6 ms·
UK Campaigning to replace the Monarchy with an elected head of state
- hunglee2 4y agoUK Republicanism has very little (but growing) public support. People are deeply invested in the national emblems and will defend them even if rational cases for reform can be made. For the Brits this is NHS, BBC and Royal Family
- weevil 4y agoAs a Brit, if we're ranking those things in order of practical importance, I'd put the Royal Family dead last. People will whinge about the NHS being slow or badly managed, but generally defend its existence to the hilt. Barring some free market extremists, there's no political will in this country to explicitly privatise and dissolve the NHS as a free at point-of-care nationalised healthcare service. The BBC gets teased for being old-fashioned, quite a bit of stick for the mandatory licence fee, and a lot of well-deserved criticism for the Jimmy Saville mess. Excluding some absolute nutters with dubious motivation and funding, no one's trying to get rid of the BBC. By contrast, there's a significant political bloc who are at least apathetic towards the monarchy, especially now the late Queen, the last symbol of continuity, has died.
- 0xy 4y agoThe NHS is a slavery farm delivering questionable value to citizens. As an example, a British brain surgeon will earn less than an American car wash manager while British health outcomes are worse than ever. 35% of people with EMERGENCY cancer referrals don't get seen within 2 months, and wait lists now hold over 6,000,000 people, and the worst wait periods (over a year) are rising rapidly. Doctors and nurses get absolutely scammed, while citizens get left to die. Additionally, despite the use of slave doctors, NHS funding is rising 2,000% faster than close neighbor France -- with further massive increases planned to 2025.
- weevil 4y agoYou should dial back the hyperbole and get some more sources in there, if you actually want to debate, and not come across as a for-profit healthcare shill.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIs the "car wash manager" an intended reference to Breaking Bad, where the genius teacher becomes a drug lord to pay for healthcare and avoid bankrupting his family and then uses the car wash where he used to work a second job to launder money?
- 0xy 4y agoBuc-ees Car Wash Manager $125k USD (100k pounds) -> https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FjXd9k7XkAAFTSn?format=jpg&name=medium https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FjXd9k7XkAAFTSn?format=jpg&name=... NHS Brain Surgeon 96k pounds -> https://www.payscale.com/research/UK/Job=Neurosurgeon/Salary https://www.payscale.com/research/UK/Job=Neurosurgeon/Salary If you decide you can move on up to checks board managing the production of burritos and burgers as a Food Service Manager, you can out-earn a British brain surgeon by 50% :) Pretty depressing to be a British doctor.
- lou1306 4y agoMost Brits still dig bathroom sinks with separate faucets. It's an uphill campaign.
- zeristor 4y agoWhat a strange word faucet is.
- KineticLensman 4y agoBrits actually say 'taps' - 'faucet' is almost never used casually.
- mihaaly 4y agoBut most importantly are proud in unity of the big and independent Empire that is so influential in most of the UK. Or British Isles minus Ireland. Or Great Britain without some folks in Scotland. Or Englad + Wales. Difficult to follow what is what and where and why and who. Nevertheless, this amount of pride mandates a Brexit. Or maybe even two.
- drcongo 4y agoOf all the things I hate about this country, which is a pretty long list, that one is right up there.
- 632brick 4y agoThey should probably focus on fixing their democracy first with proper proportional representation.
- weevil 4y agoThere's tonnes of evidence that proportional representation and voting systems other than FPTP are important for the health of a democracy. The problem in the UK is that the parties in a position to make it happen stand to lose a lot of power as a result, so it's not likely to happen. The 2011 Alternative Vote referendum was a solid victory for FPTP, and it's often used as a cudgel on anyone who dares to suggest a better voting system.
- robinjfisher 4y ago"A" UK campaign. Lots of coverage around the time of the Queen's death and unsurprisingly in the news now given the coronation. Little to no media coverage at any other time and has very little public support albeit growing support in certain demographics.
- paulodeon 4y agoLOL, given we couldn't even get an alternative vote referendum through, there is literally sub single digit percentage chances this happens in any of our lives: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_United_Kingdom_Alternative_Vote_referendum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_United_Kingdom_Alternativ...
- seydor 4y agoWhy elected? How about just The Richest?
- WJW 4y agoSuch an American viewpoint. Imagine the horror of having one of the nouveau riche becoming head of state. They probably didn't even go to the right schools!
- franky47 4y agoBernard Arnault becoming King? William the Conqueror approves of this plan.
- Ekaros 4y agoReally thinking about it. The Richest might not be horrible pick. At least if the process is proper. Every quarter, everyone who want to be in the running would be fully audited, all of their holdings, accounts and liabilities would be fully public. Then we could just tally it all up and pick the one with largest number. Just need amount of transparency that will never happen.
- Timon3 4y ago
- kypro 4y agoI wouldn't be opposed to the UK having two heads of state and reforming the monarchy somewhat, but I struggle to understand how some people don't some to see any benefit of the system at all.
- kaanski 4y agoPersonally I like having a politically neutral head of state as a personification of the country. An elected head of state will be impossible to keep politically neutral and inevitably will polarise things. Maybe a system with an appointed head of state instead of elected, similar to peerages in the House of Lords. Someone vetted and trusted, approved by an elected parliament. Although the Monarchy is already completely controlled by parliament which is democratically elected so I’m not sure what the difference would be.
- robin_reala 4y agoDo you believe that the current monarchy is politically neutral?
- kaanski 4y agoThe monarch has not exercised direct political power since the English Civil War. Yes they’re wealthy and have exercised power that wealth gives you but they’d still be wealthy if they were not a monarch. If we want to talk about the power that money brings you in politics then we’re having a different discussion, a discussion that is not UK specific. But yes the monarchy as an institution has not involved itself in political matters in living memory, and has not exercised political power (executive orders, vetoing bills) in centuries. Parliament is the sovereign political power in the UK. If they wanted to they could pass a bill today that dismantled the crown and the monarchy.
- robin_reala 4y agoDirect political power is one thing, but indirect political power is very much another. The monarch gets briefed in advance on pretty much everything. Where there’s direct commercial impact to the crown’s businesses the laws are often changed to favour them.[1] There’s also a wide range of exceptions written into the UK’s legal system after direct political pressure specifically for the royal family.[2] This might be done in the shadows, but done it nevertheless is. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/ng-interactive/2015/may/13/read-the-prince-charles-black-spider-memos-in-full https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/ng-interactive/2015/may/... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jul/14/queen-immunity-british-laws-private-property https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jul/14/queen-immuni...
- mmarq 4y agoThe issue with the British monarchy is that we pay them and their only duty is to not look like a bunch of idiots, nothing more is asked. But unfortunately all we got from the royal family is (1) somebody that gets involved in sex assaults against children, (2) somebody whose main achievement is having cheated repeatedly on his wife and (3) a TikTok influencer that writes books about freezing his dick. I’m not sure my taxes are well spent on this insanity.
- FredPret 4y agoI think the term "sexual assault" covers everything from slapping someone's butt all the way to much worse. Epstein and his pedo island is towards the nightmare end of the spectrum for the kids involved.
- kypro 4y agoYou're going to have to pay for a head of state anyway so this isn't a great argument, and I don't know where you've been for the last decade if you don't think similar levels insanity exist with elected leaders too. The monarchy is flawed, but at least provides a stable and apolitical head of state.
- epolanski 4y agoMy understanding is that the royal family is financially a net benefit for the UK for several reasons. 1) The royal family leases most of it's belongings (from land for farming to museums/castles) and that's a 300M+ pounds benefit for the British government. The crown gives back more than it takes (40M pounds/year). If you removed them from power, why would they have to do so anymore? Like it or not, it's still their personal belongings and you would also need to confiscate those. 2) The royal family drives a lot of gossip business. It's a very huge industry on which many indulge out of boredom/curiosity that gets no parallel among other VIPs. Thousands of people's livelihood depend on that. 3) Apparently it's a huge bonus/benefit for tourism. I can't find the source but most tourists find it more interesting that real nobles and monarchs live in British castles. Goes without saying that the monarchy is also essentially a tourist attraction with all it's traditions/parades/coronations in London. Essentially the Crown is more of a financial benefit to the UK than the opposite.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prima-facie 4y agoThis will change nothing with the Tories still in charge.
- jarym 4y agoNot being funny, but 'elected' has lost some of the properties it used to be associated with. For example, the UK parliament consist of elected MPs - in theory, representing their constituents. In practice, they are 'whipped' by their party into however the government wants them to vote - often against the will of the constituents that elected them. Another example is the Mayor of London, elected - but instituting wildly unpopular plans like extending the ULEZ zone despite the fact that it will not improve air quality, will push the cost of living in and around London higher and will cost more to implement than it raises in revenue. What is the purpose of electing people who will then do as they please?
- thicknavyrain 4y agoDo you have any sources on ULEZ not improving air quality? The latest research I can find indicates yes, ULEZ did lower concentrations of several pollutants: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1309104222001969 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S130910422...
- jarym 4y agoULEZ did improve air quality in central London - owing to the large concentration of cars. I'd say probably strong incentives for non-gas vehicles helped also (exemptions from Congestion Charge, reduced parking fees in certain boroughs, etc) The ULEZ 'extension' is different. It extends ULEZ to areas on the outskirts of London (the suburbs). There are a number of problems with this: * Public transport options not as great, so car ownership is far higher. Lots of commuters (that either have to travel to surrounding areas or commute in from nearby). * The area is not as densely populated as the central areas and there are more highways and things designed to support greater volumes of traffic. * The costs are high (daily £12.50) * From 2030, all new cars in the UK will be non-gas. The shift is already gaining momentum so naturally through incentives those that can afford to move to an EV are doing so. TfL's own analysis shows that the scheme will cost more to rollout than the revenue it generates. Also, I detest the 'pulling at heart strings' approach taken to justify this extension. It is akin to the people who want to break E2E encryption and privacy crying 'think of the children' - the basis is not logically sound.
- Defletter 4y agoFor most Brits, at least by my estimation, have fairly complicated feelings towards the Monarchy that often cannot really be expressed. Many Brits aren't monarchists but 'Elizabethans', but now that the Queen has passed, those complicated feelings that were kept at bay by the public's genuine affection for the Queen are now rearing their head. The King, and I suppose the Royal Family in general, aren't doing themselves any favours either. That being said, we aren't shown really any examples of good republicanism. We know that a Monarchy is weird, that this is the 21st century, that a birthright to rule is medieval... but what's the alternative? No really, what's the alternative? We look at America with its independent, co-equal executive in horror. We don't want that. And then we look at France, whose President just forced through a rise in the retirement age against the will of the Parliament. We don't want that either. Having an elected President inherently means that they'll have a democratic mandate, so there'll always be questions of whether they should be granted more power, or whether the President has the mandate to exercise power. There's great usefulness to having a Head of State who's not involved in politics or policy. And yes, WE KNOW that it's not that simple, that the Monarchy has its claws in the legislative process to grant themselves shady opt-outs to tax laws and such, we know this. We just need to be shown what a good republic looks like and then be able to actually make the change to the law without it being moulded in favour of whoever was in Government at the time. We are literally facing deterioration of our Human Rights. You think the Government wont go after the most fundamental parts of our constitution once they know it's on the chopping block? The Monarchy is the very last protection we have against a tyrannical government, as weird as that may sound. People who want the Government to remove that need to have a very convincing argument.
- Barrin92 4y agoThere's always the option of having a (largely) ceremonial president, usually elected by a non-standing representative body which is quite common in central Europe. It retains the role of a non-political head of state who represents the constitutional order and in theory even has quite a few powers should things go south, but without all the monarchy, blood based lineage, and pomp that at this point I think undermines the legitimacy these institutions have. Monarchy even if in many countries still around and reasonably popular is in my opinion on life support without any sort of modern justification for its existence. The Economist a while ago had a good column how the drama within the British Royal family with Megan and Harry is essentially a 'all that is solid will melt into air' moment as the family itself is gradually absorbed into something more like capitalist American celebrity-dom.
- rich_sasha 4y agoIn all fairness, the elected officials of the past 10-15+ years have been awful in so many ways. Ineffective, populist, law-breaking, corrupt and laughing in the face of law. That's mostly Tories, but I don't seem to remember much love for Tony Blair. End of Monarchy - maybe. But replacing it with elected officials doesn't sound like an improvement.
- pjbster 4y agoThe British monarchy has a complicated and symbiotic relationship with the City of London as enshrined in the Statute of William and Mary [1] [1] https://www.british-history.ac.uk/no-series/new-history-london/pp860-863 https://www.british-history.ac.uk/no-series/new-history-lond... Public sentiments regarding the monarchy have been massaged over the centuries via the British media which is also utterly entangled in the City. It's all one giant mutual interest collective which practises tax evasion on a galactic scale. I'd recommend picking up a copy of "Treasure Islands" by Nicholas Shaxson. Chapter 12 ("Griffin") focuses on the City and I'd also recommend viewing the reactions to any anti-monarchy campaign through this lens.
- jacknews 4y agoIn that case of course everyone will vote for Kingsly McKingface. The incumbents may also be clowns, but they are at least a bridge to the old world, dictatorships, etc, where they still have some clout, and can help peddle the national interest.
- Timon3 4y agoAnd they are able to use all of their clout to give themselves advantages while ignoring their country, like any leaders - only these also lack oversight.
- jacknews 4y agoIt's not as though they are some shadowy government agency free from scrutiny. In some ways they are better than elected leaders. They have a long-term reputation to uphold, whereas elected leaders might be gone in a term - Almost like one of those supermarket 'free smash and grabs' where competition winners get 5 minutes to grab and keep whatever they can from the supermarket shelves. I'm not particularly a fan of monarchy, but if we're going to abolish it, we should just do that, not put up some other kind of clown show.
- Timon3 4y ago> It's not as though they are some shadowy government agency free from scrutiny. Maybe not shadowy, but the rest? How do you have anything comparable to democratic scrutiny in a monarchical system? > They have a long-term reputation to uphold, whereas elected leaders might be gone in a term You're putting it like the politicians don't have a reputation to uphold. Can you clearly explain why the long-term reputation of monarchs is more important than that of politicians? The politician will have to face re-election, the monarch will stay in power.
- jacknews 4y agoheredity
- theironhammer 4y agoThe monarchy perpetuates the class system.