41 ms·
Federal Reserve pushes interest rates above 5% for first time since 2007
- pfannkuchen 4y agoThis whole interest rate hike exercise and its obvious effects on various markets has really made the economy seem fake to me. How can one government committee have so much arbitrary decision making power over how hundreds of millions conduct business in this country? It’s extremely demotivating.
- phone8675309 4y agoIt's even more of a headscratcher when you realize that the Federal Reserve is not a government committee.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> It's even more of a headscratcher when you realize that the Federal Reserve is not a government committee. The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System is an executive branch agency whose Governors are appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate, just like members of other executive branch boards, commissions, and committees... [0] The Federal Reserve System itself is a weird public/private hybrid thing, but the System doesn’t set monetary policy, the Board does. [0] hence, e.g., its inclusion here: https://www.loc.gov/rr/news/fedgov.html https://www.loc.gov/rr/news/fedgov.html
- standyro 4y agoImagine if the US Congress or the President was in charge of these decisions. To me, anyway, it's more calming. Haha.
- MacsHeadroom 4y agoImagine if the market was in charge of these decisions.
- brianwawok 4y agoHow would you prefer to do it? Like China?
- sfe22 4y agoWhy someone has to fix it for others. Can we let people decide for themselves?
- koolba 4y agoNo bank is obligated to use the Fed system. Unless you want to process a Fed wire or ACH. Or you want FDIC insurance. Or you want to offer banking services to consumers. Or you want access ti the Fed window for short term liquidity. But if you put those aside and somehow manage to get a bank charter, you could totally eschew the Fed. Now if you do play in their ballpark you have to play by their rules. And a big one there is the rate that you’ll get on short term deposits. And given the scale it implicitly sets the pace for interbank rates as they have to directly compete with the Fed.
- pfannkuchen 4y ago“No one is forcing you to buy bread from the government run nickel bread company, you are free to start your own company and charge whatever you like. If others choose to buy the government’s bread for a nickel, well, hey, that’s just the free market for you.”
- gameman144 4y agoThis is the government's interest rate for lending to banks. What would people deciding for themselves look like in this case?
- sfe22 4y agoI don’t think the (us) government is lending to the banks, it is already on close to trillion dollar deficit, if anything it is borrowing from banks. “People” in my comment includes groups of people too (eg companies, governments). Shouldn’t one be able to set the price of borrowing, why we must have one party deciding for everyone else.
- mindslight 4y agoThe arbitrary centrally-planned foundation of the economy has been clear to those paying attention on the way down, as rates were repeatedly lowered further and further over decades for one political purpose or another. What has surprised me is that the Fed did end up having the will to raise rates a decent amount. So it seems the Fed actually has been following their technocratic mandate, just with horribly broken criteria based around consumer price inflation - horribly broken because the real price of manufactured goods should have been dropping significantly due to offshoring and technological progress, but the Fed's feedback loop created enough new money so they couldn't (hence the ever-growing asset bubble). As a libertarian student of Austrian economics, seeing this play out is actually warming me up to Modern Monetary Theory - at least it means the newly created money gets directed to deliberate purposes (like sorely needed infrastructure), rather than just handed to banks in a mostly undirected manner while feigning austerity for everyone else.
- rightbyte 4y agoAll these rate hikes has made me understand how deeply manipulated the economy is. All these scary stories about the old left going to mess with the market ... It seems to me that the FED arbitrarily can manipulate the lowest return on money invested that is possible to get away with aswell as the highest rate you can expect to get on your money by some opaque banker only interest system. Like, how is printing money and givinging it to the poor any worse. Both are manipulation.
- dangerlibrary 4y ago> how is printing money and giving it to the poor any worse. You might be onto something. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_money
- rightbyte 4y agoMy gut feeling is that it is a bad idea too. But the defenders of the system do not bat an eye when the Fed pours helicopter money over the rich. The hypocrisy is maddening. It is so dishonest.
- gameman144 4y agoI can offer my perspective as someone who would probably be considered a "defender of the Fed" (definitely not government policy as a whole, though). Pouring helicopter money down is going to increase inflation, hands-down. Giving it to more people will increase inflation more than giving it to fewer people (since the competition for scarce goods will be more widely distributed), but it's just as bad giving helicopter money to the rich. Helicopter money is largely fiscal policy (i.e. how do we spend our money) instead of monetary policy (i.e. how much money should there be, and how should it flow). I'll not defend fiscal policy, as I find that Congress often just tries to buy votes with money (the right with tax-cuts, the left with loan-forgiveness or entitlements). In terms of monetary policy, though, the Fed's responsibilities are to make the employment market and inflation stay at good levels. Manipulating the interest rate of bank lending does do that (albeit not nearly as much as it could if coupled with good fiscal policy). Raising the interest rate does reduce inflation, since there are fewer free-floating dollars to compete for good. It also does make the job market less hot, since there are fewer free-floating dollars to invest in businesses or employees. There's some deep hypocrisy in fiscal policy, but I think the Fed is doing what the Fed can do to keep jobs and inflation in balance.
- blitzar 4y agoThis whole interest rate cutting exercise and its obvious effects on various markets also really made the economy seem fake .... The period of 10 years where rates were 0%+/- with 2-3++% inflation was the fake economy 5% rates with 5% inflation is the real world.
- pfannkuchen 4y agoYes agreed, I don’t mean to suggest that “high rates bad, high rates fake”. The manipulation makes the economy (seem?) fake either way. With the low rates though IIRC things didn’t happen quite so fast, so the causality wasn’t so blatantly observable.
- greyw 4y agoCan you please elaborate what you mean by "fake" economy?
- qbasic_forever 4y agoThe idea that you will always be able to borrow money at no cost is pure fantasy. Except many, many start-ups and companies built business plans that could only work when they had a constant supply of free loans. A scooter rental startup for example could offer service for less than their operation costs because there was always a spigot of money to borrow.
- Workaccount2 4y agoThe fed has a dual mandate (Powell only repeats this 20-30 times during each press conference). Stable prices (2% inflation) and maximum employment. That dual mandate is what dictates policy. The recent string of rate hikes are not arbitrary, they are because of the surge in inflation flowing the extreme policies the fed took on the other end when unemployment was high during the pandemic. If anything the case to be made is that the fed went overboard with its QE during the pandemic, but even then its a bit of "hindsight is 20/20". I think everyone can agree that had this pandemic struck in 2000, even 2010 instead of 2020, the economic impact would have been dramatically greater than it was.
- elzbardico 4y agoThe US have maybe a few months to completely undo their stupid sanctions on the Russians and return their money or the de-dollarizarion movement will keep gaining steam and those bank failures will look like children’s play. There’s no way the USA can survive as a world power if they keep stupidly weaponizing the dollar and weakening its status as the world currency. How do people think we will keep our standards of living if we don’t have the world’s currency to allow us to keep our prosperity by having this massive trade deficit?
- uptownfunk 4y agoYou raise a valid point so don't know why you're being downvoted. A lot of my investors reallocated their portfolios when SVB happened to minimize risk due to dollar volatility. I think perhaps this runs counter to the mainstream woke narratives whenever russia comes up
- gameman144 4y agoI didn't downvote, but I think one reason is probably the repeated characterization of sanctions and Fed actions as "stupid", since that kind of puts things in an us-vs-them mindset. For instance, if I worked on a library and someone filed an issue saying "We need to remove the current networking implementation", I'd be interested to hear what they had to say. If someone said "We need to remove the current stupid networking implementation", I'd immediately be on the defensive (since presumably I had thought it was a good idea). When trying to make a point, it's important to leave room for people that don't already agree with you to be convinced (especially when most people don't already agree with you).
- douglasisshiny 4y agoCan you explain what you mean by dollar volatility?
- uptownfunk 4y agoSpecifically long term devaluation with respect to specific commodity classes.
- TinyRick 4y agoLots of uncertainty in the press conference following the interest rate announcement. Seems like the Fed is preparing for the possibility of more restrictive actions in the future, but is waiting for more data to see if such actions are needed. I expect the market to place a lot more weight on data released over the next few weeks.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoaka they might have to do 1 or 2 .25bps hikes within the next 6-12 months that originally weren’t telegraphed expectation wise, so stock market will need to moderately correct to the new balance of “expected versus actual”?
- hospitalJail 4y agoJust a perspective to share from someone trying to buy property for a small business(since most people think about it from a residential POV). Unlike residential mortgages, corporate loans are not fixed interest rates. They are all adjustable. What in 2020 seems financially sound, becomes impossible a few years later. I can't imagine how other companies do this, do you just make sure your business can handle 12% interest rates just incase a politician decides to give away free money for a few years? I come from (real) engineering, so everything is just math to me. However the adjustable interest rates is quite a wrench. Do I need to assume a 15% fed reserve interest rate + the 2-4% the bank piles on? Heck, 15% might be low, you never know. I imagine that all businesses would benefit from having some long term certainty. Maybe mid/large companies can raise money or get fixed loans, but I'm at the point where I need to use my feelings(ewwww) to make a decision.
- NationalPark 4y agoCan you hedge against it with interest rate swaps? It seems interest rate risk is probably one of the more manageable risks of a small business that is fundamentally dependent on other people's money - how do you know it's going to succeed in the first place even if rates don't increase?
- hospitalJail 4y agoInteresting, thank you and I will look into this. Engineer married a doctor who owns the clinic, no finance people in the family. The company is already doing great, we are just expanding. We have the past performance of the company, so we have an idea if we can afford a set monthly cost.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoRent some finance people. Get someone you can consult with on this stuff. There's almost certainly more pitfalls than we engineer types can logic out from what we know.
- lastofthemojito 4y ago
- htag 4y agoThis shows a level of confidence in the banking sector that I find questionable. Risks associated with raising bond interest rates were one of largest factors in the recent bank failures. Surely more bank failures would be seen as worse for the economy than inflation. If more, larger banks fail in the next twelve months then the Federal Reserve will be sheepish about raising interest rates for the next hundred years. In inflation stays high then it seems likely the Federal Reserve will keep pushing those interest rates higher and higher until something breaks and we enter crisis mode. Personally, I'd like to see Congress take more action to reduce inflation. Ideally I think the answer is some combination of raising taxes and reducing federal spending, to start to decrease the amount of cashflow. I think some activity on their front can have an impact without introducing the same types of banking risks associated with raising interest rates, and we'll see better results with less negative impact. Of course, given the contents of the Inflation Reduction Act this seems unlikely. The legislative and executive branches seem content to leave inflation to the Federal Reserve, as it absolves them of responsibility.
- ttul 4y agoInflation costs more than bank failures. The Fed can fix bank failures by providing liquidity on demand - without any limit, theoretically. But unless they tighten rates, inflation will just grow and make future tightening more urgent and less easy to control.
- TinyRick 4y ago> Surely more bank failures would be seen as worse for the economy than inflation. I disagree with this. Also keep in mind that the Fed has a dual mandate (price stability and maximum employment); they aren't guardians of the overall economy nor are the responsible for ensuring that banks don't fail. > Personally, I'd like to see Congress take more action to reduce inflation. 100% agree
- Yeahsureok 4y agoCongress has no electoral mandate to lower inflation, that's not their job. Using fiscal policy for inflation targeting is crude and horrendously slow.
- tsjackson 4y agoLots of smoke in the comments here. The Fed is doing what needs to create relative stability. Uncomfortable, but real. Demand is outstripping supply and prices are going up. The least painful option is raising interest rates. Alternatives are hyperinflation, (very bad), or various price fixing schemes (which have literally never worked despite many attempts and are even worse in the ultimate outcomes). There are lots of reasons why this is happening, and none of them are related to a "fake economy:" People and businesses came out of lockdown with saved money and basically free loans burning holes in their pocket which caused a spike in demand (Least important, probably no longer an issue) Businesses came out of lockdown with a diminished staff and a ton of new uncertainty (much more important, takes a while to recover for some businesses that are planning production multiple YEARS in advance). Deglobalization/ U.S. national re-industrialization, started by Trump, continued with Biden, which will increase prices on pretty much everything. This is both a reasonable response to the issue, and makes the issue worse in the short term. There's a hot war with a major energy producer, Russia, which will increase prices for every product where energy is an input (almost every product). The biggest manufacturer in the world, China, has randomly been shutting down factories and whole metropolises for weeks at a time for the last several years. We just got a correction in this regard, but it will take time for the supply side of the equation to ramp back up, especially given all of the moving parts and uncertainty outlined above. Bottom line - lean supply chains function well when everything is stable for a longish period of time and it looks like it will continue to be for a longish period of time. In unstable/uncertain environments, supply chains break down, and supply can't keep up with demand, and the government can't keep handing out free money without causing prices to hyperinflate.
- rightbyte 4y ago> The least painful option is raising interest rates. Alternatives are hyperinflation Why is this taken as a fact everywhere. Surely, interest rates is a zero sum game? I honestly don't understand.
- zie 4y agoInterest rates affect debt. The higher the interest rate(s) the less debt people are willing to take on. Debt is the lube that keeps the economic wheels spinning. If you can borrow for 5% but can make 20% return on that money, then you obviously are heavily incentivized to borrow at 5%. If you can borrow at 5% but can only make 6%, you are not really incentivized to borrow. This means less purchasing will happen, slowing down the economy. To think about it another way, which might help: borrowing is moving money from the future to today. To do that costs you something. The more it costs, the less likely you are to do it. Credit Cards move money from 30 days in the future to today without much cost(and in the US often incentivized with rewards/cash back, etc). As soon as 31 days happen, the cost to move that money forward in time is suddenly 20+%, making it ridiculous for anyone with a clue to borrow money on credit cards past 30 days. Mortgages move up your house purchase by up to 30 years. If it costs you a lot more to borrow today than it did a few years ago, you are much less likely to move up that purchase. The same is true for companies and everyone else. The more it costs to borrow, the less likely you are to borrow, decreasing spending today.
- babelthuap 4y ago[dead]