3 ms·
Certain people push this narrative that renewables cannot meet any need, basically at all, and are pushing that we should invest in nuclear instead, precisely b
by mrguyorama 4y ago
Certain people push this narrative that renewables cannot meet any need, basically at all, and are pushing that we should invest in nuclear instead, precisely because it is expensive and will go no where for quite some time so that fossil fuels continue to be needed for longer. It's intentionally done to try to handicap renewable energy progress.
- inkcapmushroom 4y agoRenewables have obvious deficiencies which are not resolved simply by having more of them. By shunning nuclear you choose to have fossil fuel power plants everywhere to keep the flow of power consistent and matching demand. Grid-level storage is just as much of an unsolved problem as affordable nuclear, but while getting nuclear costs down is a matter of iterating and improving existing technologies, grid-level storage will likely require brand new technologies which are far from guaranteed. At this point I don't think nuclear is the way; I think it's got too many hurdles and we don't have enough time to figure it out in a safe way, if we ever can get the costs down and improve safety at the same time. But it's undeniably attractive as a nearly carbon-free energy source. Deciding that anyone with a different opinion than yours on a complex topic must be some kind of shill for big oil is doing yourself a disservice.
- KennyBlanken 4y ago> By shunning nuclear you choose to have fossil fuel power plants everywhere to keep the flow of power consistent and matching demand. Nuclear is base load - it takes days to change power levels - and cannot be a substitute for fast-reacting power sources If I had a penny for every HNer who opens their mouth to pontificate about how turning off nukes means a less reliable grid or "we'll need fossil fuel plants to make the grid reliable", I'd be a very rich person.
- Ekaros 4y agoNope "modern" plants do it just fine. Something like 30-100% capacity is scalable at 5% a minute or over hundred Megawatts.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoDo that five times in one day then.