4 ms·
> Age checks for porn sites: seems like if parents care about this, there are plenty of technological ways to restrict their children's access? Is there a gap b
by mschuster91 4y ago
> Age checks for porn sites: seems like if parents care about this, there are plenty of technological ways to restrict their children's access? Is there a gap between what's available as a technological intervention and parents' want?
The real problem behind that are various Evangelical groups running scare campaigns against parents and pressure campaigns against ISPs and individual sites. The US was the first with FOSTA/SESTA, the UK followed suit, and here in Germany our media regulators are going nuts as well.
> Measures to clamp down on “anonymous trolls” by requiring that services give the option for users to verify their identity: for minors it seems like parents could restrict access to websites via technical means, for adults... don't use the website/app?
That one is more complex. There are many different and valid points that collide:
- the EU GDPR effectively demands that services can be used anonymously, and so did the old §13 TMG law in Germany.
- service providers (Facebook most infamously) try to skirt these laws because they sell "authenticity" of users as part of their product appeal, and others to combat spam
- the people demand the ability to post on the Internet without having to reveal their identity - say, in customer or employer review sites, or when unionizing or protesting against the government
- Employers and brands do not want anonymous reviews due to the libel potential
- people wish to watch porn or sext anonymously, because of the risk that a link between their porn habits and identity poses - the best example here is the prosecution of gays via Grindr
- governments do not like anonymous commenting either, partially because they're oppressive, and partially because of the potential for hostile acts by enemy nations such as the Russian and Chinese "fake news" campaigns
Striking a balance between these points is very complex, and the fact that many politicians are frankly way too old (or incompetent) to understand what they are regulating doesn't make things better.
- djoldman 4y agoThere are definitely multiple viewpoints on "anonymous trolls." I don't understand how allowing anonymity fails to address all of them. - the EU GDPR effectively demands that services can be used anonymously, and so did the old §13 TMG law in Germany. This allows anonymity. - service providers (Facebook most infamously) try to skirt these laws because they sell "authenticity" of users as part of their product appeal, and others to combat spam Consumers/users are not forced to use these products... as with any other product, they are forced to balance the commercial offerings' pros and cons. If they value anonymity highly, they may choose to not partake. - the people demand the ability to post on the Internet without having to reveal their identity - say, in customer or employer review sites, or when unionizing or protesting against the government This allows anonymity. - Employers and brands do not want anonymous reviews due to the libel potential They can decide (or not) to require anonymity for their offering, with attendant effects on engagement and community trust. - people wish to watch porn or sext anonymously, because of the risk that a link between their porn habits and identity poses - the best example here is the prosecution of gays via Grindr This allows anonymity. - governments do not like anonymous commenting either, partially because they're oppressive, and partially because of the potential for hostile acts by enemy nations such as the Russian and Chinese "fake news" campaigns It seems that oppression is bad, so without a compelling reason, anonymity should be allowed. "Fake news": adults should be allowed to believe in or be exposed to the information of their choice.. particularly because no one can be trusted to be the arbiter of "fake."
- mschuster91 4y ago> It seems that oppression is bad, so without a compelling reason, anonymity should be allowed. "Fake news": adults should be allowed to believe in or be exposed to the information of their choice.. particularly because no one can be trusted to be the arbiter of "fake." The last six years should have proven that most adults are not capable of judging whether a piece or source of information is trustworthy or not, hence the call for government regulation in the face of digital warfare - and yes, what Russia and China did to Western populations would have been classified as an act of war some decades ago.
- goatlover 4y agoAnd the last six thousand years of government have proven that most officials are not trustworthy for having say over what source of information adults should have access to.
- 1827163 4y agoWell in my opinion the government has absolutely no right whatsoever to dictate to the population what media they should have access to or not. It's not the government's business to regulate what we are reading, period. Such regulation belongs in dictatorships and authoritarian regimes, not free societies. Should the government try to control what we can read, then under the concept of natural rights, it has no authority to do so. And we might even have an obligation to disobey the government - yes, civil disobedience, something that I strongly advocate for in that case. Enough is enough with this censorship and thought control that has no place in a secular, tolerant and free society.
- t-3 4y ago> what Russia and China did to Western populations Do you have any examples? Everything I've heard claimed as a Russian psyop has later turned out not to be at all. I haven't heard any claims of Chinese propaganda gaining traction at all.
- 4y ago
- fknorangesite 4y ago> The real problem behind that are various Evangelical groups running scare campaigns against parents and pressure campaigns against ISPs and individual sites. The US was the first with FOSTA/SESTA, the UK followed suit, and here in Germany our media regulators are going nuts as well. 100%. Happening in Canada right now too: https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2022/02/age-verification-requirements-for-twitter-or-website-blocking-for-reddit-my-appearance-on-bill-s-210-at-the-senate-standing-committee-on-legal-and-constitutional-affairs/ https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2022/02/age-verification-require... It's a concerted evangelical Christian campaign across the board. The lobbying groups for these policies - in the UK, Germany, Canada, etc - overlap a lot.
- 1827163 4y agoWhat can we do to fight back against this lobbying, while remaining within the law? Enough is enough, we cannot have these unelected pressure groups dictating our laws. And whose views are in the minority. They do not represent the general public in any way at all.
- mschuster91 4y agoVoting, and hope the boomer generation dies out. Not much more you can do while remaining within the law.
- 1827163 4y agoSome kind or organization dedicated to exposing these front groups for what they really are, and their hidden agendas. Infiltrating them and leaking evidence to the press. A dump of all their internal emails would be very nice indeed (without breaking the law). Just like those exposing cults e.g. Scientology. We need to give these pressure groups as much publicity as we have given cults. To stop them from having a such a grip on our society, because they represent the opinions of a tiny minority. It is as if we have a second unelected government, because these pressure groups have so much power. Giving these organizations a name, a word, a label, so that the general public can identify with the problem. Maybe their actions are illegal in some way, just that they haven't been successfully prosecuted yet. This needs looking into. And maybe their behavior can be rightly criminalized in some way I don't yet know about? So a new law could put a stop to them. Many are hiding behind registered charity status. If they could be stripped of that status...