3 ms·
The madness is people in charge of nuclear facilities being able to cover up accidents with the complicity of governments. Windscale is now called Sellafield be
by anigbrowl 4y ago
The madness is people in charge of nuclear facilities being able to cover up accidents with the complicity of governments. Windscale is now called Sellafield because it had acquired such a bad reputation that the UK government decided to just give it a nicer name as a PR move. In addition to incidents described in OP's article, operators dumped ~200kg of plutonium into the Irish Sea in the 1950s, as well as other waste byproducts subsequently. These quantities are probably small enough not to present any great risk to life or local ecology, but using a small sea as a dumping ground without the agreement or even awareness of neighbors hardly builds confidence. There have also been numerous smaller scale incidents over the years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sellafield#Incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sellafield#Incidents
I'm pro-nuclear and share your optimism about small modern reactor designs. But any nuclear proposal that doesn't include safety and transparency as core values that take priority over all other considerations deserves to be rejected. There's a reason that people have grave doubts about the integrity of the nuclear industry, and it's not technical but social. There are way too many nuclear proposals that lead off with happy talk about the benefits, and defer discussion of safety, transparency, cost and so on until those issues are raised as objections. It's a PR strategy and I automatically distrust it, because that 'good vibes only' mindset is likely to embed itself in the subsequent management of the plant and lead to cover-your-ass style decision-making.
tl;dr I like nuclear technology, it's the operators I don't trust.