7 ms·
For me, the most frustrating part of our legal system is the bastardization of jury trials. The entire point of a jury trial is to let a group of peers decide
by _heimdall 4y ago
For me, the most frustrating part of our legal system is the bastardization of jury trials.
The entire point of a jury trial is to let a group of peers decide whether they were willing to punish a citizen for the crime they were committed of. Laws come down to moral opinion, and jury trials are a way for the public to answer the question of what the general moral opinion of the time is. The jury decides (a) was a law broken, (b) dotthey agree with the law, and (c) are they willing to punish someone for it. This creates case law and ultimately should impact laws on the books - if people continue to acquit convictions because the crime isn't worth punishing, eventually the law should be changed.
Instead lawyers and judges have done an extremely effective job flipping the tables and telling juries their only job is to read a list of laws the court deemed relevant, hear evidence the court deemed important, and decide if the logic between fact and law holds true. Juries are pushed to consider only the statutes in question as written and aren't expected or asked to consider for themselves if the crime is something they even think matters.
- dclusin 4y agoJury nullification doesn’t exactly have a spotless history. Although I do agree with the sentiment.
- _heimdall 4y agoThe legal system itself doesn't have a spotless history. I just don't see the point in a hurry trial if we aren't asking representatives of the community to weigh in on the law and punishment itself. If all we want is a system where legal statues are presented and evidence is compared against it, we really don't need a jury at all and might as well let the judge or OpenAI decide on what if basically boiled down to a mathematical equation.
- js2 4y ago> Juries are pushed to consider only the statutes in question as written and aren't expected or asked to consider for themselves if the crime is something they even think matters. Doing otherwise is known as nullification and you'll never sit on a jury if you even imply you know such a thing exists. Here's Paul Newman's character in the The Verdict arguing for it though: https://www.americanrhetoric.com/MovieSpeeches/moviespeechtheverdict.html https://www.americanrhetoric.com/MovieSpeeches/moviespeechth... (The movie is well worth watching and pairs well with 12 Angry Men, both directed by Sidney Lumet.)
- _heimdall 4y agoIts lower on my list of complaints of the legal system, but I also don't like the jury selection process itself. Juries are meant to be a random sampling of peers in the community, jury selection gamifies that process and muddied the water.
- Pet_Ant 4y agoA random selection of citizens can get 12 KKK members on the jury for the murder of a black man. I mean this isn't just supposed to be mob rule, this is supposed to be impartial people applying the established law. The input for opinion comes when voting for the legislature.
- _heimdall 4y agoIt sure can, the legal system will never be perfect though I'd seriously question where you live if there's any feasible chance of randomly selecting an entire jury of KKK members What is the point of a jury in your opinion, if not to act as a check on the legal system itself? If all we want is a list of the current laws as written and someone to compare evidence against it as a checklist, why bother adding potential inaccuracies by asking a jury of people who aren't trained in the law?
- Pet_Ant 4y ago> What is the point of a jury in your opinion, if not to act as a check on the legal system itself? The check on the legal system is appealing to the higher courts. They can strike down laws that are against the constitution. Trials aren't referendums. > If all we want is a list of the current laws as written and someone to compare evidence against it as a checklist, why bother adding potential inaccuracies by asking a jury of people who aren't trained in the law? To avoid the consolidation of power in the hands of a few deciders. Especially as the deciders may come from a certain section of society (eg upper-class educated, and thus may unduly disregard the poor) they may have incentives or biases or connections that may influence their impartiality of their evaluation.
- arcastroe 4y agoInteresting. If you google "jury nullification", google provides a helpful "answer" at the very top > There is no such thing as valid jury nullification[.] You would violate your oath and the law if you willfully brought a verdict contrary to the law given to you in this case. However, the link this is sourced from paints a very different picture. Right after those two sentences, the source says: > the Kleinman court found [these] two sentences to be error because they suggested that nullification could be punished and that an acquittal resulting from nullification would be invalid. Seems google didn't do a good job at providing a helpful summary of jury nullification.
- amatecha 4y agoYeh I mean as a general rule, probably don't read algorithmically-generated summaries of any content, ever. It's never going to be a good idea to rely on software to try to contextualize human-written text. Unless you like arbitrary falsehoods and misinformation sprinkled into half of your beliefs/thoughts, I guess.
- Brian_K_White 4y agoThe error is not that someone read what google presented. The error is that google presented something wrong.
- birdyrooster 4y agoBoth?
- amatecha 4y agoYeah agree with sibling comment: both. Never trust a machine, an algorithm, a piece of software. Maybe unless it has been built to extremely stringent specifications that are publicly available and verifiable -- which is blatantly not the case for proprietary closed-source search engines.
- 93po 4y agoLawyers I know are very anti jury nullification and they claim it's for well rationed reasons (that I don't recall) and not just group think in that it makes the lives of lawyers more difficult. I tend to want to believe them, but at the same time find our justice and punishment system horrific and sort of don't care if JN isn't ~theoretically~ the best thing to do in our legal system
- anonymousab 4y ago> if people continue to acquit convictions because the crime isn't worth punishing, eventually the law should be changed That idea kinda falls apart on areas that are or were particularly racist. When folks were consistently getting away with all sorts of crimes because of the color of their skin and consistent color of their victim's skin, deriving law from "the general moral opinion of the time" doesn't work.
- _heimdall 4y agoOh I'm in no way trying to imply that the legal system is unbiased or could be simply by juries approaching trials differently. As far as I see it, laws are entirely based on moral opinion and that itself is always going to be biased. The best we could do is have a set of laws that represents the majority moral opinion for any topic codified into law (or don't have the law at all). History is is full of examples where the majority moral opinion was bigoted, unfortunately.
- BurningFrog 4y agoThe (even) bigger problem is that almost no one gets a jury trial these days. From memory, 96% of cases are decided by plea bargaining.
- stuaxo 4y agoThink plea bargaining is just the US?
- gumby 4y agoWhere else is it used? In some countries it’s considered a human rights violation because of the asymmetry of power.
- arrowsmith 4y agoThe site that I linked to in my other comment [0] claims that "No other country [than the USA] on earth incarcerates so many people without trial. While many countries around the world have rushed to adopt American style plea bargaining in recent years, not a single one uses it for such a large portion of cases." If you follow the sources it takes you to this 80-page report, which I haven't read, but I assume the numbers are in there: https://www.fairtrials.org/articles/publications/the-disappearing-trial/ https://www.fairtrials.org/articles/publications/the-disappe... [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35814578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35814578
- arrowsmith 4y ago98% of people currently incarcerated in the U.S. have not had a trial. In fact, around 25% of them haven't even been convicted of a crime as they're being held in pre-trial detention (usually a misnomer because, as mentioned, most of them will make a plea bargain before going to trial.) This website has a really great visualisation of the U.S. prison population: https://mkorostoff.github.io/incarceration-in-real-numbers/ https://mkorostoff.github.io/incarceration-in-real-numbers/ And see here for its sources: https://github.com/MKorostoff/incarceration-in-real-numbers/blob/master/SOURCES.md https://github.com/MKorostoff/incarceration-in-real-numbers/...
- dguest 4y agoI'm not a lawyer (would love to hear a more professional take) but I think this is vaguely related to the Common Law vs Roman Law divide. The main difference is how they handle ambiguity in the law: Common (US, UK): research past cases -> argue based on precedent -> build new precedent Roman (most of Continental Europe): research law -> argue based on law -> amend laws to avoid ambiguity Under Roman Law precedent plays a much smaller role. This also means there's a lot less riding on any given case, since judges aren't bound to follow the decisions of past courts. What comes along with it is a need for very clean cut laws. They accomplish mostly the same thing, with the critical difference that under common law you need ready access to past case law to have any fighting chance. Unfortunately, while technically public information, most good case law databases are behind very expensive subscription fees that only make sense if you're a lawyer. So my take (again, not a lawyer, would love to hear how this picture is incomplete or outright wrong) is that the US legal system will remain biased against the poor until there's either: - heavy public investment in free case law databases, or - a shift toward a less ambiguous legal code (i.e. Roman Law) which is comprehensible to ordinary people
- stareatgoats 4y agoThe two systems may accomplish much the same thing, but over the years I've come to realize how much the divide between Common vs Roman law influences not only the respective legal frameworks but the political systems right down to things like personal, life philosophy. But the distinction is rarely discussed, and the situation across Europe is not helped by everyone thinking we must have a Common law system (since that's what we see on TV). It probably like discussing Arsenal vs Liverpool to try and compare the two systems; one tends to like the home team. But since you extoll the virtues of Roman law I have to submit: it is in my view afflicted by some variant of naïve realism [0], the notion that one can capture the many-faceted reality in script, and then apply it across board. There is very little room for interpretation regarding the circumstances: the rules rule. Which can lead to absurd situations in the extreme, i.e. the case where a bus driver was deemed to be in the right (followed the rules) when he dumped a 6-year old in the middle of no-where because he didn't have a ticket (example from Sweden). In that regard a Common law system is preferable in my view. But in all honesty, both systems are imperfect, and would probably benefit from some sort of blending. And yea - perhaps not so lawyer dependent. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Na%C3%AFve_realism_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Na%C3%AFve_realism_(psychology...