3 ms·
> If Google/Amazon/Apple/Meta/whoever locks your account out, you now lose access everywhere. Fortunately, both iOS and Android also support "detachable passke
by lxgr 4y ago
> If Google/Amazon/Apple/Meta/whoever locks your account out, you now lose access everywhere.
Fortunately, both iOS and Android also support "detachable passkeys" a.k.a. Yubikey and co. ("roaming authenticators" in WebAuthN/FIDO parlance).
Unfortunately, only Android is planning to offer [1] a first-party Passkey provider API, because that's what I'll probably be using 99% of the time (finding my external authenticator for every login is frustrating).
> Also, Passkey providers now get sweet sweet metadata about your accounts around the web.
To my knowledge, both Google's (for Android) and Apple's sync backends are end-to-end encrypted. I'm not sure if that includes the metadata as well as the private keys, though.
[1] https://developers.google.com/identity/passkeys/supported-environments https://developers.google.com/identity/passkeys/supported-en...
- signal11 4y ago> Fortunately, both iOS and Android also support "detachable passkeys" a.k.a. Yubikey and co That’s good to know. Although my concern would be, that’s really good for people who use YubiKeys, but regular people won’t, and they can then get bitten by account lockouts. Is there something regular users can do to use Passkeys (let’s say they use Google) and have some recourse if Google locks them out? Also, what happens if they use Android, have no other computing device (this is fairly common in some parts of the world), and their phone gets stolen?
- waboremo 4y agoPasskeys don't negate regular account recovery processes. Just as if you were to lose your password, you would have to talk to support.
- knallfrosch 4y agoRight now, the identity of an account is tied to knowledge of the email address and the password. Something you know. If you forget the password, you need access to the email account. With passkeys,the identity of the account is tied to either a BIGTECH account, or to physical devices. If BIGTECH locks you out or you lose access to all your physcial Yubikeys at the same time, you will never access the account tied to the passkeys again.