5 ms·
Is ChatGPT Securities Fraud?
- clnq 4y agoIs the free media securities fraud? Is free speech securities fraud? Is sharing an opinion about a company securities fraud?
- helsinkiandrew 4y agoYes if the opinion was formed from an illegal or unethical activity or you use information that others don't due to your role etc.
- villgax 4y agoFair use training, then BS ToS on fair output usage. Then using the funding to intimidate GitHub repo owners for banal stuff. It's like Google or AWS telling you that you can't use their API/compute to train a competing Speech-to-Text model lol
- nivenkos 4y ago"Open"AI
- hombre_fatal 4y agoHacker News? More like "Hacker" "News" amirite guys?! XD This quip is so trite and boring. We have to come up with something more scathing than this. I'm begging us.
- rzzzt 4y agoOpen "AI"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- villgax 4y agoWe're beyond their company name/work relation or even the non-profit to profit turn over. We're pissed at them willy nilly scraping the internet citing fair use for something which is neither research nor itself governed under fair use when they want to limit how people use the outputs or share the outputs with another 3rd party. Just like how Facebook wanted a partial internet, these guys want to screw over the rest of similarly
- dan-g 4y agoI see “Securities Fraud” in the title, I know it’s a Matt Levine article before I even click (Matt famously likes to show that everything is securities fraud in his newsletter)
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoThe "insider trading" question brought up in the first paragraph got me thinking. I suspect it's been asked before (it's just a rehash of "is ChatGPT copyright infringement?") but it's the first I'd heard it. > Will some ChatGPT-style large language model manage to do some insider trading? Will it, like, ingest some corpus of data that includes inside information, and then use it to answer questions like “which stocks should I buy?” But yeah, this "everything is securities fraud" thing is... also interesting, let's say. It's a weird manifestation of Poe's law. I can't tell if such lawyers "drank the kool-aid" or not.
- senko 4y agoThis is about ChatGPT (or AI in general) disrupting other companies, not about OpenAI (or ChatGPT) being a fraud. Relevant quote: The most immediate way in which ChatGPT is going to be securities fraud is the usual “everything is securities fraud” way: 1. ChatGPT is going to be disruptive to some number of businesses and industries. 2. Some companies will lose money because ChatGPT disrupts their business. 3. This will be bad, for them, and their stocks will drop. 4. Every bad thing that happens to a public company can be characterized as securities fraud: “You didn’t sufficiently warn us about the bad thing, so we bought the stock thinking it was good, but then the bad thing happened and the stock dropped, so we were defrauded.”
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoI suspect there will be companies touting AI or GPT types of things seeking investment. Some of these are likely to turn out to be fraudulent without any such technology being used, this type of thing happens with every tech hype cycle. It would be super helpful for the industry to have some independently created and peer reviewed (under NDA if necessary) stages of AI or terminology that can and cannot be used in various ways. Without this I expect to see a bunch of "GPT", "bot" and "AI" terms thrown about for years when under the hood none of those things are used and people just used the words to get traction.
- senko 4y agoThis has always been the case. During the dotcom bubble, many companies added ".com" to their name just to benefit from the hype. During the crypto craze companies were peddling their crypto strategies left and right. Same with ESG. I don't think there will incentive enough to regulate it, as it's very hard to figure out how to regulate (there are tons of different AI approaches, it's a very broad term) and stretching the truth usually doesn't cause actual harm to people. The only counter-example I can think is food (process) labelling, where terms like "organic", "bio" or "halal" are regulated.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoYeah and all the ICO's as well. I'm not suggesting Government regulation, they move too slowly and barely understand technology. I think the leading AI firms would be best to create some standards body to come up with definitions and certifications about usage, ethics, etc. around the technology. Hire some lawyers and get independent trademarks or whatever that can only be granted by the standards body.
- evmar 4y agohttps://archive.is/x3AiC https://archive.is/x3AiC
- windex 4y agoPutting ChatGPT in the text is a surefire way to get a click. Bonus points if you ask a speculative question.