5 ms·
Why a raffle and not an auction? Auctions are the standard way to find a price that balances supply and demand. (Give poor people money, if you think they nee
by eru 4y ago
Why a raffle and not an auction?
Auctions are the standard way to find a price that balances supply and demand.
(Give poor people money, if you think they need the help. No need to decide for them what is best for them by giving them help in the form of tickets. Are you afraid they'll buy booze instead?)
- xnorswap 4y agoAuctions are terrible because of the uneven distribution of wealth. You end up with a situation where the wealthy can do everything and the poor can do nothing. And then there's the super rich, who could buy out the possibility of anyone else participating, literally turning such places into their private playground for eternity if they so wished. Like, what price could you price it at where: 1. You could afford to go occassionally 2. Elon Musk couldn't just buy out every single ticket for the next decade to make it their personal playground. There's simply no feasible solution to that. Just auctioning everything and letting capitalism take its course just denies a vast segment of society from participating at all for activities where demand outstrips supply. Supply & Demand only works if supply can be increased, so that as prices rise there's incentive for greater supply. For things like National Parks or Taylor Swift concerts, price discovery through "supply and demand" does not work because supply can't increase to match supply no matter the price.
- eru 4y agoGive poor people money, if you want to help them. Giving them a park ticket is equivalent to giving them the auction price for the ticket but restricting them to use it on park tickets. Very condescending and paternalistic. > Supply & Demand only works if supply can be increased, so that as prices rise there's incentive for greater supply. No? Where did you get that idiosyncratic notion from? Auctions work just fine for eg van Gogh paintings, and they have been in decidedly fixed supply since 1890. Auctions also work well for things that are in fixed demand. Of course, in that case you have suppliers bid, not buyers. You can also have a two-sided auction where both suppliers and buyers bid.
- unionpivo 4y ago> Give poor people money, if you want to help them. Giving poor people money will not help the situation. How much money do you need to give to a family, that would want to have a picnic over the weekend, so that Bill Gates and Elon Musk and others, could not outbid them. Yeah wont happen in real world. I wont assume bad faith from you, but generally speaking saying just give them money is a huge copout. > Auctions work just fine for eg van Gogh paintings, and they have been in decidedly fixed supply since 1890. Glad you brought that up. Van Goh sold his paintings and owners of such paintings then sell them on auctions etc. There are people in the art world who would argue that such paintings do belong in Museums, so that public can enjoy them. So they band together and collect money so that their local museum can afford to buy such Van Goh painting. After such painting are displayed in Museum where anyone can view them, for a fixed price, that generally covers the upkeep. Which is the same situation as here. there is a public park (that is by definition there to be used by the public), that sells tickets, that should cover the upkeep. But since the demand is too high, it sometimes need to raffle them. Auctions would defeat the purpose.
- eru 4y ago> Giving poor people money will not help the situation. How much money do you need to give to a family, that would want to have a picnic over the weekend, so that Bill Gates and Elon Musk and others, could not outbid them. And that's why Bill Gates and Elon Musk bid on and win all ebay auctions ever? Whenever a house goes for sale, they snatch it up, too. Don't they? /s Basically, the same forces that make the paragraph above untrue, would also be at work here. > Which is the same situation as here. there is a public park (that is by definition there to be used by the public), that sells tickets, that should cover the upkeep. But since the demand is too high, it sometimes need to raffle them. If demand is so high, then a poor person who wins a ticket in a raffle is better off selling the ticket in the secondary market (to Bill Gates perhaps) and enjoying the money. Naturally, you can forbid poor people from reselling their ticket to prevent that. We all know they would only use the proceeds for booze, wouldn't they? /s
- unionpivo 4y ago
- Sankozi 4y agoNot sure how you come up with point 1 when talking about auctions of a very limited resource. Lets focus on the point 2. You are vastly overestimating buying power of the richest people. Lets assume that some of them are really irrational and want to buy access to the single place by selling whole their wealth. X entries per day, 365 day in a year, that is 3650*x tickets to buy out to cover 10 years. Musk wealth: 171 000 000 000 Divided by 3650 = 46 849 315 If we sell only 50 tickets daily it is less than million of $ that Musk have available for each ticket. There is over 60 million people with wealth higher wealth than that. (https://www.statista.com/statistics/203930/global-wealth-distribution-by-net-worth/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/203930/global-wealth-dis...). If park increases number of tickets to 500 daily (~21 per hour) then we are talking about 600 million richest people that can try to outbid Musk on a single ticket. In reality people like Musk probably would never spend even 1/100 of their wealth for any single attraction. If they had, they would not be that rich. Additionally park could easily increase number of tickets if those are not used.
- HWR_14 4y ago> If we sell only 50 tickets daily it is less than million of $ that Musk have available for each ticket. Wow, and for anyone else for only a million dollars people can buy an entire day in what was once a free federal location! Meanwhile, let's look at Yellowstone. Over a decade, they will sell about $110MM in passes (just a 10x of what they generated recently.) Let's say at an auction the passes go for an average of 20x that. So for $2.2 billion, someone can buy exclusive access to a 2.2 million acre federal park for a decade. A 20x multiple is pretty high too. > reality people like Musk probably would never spend even 1/100 of their wealth for any single attraction. Musk spent approximately 20% of his wealth on an internet toy.
- eru 4y agoSure. But he has only five twenty-percents to spend in total.
- et-al 4y agoIf all one cares about are that only their fellow millionaires get to savor some publicly-owned campsites, then sure that's a great solution.
- eru 4y agoGive poor people money, if you think they need the help. No need to decide for them what is best for them by giving them help in the form of tickets. Giving them a ticket is equivalent to giving them money, but restricting it be spent on park tickets only. Very condescending and paternalistic, isn't it? Are you afraid they are going to spend their ticket money on booze?
- olivermuty 4y agoThis argument is nonsensical unless you suggest the tickets should be sellable. False equivalent argumentation. Edit: Excellent idea to give poor people money either way though. UBI!
- eru 4y agoYes, of course, the tickets should re-sellable. Naturally, you could ban poor people from reselling their ticket. On the grounds that 'we know better' than them that they really need their ticket, instead of the thousand dollar they could get for it on the secondary market. They'll probably just spend it on booze! /s
- unionpivo 4y agoNot from USA, but my opinion on raffles vs auctions: Raffle is not giving them money. Raffle is giving them a chance. No matter how much money you give to poor people, rich people will always be able to afford to outbid them. So sure, giving money to poor people (or better jet, making sure they get decent pay in the first place) is good idea. And raffle makes sure, prices stay reasonable so that even poor/middle class people can on occasion enjoy the parks. You do auctions when you want to maximize profit. You do raffles when you need to rate limit access to a limited resource.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lukas099 4y agoThis would be politically unviable. Just look at responses to your comment.
- eru 4y agoIndeed. Though that doesn't mean it's a bad idea. You know how eg abolishing slavery or letting women vote was once politically unviable.