3 ms·
Well, that was better than I was expecting. Sokal's name raises my hackles. I don't believe his "hoax" was as informative as people like to imagine. The kind o
by jfengel 4y ago
Well, that was better than I was expecting.
Sokal's name raises my hackles. I don't believe his "hoax" was as informative as people like to imagine. The kind of postmodernism he was challenging is deliberately about exploring genuinely novel ideas that aren't easy to understand, and is thus easy prey for a deceptive credentialed person. He was tilting at a windmill of a tiny subset of people doing a different thing than he wanted them to be doing.
I still think he's missing the point of sociology. Sociology is not physics. It is an evolving field that is trying to describe the insane complexity of human relationships. It's no surprise that it doesn't have a fully solid epistemic grounding. Scientific revolutions occur because we spend time with one ontology and suddenly discover a new, better one -- which often comes with a rewriting of the epistemology of what can be known. It's hardly surprising that we don't have a fully formed epistemology of the human mind, much less of human social interactions.
Nonetheless, he is right to point out that the epistemology exists, and it's worth making it explicit. It's especially important in this age where deliberate falsehoods are spread, knowing that they are false, to people who choose to uncritically accept them. Race is one of many areas where people will defend their own racism, justified on grounds that are flagrantly false and which a moment's reflection would reveal that they cannot possibly have the information they believe they have.
I think this is, overall, a pretty good paper. But he's also very clear that it does not invalidate the fundamental thesis made in DiAngelo's book.
- at_a_remove 4y agoI saw an interesting flowchart someone had made (I am looking for it even now) about that book -- it pulled quotes from the book which demonstrating that the concept was a tautology, no null hypothesis. I reviewed the flowchart and thought, "Hey, this is a lot like those circular (but labyrinthine) arguments from the Christians about the Bible!"
- jfengel 4y agoThat's actually kinda the point of both the book and Sokal's analysis of it. It sounds as though you haven't read the book, but feel confident in your rejection based on somebody else's analysis presented in meme form. The book has a thesis on why you might feel so confident in the face of insufficient information. Sokal critiques some of the underlying epistemological questions of the insufficient information, how we come to accept or reject it.