6 ms·
About 43% of people find pornography morally acceptable: https://www.nationalreview.com/news/gallup-poll-majority-of-democrats-accept-pornography https://www.na
by rayiner 4y ago
About 43% of people find pornography morally acceptable: https://www.nationalreview.com/news/gallup-poll-majority-of-democrats-accept-pornography https://www.nationalreview.com/news/gallup-poll-majority-of-.... I suspect that the majority of parents don’t. It’s only 53% among Democrats.
It’s probably a better political environment to push for restrictions on access to porn than it’s been in decades. Most people still don’t approve of it. The free speech justification for it has been knee-capped on the left. And there has been a rightward turn in views towards sex among #metoo feminists.
- aliasxneo 4y agoI'm curious what defines morally acceptable. I disapprove of it on the grounds personal convictions, but more importantly because I've done a lot of volunteer work in the anti-sex trafficking world. Knowing many of these victims were abused for the purpose of producing pornographic content is enough to sour my stomach on the issue. I just wonder if that's being made a part of the moral argument.
- macrolocal 4y agoI wonder why there isn’t more support for replacing possibly the entire industry with generative AI. Pornography is such low entropy content.
- rayiner 4y agoThe opposition to pornography is multifaceted. In particular, most women are opposed, and there’s a significant philosophical basis to that opposition both among conservative feminism but also a significant category of liberal feminism. Even secular people have objections to how porn represents women, and how it socialized young men to think about sex and what normal sexual activity looks like. In the Gallup poll (linked above), the only group where a majority find pornography morally acceptable is men 18-49. Only 1/3 of adult women find it morally acceptable. Among married people it’s only 1/3. Half of women also think sex work should be illegal, compared to only 36% of men: https://www.vox.com/2016/3/11/11203740/prostitution-legal-men-women-poll https://www.vox.com/2016/3/11/11203740/prostitution-legal-me....
- kodah 4y agoThat's changing imo. There are a lot of women that identify as liberal who are morally conservative, but it can be reasoned that this is just the effects of patriarchy that they haven't chosen to prioritize addressing because it doesn't directly benefit them. Freedom from modesty will not be won overnight.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoWhen your partner can't get it up because they've been abusing porn, you're incentivized to not like it just for personal reasons. And that's without even touching the fact that your partner is getting off to images of someone else. There's nothing "liberal" about porn. Porn is neither conservative nor liberal, it is libertine.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> When your partner can’t get it up because they’ve been abusing porn, you’re incentivized to not like it just for personal reasons. If your partner prefers interacting with porn to doing so with you, the porn use is a symptom, not the source of the problem.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoMaybe at first, but just like alcohol or any other addiction it becomes its own problem over time.
- account42 4y agoAnything enjoyable (and many things that are not even that) can be addicting and in some cases enought to be a problem. That however is not an argument for banning it altogether or that it is morally unacceptable. And most additictions really are just a symptom for other problems.
- kodah 4y ago
- bbarn 4y agoSimilar to legalized prostitution, this is where I often find myself at odds with my otherwise libertarian and personal freedom leaning beliefs. Should one be allowed to do with their body as they wish? In theory, yes, if it doesn't hurt others, but the reality is legalizing these things has a far greater capacity for harm at the hands of others who would exploit them.
- em-bee 4y agoisn't it the other way around? criminalizing prostitution taskes away options to seek help by those who are exploited or abused.
- bbarn 4y agoIt's already criminalized, so the only thing that could change is legalizing it or decriminalizing it. By legalizing it, you effectively add cost, or tax, and the illegal component continues to remain (unlesss you simply make it stop being illegal, and unregulated, which most people agree is a bad idea) and the market segregates the workers into legal and illegal workers. The illegal workers lives get even worse, and the legal workers end up losing a lot of their money. Look at legal marijuana, or hell, even legal prostitution in places that allow it and you'll see that's been the real effect.
- em-bee 4y agoBy legalizing it, you effectively add cost, or tax, and the illegal component continues to remain but that's the point, legalizing or decriminalizing the actual act enables the people involved to seek protection from the illegal components. Look at legal marijuana, or hell, even legal prostitution in places that allow it and you'll see that's been the real effect at least in germany the opposite effect seems to be the case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_Act "Sexual acts in the context of a prostitution contract are now valid to establish claims for compensation since the law came into force. This has not only significance for civil law, but also criminal law (property offences). In addition, prostitutes can now regularly insure in the statutory health, unemployment and pension insurance." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitutes_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitutes_Protection_Act "effective protection for prostitutes is only possible if this work is legalised" in addition to that, the issue i see is, how much control is necessary to enforce a ban on prostitution. i would argue that it is not possible without a serious reduction of personal freedom. legalizing it enables to focus the control on those engaged in such activities whereas the rest of us won't be bothered.
- bongobingo1 4y ago> Results for this Gallup poll are based on telephone interviews conducted May 1-10, 2018, with a random sample of 1,024 adults, aged 18 and older, living in all 50 U.S. states and the District of Columbia. For results based on the total sample of national adults, the margin of sampling error is ±4 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. > Each sample of national adults includes a minimum quota of 70% cellphone respondents and 30% landline respondents, with additional minimum quotas by time zone within region. Landline and cellular telephone numbers are selected using random-digit-dial methods. https://news.gallup.com/poll/235280/americans-say-pornography-morally-acceptable.aspx?g_source=link_NEWSV9&g_medium=NEWSFEED&g_campaign=item_&g_content=More%2520Americans%2520Say%2520Pornography%2520Is%2520Morally%2520Acceptable https://news.gallup.com/poll/235280/americans-say-pornograph... Dunno about you but I never answer unknown numbers, and neither does any of my friends, or anyone in my age bracket that I know, or anyone younger (gen z), so ... "Older Americans say they dislike pornography" is hardly surprising to me. If you look at the demographic break downs its only getting more acceptable.
- rayiner 4y agoLook—if you’re going to use the phrase “moral minority” you should be prepared to address polling on the issue from a reputable polling agency. If you look at the demographic breakdowns, almost all the movement is among younger men. Among women 18-49, it’s only 41% approval.
- snvzz 4y agoShould be legal? would be a far more relevant question. E.g. I won't do drugs, I do not like people who do drugs, yet I'm all for regulation.
- LorenPechtel 4y ago?? Did you state the end of it backwards? I don't do drugs, I don't like drugs, but I think the drug war is worse than the drugs.
- snvzz 4y agoRegulation as opposed to prohibition.
- cat_plus_plus 4y ago[flagged]
- throwwwaway69 4y agoYou can’t be serious. We need porn to stop ugly men from raping women? I’m pro ethical pornography. But still this is a weird argument for it. The only argument that matters is whether the person making pornography is consenting to it and isn’t being taken advantage of. That second part is very tricky with a very wide spectrum of opinions.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoYou still has not explained your alternative plan and how it is going to scale in current society. Rape is an extreme case, there are also drunk (but not drugged/passed out) one night stands and men lying about their intentions/finances/etc. Isn't it better that the woman at least gets paid in an honest transaction? Speaking of drunk, few would argue that booze is an overall benefit to society, but we tried prohibition and saw how that turned out. So yes, adulting can include accepting unpleasant truths and choosing the lesser evil.
- thrwaway0987 4y agoThere is good evidence that legalized sex work in the form of porn, prostitution, strip clubs, etc. reduce the incidence of sex crimes. For instance: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328512426_The_Effect_of_Adult_Entertainment_Establishments_on_Sex_Crime_Evidence_from_New_York_City https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328512426_The_Effec...
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoProstitutes get physically assaulted an average of once a month. That's without factoring in pressure to engage in sex acts they aren't comfortable with. And the death rate is about 1 in 500 per year. https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/prostitution-in-the-united-states-30997 https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/prostitution-in-the-united... Are these crimes against prostitutes factored in to the total incidence of sex crimes? I just briefly looked at your link and can't tell. We're potentially dealing with a "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" situation here.
- onetimeusename 4y agoEven if you dislike porn, how would pushing for restrictions on it work? If you ban the production/distribution of it, it will move to places where those are tolerated. If you place restrictions on possession of material, it would have free speech implications that I don't think are trivial. Sure, we don't have absolute free speech but then there would be a debate about what porn is and the worst part of this is there is enough porn out there already that a lot of people would become felons once banned. It could even be weaponized to destroy websites where users can host content. Porn detectors would probably have to scan everything and there would be a non-zero false positive rate. If you use the internet to restrict it, you're creating this powerful device the government has to censor the internet. I think this last one is something the government is very very interested in having. It's just hard to see how any of this would improve people's lives even if you are totally opposed to porn.
- xyzzyz 4y ago> If you ban the production/distribution of it, it will move to places where those are tolerated. This is a fully general argument against banning anything at all. Nevertheless, we ban things, and moreover, we do not seem to act as if act of banning is meant to be pointless charade. We ban smoking in many public places, we ban possession of weapons by felons, or carrying them without a license in many places. We ban selling alcohol to minors, and we ban kids from driving a car. These measures are highly successful, they resulted in great reduction of the banned activity, and most people would oppose lifting this bans. In other words, the answer to the question “how banning porn would work?” is “very effectively, like most other things that government bans and actively enforces”.
- onetimeusename 4y agoMy point was that a ban on content distribution/production via the internet will require heavy handed measures to be effective. The cost of regulating the internet is relatively high. The ban on minors drinking alcohol is illustrative. You must now produce a state issued ID. You must show your ID containing personal information to a stranger. Your data may be recorded as many stores require scanning the ID and for you to input your birthday. Now a profile has been created about what your private purchases are. Likewise, on the internet, for a ban to be effective, heavy handed measures will have to be implemented. For example, a legal apparatus for effective policing and enforcement will grow in power against citizens, edge nodes of a country's internet border will be monitored, personal information and identity will be stored and tracked, etc. The internet has many uses so even if you do not like porn, I think a porn ban specifically will adversely effect people's free speech rights. That is not necessarily true for other types of bans.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoPlease link the real information: https://news.gallup.com/poll/235280/americans-say-pornography-morally-acceptable.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/235280/americans-say-pornograph... And note the breakdown by religion--most of the opposition to pornography is religious-based.
- rayiner 4y ago> And note the breakdown by religion--most of the opposition to pornography is religious-based. What does that matter? The objection to pornography among religious people isn’t rooted in the supernatural or doctrinal aspects of religion. It’s not like mixing fabrics or eating shellfish. If you broke down the results by different religions, I suspect you’d find that Hindus and Muslims and Christians are all pretty opposed to pornography. What you’re really talking about is moral philosophy. Do you believe that society should prioritize individual self expression and satisfaction, or collective duty and family formation? These are correlated with, but separable from, supernatural religious beliefs.
- nnf 4y ago> What does that matter? It matters because we have a secular government, so we don’t make laws based on people’s religious beliefs, no matter how popular those beliefs may be. Religious people are welcome to live by whatever set of rules their books dictate, as long as doing so doesn’t infringe on other people’s rights. But they are not welcome to apply their religious restrictions to everyone else.
- positus 4y agoJohn Adams: “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious People. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”
- krapp 4y agoIt's now the Year of our Lord 2023, we can (and should) move on from the outdated premise that morality requires a belief in God (as nonreligious people are no more or less moral than religious people) and that government presupposes it, just as we moved on from the premise that black people are property.
- jstarfish 4y ago> About 43% of people find pornography morally acceptable: https://www.nationalreview.com/news/gallup-poll-majority-of- https://www.nationalreview.com/news/gallup-poll-majority-of-.... I suspect that the majority of parents don’t. It’s only 53% among Democrats. Nobody ever addresses the middle ground...the group of parents who have no objection to adults' use of it but believe it's not something that the developing minds of children should have unfettered access to.
- account42 4y agoAnd that's a fine position as long as those parents take responsibility for ensuring their children don't have access to things they don't want them to have access to. It's not fine if it means they want the state to restrict access for everyone.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoThat's why technological arguments of "you and which army?" or "porn is illegal? so is piracy. Hasn't stopped that either." are more important than appeals to the democratic process for these types of issues.
- thephyber 4y agoI think your parent was expressing frustration that so many laws are dressed in the sheepskin of “WON’T SOMEBODY THINK OF THE CHILDREN?!?!” I don’t think the commenter necessary would disagree that many parents _do_ want to protect children, but that so much of the electorate turns off their critical thinking skills when that sheepskin is used. They don’t seem to remain skeptical that the law could actually be a wolf in sheep’s clothing. Or maybe I’m just projecting…
- commoner 4y agoIn the same 2018 Gallup poll that your National Review article referenced, only 10% of people in the U.S. believe that married men and women having an affair is morally acceptable, and only 42% of people in the U.S. believe sex between teenagers is morally acceptable, but it would be ridiculous to ban these things through law because the government should not be intruding into citizens' private lives in this way. https://news.gallup.com/poll/235250/say-consuming-alcohol-marijuana-morally.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/235250/say-consuming-alcohol-ma... Also, the proportion of people who find hate speech morally acceptable is likely much lower than 43%, yet that is still protected in the U.S. by the First Amendment. An activity needs to be more than merely "morally unacceptable" to some people to justify banning it through legislation. You must also consider the infringement of personal liberties that a ban on that activity would cause, the resulting collateral damage, and whether the ban is practically enforceable. Prohibition was unsuccessful in the U.S. even at a time when the temperance movement triggered a wave of anti-alcohol sentiment because there were enough people who rejected the belief that others should be able to restrict their liberties based on different opinions on what is morally acceptable.
- rayiner 4y ago[flagged]