3 ms·
It certainly has warts. But it's not bad for something from the late 80ies (my guess is that Tcl is older than a small but significant number of this site's us
by davidw 15y ago
It certainly has warts. But it's not bad for something from the late 80ies (my guess is that Tcl is older than a small but significant number of this site's users), and I don't think language design is a key component in being popular / having a healthy community.
Exhibits A and B: PHP and Java.
- quatrevingts 15y agoI think Tcl is beautiful example of a certain point in the design space and extremely useful pedagogically. It's not that it has unnecessary deformities (warts) the way that PHP does. Someone could make a much better PHP than PHP by just cleaning up a bunch of nonsense that's only there because its designer didn't know what he was doing. I don't think that's the case with Tcl (or Java, for the most part.) It's just that solving a complex problem with a simple tool can often be more complex than solving it with a complex tool, even if the complex tool requires a bit more up-front learning. Working with Tcl makes it very clear that spending some of your complexity budget on closures pays off big. As far as what makes for a popular language, clearly corporate support is the key factor in some cases, good libraries in others, but I can't really explain the rise of Python except by its design.