3 ms·
> we need to work on fusing all the factor-types into a single strong 3-factor auth Would this not make logging into things three times more painful? Even just
by JohnFen 4y ago
> we need to work on fusing all the factor-types into a single strong 3-factor auth
Would this not make logging into things three times more painful? Even just using 2FA is a pain right now.
- Phemist 4y agoThis is another hot take, the word factor is overloaded (by marketing people) to be really confusing. The three factors of auth are categories / types. TOTP, password-entry into a form, biometric presentation, etc are _measures_. Sometimes the first measure is not sufficient, because it only implements one factor-type (e.g. the secret knowledge password), and a second measure that like TOTP is necessary which proves possession of something to a degree. The time between proving one measure and then the next 2"F"A measure allows many shenanigans (e.g. social engineering to get me to send a TOTP code to my down-on-his-luck "son"). What I am professing is a focus on measures where proof of all three factor types happens at the same time. PIN codes as entered to unlock a private key on a smartcard, which is then used to sign some other thing, would be one example of a 2-factor measure. Another is FaceID/TouchID (on-device matching). But 3-factor measures are not impossible - e.g., take also the keystroke dynamics into account of a password being entered on a specific device, apple could implement "KeystrokeID". Other options can exist, it just takes some creativity to think of how a secret behaviour can be encoded into a biometric modality that is then only understood by a specific device..