6 ms·
White House proposes 30 percent tax on electricity used for crypto mining
- derjanni 4y agoThanks for sharing this article! Do you think this proposed tax will significantly impact the profitability of crypto mining?
- hsnewman 4y agoOnly if you consider 30% significant.
- lockhouse 4y agoSpoiler: if they actually implement this and find a way to enforce it, the miners will just do it overseas.
- dragontamer 4y agoGood. Let them waste someone else's energy. USA is energy-constrained as it is, we don't need miners coming here wasting electricity for their insane project.
- runnerup 4y agoThat's probably a net benefit for the USA. The same people will still accrue the benefits of mining, but without stressing domestic infrastructure.
- ETH_start 4y agoI'm not a fan of Proof of Work mining now that a robust Proof of Stake consensus algorithm is fully operational in Ethereum, but if the Bitcoin mining operations stay in the US, their revenue will go toward funding the expansion of domestic infrastructure. It's clearly in US interests to keep mining domestic.
- klobuerste 4y ago[dead]
- siegfriedernst 4y ago[flagged]
- vorfahrt74 4y ago[dead]
- antalyagrill 4y ago[dead]
- tyingq 4y agoThat is probably the objective. Make it some other country's problem.
- chunk_waffle 4y agoWow, taxed based on how you use your computer huh? Doesn't sounds very American to me. What's next, taxed for fuzz testing? Taxed for using inefficient programming languages? FWIW I do not support the crypto space either, but if they want to use a computer to run an infinite loop for the end of time that's their business. Perhaps spending more effort on improving the power grid and using more renewable resources would be a better effort?
- chunk_waffle 4y agoUpon further reflection perhaps this is the most American thing that could be done... The folks who got in early and made millions in Crypto reaped the benefit but no new comers could ever realize the same potential because we've taxed the snot out of it. Closed that loop hole (not that I have much faith in crypto anyway.)
- localplume 4y ago[dead]
- bb88 4y agoNo. You're taxed on how you're using energy. We're also taxed on how we use money. If we buy an electric car, we (used to) get a tax break. You could see a tax break on energy used to charge an electric car, say.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> but if they want to use a computer to run an infinite loop for the end of time that's their business I don't see anything in this proposal that would prohibit running an infinite loop for the end of time.
- ulrashida 4y agoThe article suggests this tax is proposed for cryptocurrency mining firms.
- operatingthetan 4y agoIs there even that much crypto mining happening in the US anymore?
- missedthecue 4y agoUS mines more bitcoin than any other country. The big thing now is using natural gas from oil wells that are not connected to gas pipelines (it's not economical to connect them), so instead of flaring the gas off into the sky, they fuel a generator to power a bitcoin farm using essentially free electricity.
- jjtheblunt 4y ago> US mines more bitcoin than any other country. how do you know that? are there rankings somewhere? super curious
- ipaddr 4y agoWhat is the tax rate on free electricity?
- shadowgovt 4y ago"Value of that electricity, if purchased externally." https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanations-FY2024.pdf https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanati...
- stonemetal12 4y ago
- lockhouse 4y agoHow would you even enforce this? I think crypto is a huge waste of electricity but this is not the answer.
- Imnimo 4y agoI don't understand why this would be difficult to enforce? It's a tax on companies that are doing crypto mining, not on an individual running mining on their personal machine.
- lockhouse 4y agoSo would they tax all the electricity that company uses or just the electricity used for mining? The article isn’t very clear on the specifics.
- paxys 4y agoThe company has to declare it themselves. They can lie, but they can also get audited and caught. This is how all taxes work.
- lockhouse 4y agoOh the honor system, we tried that with all the COVID money that we threw around and people bought Corvettes with it. This is just a terrible, unenforceable idea. Say they do get audited, how do you prove how much electricity they used to mine crypto? Unless that company wires a meter directly to the circuit that powers their mining rigs, it will be a total guess.
- Imnimo 4y agoHow do you think any other taxes are enforced?
- dragontamer 4y agoWell, when someone opens up a Data-center in Texas or New York and buys a whole bunch of Antminers for BTC mining, I think it will be pretty darn obvious what's going on.
- skybrian 4y agoI imagine cloud vendors having a new checkbox: are you doing crypto mining? You can lie, but then you’re committing tax fraud in a way that should be easy to prove if they notice you. It’s the sort of thing they do in banking when they ask what a bank account is for.
- Mistletoe 4y agoBullish for Ethereum I guess, which has cut its electricity usage by 99.9% or something since switching to Proof of Stake.
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoI'm really tempted to buy some ETH at this point, and I'm a crypto skeptic who owns nothing. Smart move?
- bradjohnson 4y agoIf red hasn't come up in a while on a roulette table, is it a smart move to bet on red?
- ipaddr 4y agoIt's about 50-50 (minus 0 and double 00) regardless
- bradjohnson 4y agoI'm saying that any knowledge you think might tip the scales in one direction is inconsequential. You will lose money or gain money depending on the will of those with the most stake. It is never a "smart move" to invest in crypto. It is gambling. Maybe get a lady friend to blow on your mouse before you click buy.
- Mistletoe 4y agoNever a smart move? It's been the best performing asset like clockwork 3 out of every 4 years since inception, in time with the Bitcoin halving cycles. https://twitter.com/TimmerFidelity/status/1653114784257040384 https://twitter.com/TimmerFidelity/status/165311478425704038...
- bradjohnson 4y ago
- izzydata 4y agoWhat is the difference between computing crypto and something like Prime95 to discover new prime numbers?
- dragontamer 4y agoPeople using Prime95 aren't buying $Hundred-Million of electricity from the Texas Energy Grid during the snowstorm when everyone else was literally freezing and dying in their homes. The amount of electricity these miners are pulling is insane, and is beginning to affect their neighbors. Its about time we stopped putting up with it.
- izzydata 4y agoIf there isn't enough electricity to go around it makes sense to do something about it. It seems like the issue is about electricity distribution rather than the use of the electricity. If it is the scale that is the problem then other seemingly unimportant industries using a ton of electricity in a time of crises should maybe also be limited.
- ulrashida 4y agoCould you suggest a few unimportant, high energy consumption industries you had in mind? The IEA suggests the following: * Chemical manufacturers * Steelmaking * Paper mills * Refineries Industrial crypto mining is not in good company here.
- izzydata 4y agoMaybe so, but I'm mainly suggesting that such a law be written a way that targets any large scale and wasteful use of electricity rather than being so specific to crypto. Even if that means crypto is the only thing currently affected. I don't like the idea of a law deciding what you can and can't compute or that some other wasteful industries get a free pass.
- 4y ago
- everdrive 4y agoI’d be happier with a 99% tax on crypto mining, however I don’t see how this could enforced.
- shadowgovt 4y agoAt present, there are companies in negotiation with various landowners to set up mining rigs on otherwise-disused natural gas wells. The wells are too far off the beaten path to be economical to run (some gas sources aren't revenus-positive when you factor in transportation), but building out a small crypto-mining shack next to the well and a small refiner and generator is pretty straightforward, and bits can be transported at a fraction of the cost of gas molecules. That sort of thing would be trivial to tax with this system, because if you're going to build one of these rigs you have to maintain paperwork with the state to open the well (and if you don't, the EPA does independent monitoring and will eventually say "Hey, what's this huge plume of heated exhaust showing up on infrared coming from this farmer's back-acre?").
- djoldman 4y agoActual text of proposal: ... Any firm using computing resources, whether owned by the firm or leased from others, to mine digital assets would be subject to an excise tax equal to 30 percent of the costs of electricity used in digital asset mining. Firms engaged in digital asset mining would be required to report the amount and type of electricity used as well as the value of that electricity, if purchased externally. Firms that lease computational capacity would be required to report the value of the electricity used by the lessor firm attributable to the leased capacity, which would serve as the tax base. Firms that produce or acquire power off-grid, for example by using the output of a particular electricity generating plant, would be subject to an excise tax equal to 30 percent of estimated electricity costs. Except as otherwise provided by the Secretary, the term “digital asset” means any digital representation of value which is recorded on a cryptographically secured distributed ledger or any similar technology as specified by the Secretary. The proposal would be effective for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023. The excise tax would be phased in over three years at a rate of 10 percent in the first year, 20 percent in the second, and 30 percent thereafter. ... From: https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanations-FY2024.pdf https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanati...
- jrm4 4y agoAs someone who's neutral/vaguely positive on crypto (which is to say, it's gonna happen regardless of what any of us think of it) this is a great idea, simple and to the point. Mining crypto is (now DEFINITELY) wasteful; make it more expensive. I'd go higher, even.
- leetcrew 4y agoI agree crypto mining is wasteful, but I don't think this kind of narrowly targeted tax is the right solution. ideally the federal government would not have an opinion on what citizens use electricity for, only that the externalities of power generation are priced in. at a high level, crypto mining is just arbitraging the price of electricity. if the externalities are priced into generation, this is a non issue. if they're not, a tax should be applied that doesn't discriminate by use case.
- paxys 4y ago> ideally the federal government would not have an opinion on what citizens use electricity for, only that the externalities of power generation are priced in. Only if you take the stance that energy generation and use sure be governed by pure free market economics, which never works out in the real world. Natural resources are limited. Mining/drilling has environmental impacts. People need energy to survive. It makes a lot more sense to go the opposite direction – treat it as a public good (which it is) and regulate usage. Otherwise you will end up in the inevitable reality where there is a large bitcoin mine in town printing cash for its owners and no one living around it can afford to heat their houses.
- Verdex 4y agoOn an individual level, I agree with this sentiment. However, as power and influence increases, I feel, so too does accountability to the community. For example, if an individual wants to have christmas lights on their house year round, I think they should be allowed to as long as they can pay their electric bill. However, if a crazy billionaire wants to blast a giant laser into the sky and this causes brown outs due to the power draw to the surrounding community, then I think the community should be able to get the laser shut off. And on the other hand, if the billionaire runs a free entry water park and that causes brownouts, I think the community should be able to decide whether or not to flip the switch.
- ulrashida 4y agoIt's a smart idea. Who is going to have sympathy for crypto miners? As a citizen, would you rather a Watt of power go to driving an industrial facility, heating a home, or making a Shibacoin? For most it's a very easy calculus. Either they pay up, in which case there's a new revenue stream, or they don't, in which case energy prices will go down due to the lowering of demand. A win for the general public and an easy sell. Who said policy was boring? Wonder how fast it will be copied elsewhere.
- knicholes 4y agoHeating a home and mining crypto don't have to be mutually exclusive!
- ragebol 4y agoI thought these guys [0] were out of business but at least the website is still alive. They ma{k,d}e a server that provides heat to your home. Just give it power and internet access, they provide compute loads. Now that I have solar panels, a hybrid heat pump and currently excess electricity, this is interesting to warm up a vat of tap water, for example. Any guides on DIYing such a combo? [0] https://nerdalize.cloud/ https://nerdalize.cloud/
- ulrashida 4y agoVery true: Geralt and V have kept me warm on many nights!
- ipaddr 4y agoAll this does is move HQ. There is a reason most US cargo ships sail under a foreign flag like liberia
- jonny_eh 4y agoShips are on water, their flag doesn't matter much. But charging a tax on activities occurring within the border has the effect of discouraging that activity. You can't slap a different flag on a server and escape the tax.
- ipaddr 4y agoThe flag matters to pollution controls, liability and taxes not to mention employee rights/wages. You are talking about billions of lost money. You can become a European company operating in the US. You can have a shell company operate the mining. You can show no profit.
- tialaramex 4y agoThe Paris MOU was such a success that many parts of the world have Port State Control (rather than Flag State) too now. If your ship flying Country X's flag docks in Europe then under the Paris MOU your flag decides how likely you are to get inspected by local authorities. Does Country X do a great job? Then inspections will be rare and you've nothing to worry about. Not so much? Expect to spend far more of your visits being inspected and if you don't obey inspection rules under the Port State rules too bad, their port, their laws apply, if you don't like it stop coming to Europe. If Country X don't like it, and I promise they don't give a shit once you paid the registration fee, they can take it up with Europe and see how far that gets them.
- paxys 4y agoSounds like a win-win. Bitcoin mining farms are contributing nothing to the region where they operate. People will be happy if they packed up and left and drained someone else's energy supply.
- rich_sasha 4y agoInteresting; it is difficult to both tax and ban something. Eg if crypto is deemed to be "bad" then how would the US justify profiting from running its operations? Perhaps a step towards some kind of normalization of crypto in the US.
- golergka 4y agoSo weird seeing such a positive feedback here as opposed to ISPs attempts to break net neutrality when it's exactly the same thing. When you purchase services or commodities, price either should depend on what you're using them for, or it shouldn't.
- dsr_ 4y agoAll societies are engaged in encouraging some behaviors, being neutral about some, and discouraging others. The tools for encouragement and discouragement are almost always, and always should, lie on a continuum from "subtle" to "draconian". Your proposal amounts to banning the intermediate grades. I suspect this is not what you actually want. It is certainly not what I want.
- golergka 4y agoI don't have any proposal here, just an observation about self inconsistency
- throwaway743 4y agoCurious to know if this would include a personally owned solar farm powered mining.
- xk_id 4y agoI think it’s short sighted to celebrate this. In reality it won’t reduce the demand for bitcoin hashpower. Instead it will force miners to flee to foreign jurisdictions (like Kazakhstan, china, russia, iran, venezuela), who are the least producers of clean energy. The result becomes higher climate impact, loss of domestic taxable income and slower growth of renewable energy due to lowered demand. Not to mention the moral issue of setting a precedent for permissioned electricity consumption .
- dragontamer 4y agoWho ever said this was about clean energy or carbon whatevers? This to me, is about not wasting US resources on this. Let other countries waste their electricity on cryptocoin mining if they want to. There's only so much electricity in this country, and there's already plenty of regulations on waste (or attempts to mitigate waste).