
There are some software tools where the investment pays back, and has been over decades. Microsoft Office (in part because it's not reinventing itself, but rather accrues new features; in part because everyone else copies its UI patterns). Photoshop. Emacs.
With modern software, I find it that there isn't much to learn at all - in the past decade, seems to only be removing features and interaction modes, never adding anything new.
Still, I don't regret having learned so much all those years ago. It gives me an idea what the software could do. What it was supposed to do. This means I often think of multi-step solutions for problems most people around me can't solve unless there's a dedicated SaaS for it. As frustrating as it often is to not be able to do something you could 10 years ago, sometimes I discover that some of the more advanced features still remain in modern toy-like software.
- eternalban 4y agoOffice UI was reinvented at least one time. I remember when that god awful ribbon showed up. "In 2003, I was given the chance to lead the redesign of the most well-known suite of productivity software in the world: Microsoft Office. "Every day, over a billion people depended on apps like Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and Outlook, so it was a daunting task. This was the first redesign in the history of Office, and the work that we did ended up shaping the standard productivity experience for the next two decades." ... https://jensenharris.com/home/office https://jensenharris.com/home/office https://jensenharris.com/home/ribbon https://jensenharris.com/home/ribbon
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThat's not what I mean. The ribbon, whatever you think of it, only moved some functionality around. It didn't actually change the way old functionality worked. All the things you knew how to do, you could still do - you only had to learn their new placement.
- heartbreak 4y agoIf we consider the Word 2.0 (for Windows) era as the beginning of a graphical Microsoft Office suite, then graphical Office has had the ribbon for as long as it didn’t: 16 years. I’m still waiting for people to stop complaining about it.
- ethbr0 4y agoThe irony is that LLMs are actually the real solution that Ribbon took an awkward half step towards -- how to quickly get to what a user actually wants to do. Originally: Taxonomically organized nested menus, culminating at a specific function or option screen Now: Usage-optimized Ribbon (aka Huffman coding for the set off all options), culminating at a specific function or option screen Future: LLM powered semantic search across all options and actions, generating the exact change you want to implement Why have an "email signature" options page at all, when an LLM can stitch together the calls required to change it, invoked directly from English text?
- mook 4y agoYou missed Office 2000: magically disappearing menu items. It was pretty confusing.
- ethbr0 4y agoOof. I did. Ribbon felt enough like magically disappearing menu items to me.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> Why have an "email signature" options page at all, when an LLM can stitch together the calls required to change it, invoked directly from English text? 10-20 years from now? Maybe. It depends on whether or not the industry will cut corners in this part of the experience. I find it hard to predict which features get polished, and which are forever left barely-functioning. Might depend on which are on "critical path" to selling subscriptions. 0-10 years from now? We'll still need the options page. "Email signature" options page provides visibility, consistency, and predictability. That is, you can see what your e-mail signatures are, you are certain those are the ones that will be used for your message, under conditions defined in the UI pane, and if you change something, you know exactly how it will affect your future e-mails. LLMs are quite good at handling input, though not yet reliable enough. However, as GUI replacement, they are ill-suited for providing output - they would be describing what the result is, whereas the GUI of today display the result directly. As the writers' adage goes, "show, don't tell". (That said, the adage is way overused in actual storytelling.)