5 ms·
Americans Gaining Most Weight in Their 20s and 30s: What They Can Do
- bruceb 4y agoFor most people the key to not gaining lots of weight is making good decisions when you shop at the supermarket. Look at the label of the food you are buying. If the ingredient list is long and there are lots of words you don't recognize or can't pronounce, don't buy it. If most of you food comes in a box/container then you are probably eating sub optimal food. Look at how much sugar is in it. Most processed food has more sugar than you think. A lot more. Limit drinks that are not water. They have sugar in them or chemicals. It is not hard to eat relatively health, if you have time or money. Time to prepare food or money to buy pre cut veggies and other fresh items.
- naruhodo 4y agoYep. It's easier to have self-control for the one hour a week that you're at the supermarket than 24x7 when there's chocolate and alcohol in the pantry. So the easiest way to control your intake of high calorie foods is to just not buy them. May I also offer some words of wisdom from Dr Rudy... two words: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0GGf_GlD2RY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0GGf_GlD2RY
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- usui 4y ago> eat less It is quite literally this simple, but the weight-loss industry keeps growing. So many billions of dollars spent to redirect the answer for people. Some people will have a harder time mentally coping due to genetics, but at the end of the day, this is the answer.
- rantallion 4y ago> They have sugar in them or chemicals. Nitpick: everything is a chemical (even water itself).
- dougmwne 4y agoIt is possible for a statement to be technically correct, but practically incorrect. Words have different definitions and meanings in different contexts. If you try to force a meaning from one context into another context, you have made an error in your language use. If you take a look at the dictionary, which is a documentation of the practical use of words, you will see that to talk of chemicals in food is entirely coherent. Words do not have absolute definitions, they are defined by their usage in the real language. https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/chemical#:~:text=Chemical%20means%20involving%20or%20resulting,substances%20that%20something%20consists%20of https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/chemica....
- YurgenJurgensen 4y agoYou linked a dictionary definition which would qualify water as chemical. Even your own source disagrees with you. The purpose of language is communication. If the 'practical' use of the word doesn't communicate anything, then the practical use is wrong.
- dougmwne 4y agoYou can’t redefine words as you see fit to suit a simplified model of the world. Meaning is complex and shaded by situation and intent.
- YurgenJurgensen 4y agoNote that the dictionary you provided agrees with me and disagrees with you. The one redefining words here is you. Well, you'd actually have to have defined the word in the first place, but you haven't even done that. If you can't even define the word you're talking about, how can you be in a position to tell other people what it means?
- silisili 4y agoI feel like this is treating obesity as a scientific problem, and not a mental one. It's absolutely, one hundred percent the latter. Losing weight is easy. Eat less calories than you burn. If you don't know what that is, assume 1500ish. I know this, but still have had huge phases of gaining and losing weight in my life. And it was never because I'm so dumb as not to know why or how to fix it, but because fatty foods become some type of 'good part' in an otherwise uneventful day. Or because you're so exhausted fast food is all that's for dinner. We've got to figure out how to fix the mental parts. With the rise of social media and the recently published 'loneliness epidemic', I suspect this will get worse before it gets better.
- switch007 4y ago100% agree with this. I just got out a bad relationship and I’ve gained 7kg. You need to be in a really good place mentally to make all the good decisions and fight all the advertising.
- crooked-v 4y agoThe funny thing is, I've always had an easier time keeping a steady weight in the parts of my life when I relied on fast food or chain restaurants because I could reliably count calories. It's when I cook at home that I have a hard-to-impossible time trying to keep track.
- eternityforest 4y agoMany foods are designed to make you want to keep eating them. If you have cookies in the house you will probably eat them, or at least I will, if you have something healthy that takes effort to make you'll probably eat a serving and move on. Too many calories might be bad no matter what the source is, but some foods seem to make people want to eat more of them than others... and some foods have negative effects even aside from weight. They seem pretty sure even lots of stuff that's totally natural isn't that healthy... The thing that I would really like to understand is why social media and internet addiction doesn't make us eat less. I would expect the American diet to be a lot healthier now that phones exist, because we all look at screens all day, you would think we would just eat exactly enough to not be hungry, and maybe a little more as a social thing, and otherwise maybe even forget to eat half the time, like people do when engrossed in a book or a project? Why can't tech fill our pointless dopamine seeking needs just as well as eating crap? Shouldn't intermittent fasting be kind of automatic now? Perhaps one might expect us to even have healthy meals more just to show off on Instagram. Instead we scroll while we eat, and we even doordash now, from what I hear. It almost seems like the scrolling makes it worse!
- not_your_vase 4y ago> It is not hard to eat relatively health, if you have time or money. This is the most important sentence. I would also say `s/or/and/g` When counting calories and spreading eating out through the day, diet planning, food preparation and eating can easily become an almost full time job.
- frankzander 4y agothen just don't count calories, don't plan diets. just prepare your food and eat. it takes around 2 hours. at the end this is one of the most important activities because you care about your fuel.
- not_your_vase 4y agoThat's more than 2 hours, spread across the day, with constant context switching (unless you like hours old food). I know it is easy to talk about it. Doing is very very different. I know, as I used to talk about it, but I have been about it since quite a while.
- alkibiades 4y agoalso when people tend to have kids
- patatino 4y agoYes, that's why it is so funny to me nobody talks about stress. Sure, it is easy on paper to lose weight, just do not overeat. It is more about emotions and stress than scanning food for me. Most of the time, gaining weight is a symptom.
- alkibiades 4y agoyeah it isn’t too differnt than smoking or drinking or drugs in terms of use as a stress reliever
- noufalibrahim 4y agoWhy do you say that? I'm not American but my eating and exercise habits have improved considerably after I had kids.
- alkibiades 4y agowell for women there’s a biological reality that they tend to gain weight in pregnancy and don’t tend to lose it all after but for both sexes it’s a lot less free time and alot more stress. both of which are contributors to weight gain
- switch007 4y agoRemember people: despite your country being designed around cars, and food companies are more or less allowed to poison you, and companies being able to advertise whatever they like, and companies employing psychologists to trick you in to making bad decisions, it is up to /you/ to make good choices. Walk that 6 miles to the grocery store. Don’t be lazy! At least 3 miles might have a side walk. And when you get there and look at the 62 different loaves of bread, make sure to pick one which is healthy. Should be easy. I do accept the role of personal responsibility but come on let’s not ignore all the other issues too.
- realjhol 4y agoPorn should be illegal for the same reason
- benatkin 4y agoThe main problem is the vilification of beans, potatoes, corn, peanuts, and apple juice.
- ddorian43 4y agoJust eat low-carb or carnivore. It's the easiest way.
- antirez 4y agoWow, what a set of terrible handwaving advices that will produce zero results. Here is the proper list: 1. The only way to lose weight is to eat at a calories deficit. Calculate the number of calories you need using this app/site/whatever, than make sure to eat at a devicit tracking all your eating with this app. EDIT: This does not mean it is not important to eat well and clean, but that eating well alone is not going to make you lose weight if you are eating too many calories. 2. Engage in strength training at least 2 times per week, better 3. It is impossible to revert eating too much with exercise because the calories used during exercise are very easy to eat back just with a few slices of bread. However resistance training helps to create more muscles and less fat in the event you are still getting weight, and if you are losing weight will protect from losing muscles. There will be also methabolic benefits. 3. To speedup the weight loss, assuming you are eating at a deficit, you may add some cardio activity, this also helps to lower blood pressure, glucose levels and so forth. 4. When eating don't use cheat days: if your daily deficit is for instance 400 calories, and in your cheat day you eat back 400*6 of the deficit created during the other six days, you will not lose any fat. 5. Weight every day and store the weight into an app that can draw a graph for you, such as Google Fit, MyFitnessPal or whatever. You need a constant warning in case you are not losing weight but are gaining it.
- silisili 4y agoAnd I consider this also potentially terrible advice. 1 is all you need to lose weight. 2 is mostly irrelevant. It's not like if you accidentally eat too much you'll get hulk muscles if you were working out. It's mostly impossible to both gain muscle and lose fat at the same time. 3 cardio is always good for you, but does little for weight loss, compared to food intake 4 is probably good advice. 5 is awful advice because you'll get discouraged weighing everyday. Between swings in water weight and erm, waste product, weight can easily swing a few lbs. Weekly is better advice. None of this is to say your advice is necessarily bad, but I feel you're treating heavy people as idiots that you are smarter than. And maybe you are. But I personally think there's much much more going on than fat people being too stupid to know better, and that's what we need to focus on.
- 4y ago
- zenpolish 4y agoDiligently counting my calories and trying to keep within a certain threshold helps. The app I use is MyNetDiary and the free version is generous, although I purchased the premium version to support it.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoI gained most of my weight in my 20s. I lost most of it in my 30s. Lose weight swiftly in 4 simple (but not easy) steps: 1. Cut out sugar and anything that has sugar or sweeteners as an ingredient. 2. Cut out all fruit juices. Eat all the fruit you want instead. 3. Warm up every day. A quick 10 minute routine upon waking up. Not enough to feel tired or sore - just enough to feel strong and agile. 4. Walk 4 miles every day. That's around 10k steps. I know a woman who lost 50 pounds this way in one year. I've lost 15 pounds in 2 months. It works if you can stick to it.
- robocat 4y agoDifferent things work for different people. To drop my spare kilos I only eat one meal a day which I think was the main reason to lose the spare tire. I also reduced my carbohydrate intake, cut out sugars (including fruit juices), and try to avoid highly processed foods. I don’t do much exercise, and I do drink a moderate amount. My one-meal technique does work for middle aged me. However I know others that need breakfast and lunch, and my technique can’t work for them. I have friends who try much much harder than me at various techniques to lose weight, without good results. If I start lunching and dinnering (or just home snacking) then I do put weight back on.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoDefinitely. I for example don't do well with alcohol (it gets in the way of waking up early) and put it in the same category as sugar. Intermittent fasting works for me too, but I'm much happier when I eat two to three meals per day.
- lostmsu 4y ago> Walk 4 miles every day That will eat your lifetime faster than obesity unless you also do something else.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoThis flies in the face of everything I've learned. Please provide some information on "Walking 4 miles worse for you than obesity".
- iknownothow 4y agoMy opinion, comparing Americans with Germans I see and I find two obvious differences: * On average Americans are likely to be obese and very likely to be overweight. * Fit & muscular Americans are much bulkier than fit Germans. My conclusions * On average, Americans consume way more sugar. * On average, Americans consume way more fast food. * I think American meat has more steroids.
- exitb 4y agoWhile that might depend on a particular person to an extent, I found exercise the biggest differentiator for my own health and weight. And I don't even mean workout - rather anything more than 15 minutes of walking per day. I also never walked less than the two weeks I spent in Texas.
- logicchains 4y ago>* I think American meat has more steroids There's a simpler answer: Americans, regardless of whether they exercise or not, consume more calories than Germans. This means Americans who lift weights will grow more muscles than Germans who lift weights, and Americans who don't will grow more fat.
- twelve40 4y agowell, the numbers in Germany are trending in the same direction, so there isn't really a magic formula and in a decade or so it's likely to have the same obesity prevalence as the US does now.
- zttg 4y ago[dead]
- WalterBright 4y agoDoesn't jibe with my experience. My ability to control my weight gets more difficult every year.
- oogabooga13 4y agoThere are levels to everything. When I found myself losing close to 60lbs the weightloss in a sense was easy with a very basic plan. IMO I feel the mental component is not brought into the equation enough. After the physical weight loss I still had to work through the mental issues with losing what felt like half of me (positive but still strange to witness in the mirror), becoming visible in spaces (think socially) I was typically invisible (despite being so large), and transitioning out of a year long weightloss mode to a life long sustainable "maintenance mode" to keep the weight at bay but not go crazy. While the weight has fluctuated a bit since the intial weightloss over 10 years, the bulk 45ish lbs has not come back. One key are for me personally was wrapping my head around all the stuff surrounding my unhealthy habits, many not tied to food and working to shore up those areas in my life as well. Mind. Body. Soul. Just wanted to throw that into the ring. Everyone has their own journey and the steps are really basic from a nutrition stand point. It can be a fascinating oppurtunity to learn about oneself through focused observation.
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoI sit somewhere in the 8th-13th percentile according to DQYDJ’s calculators for weight distribution. So I’m a thin guy. The only men thinner than me are usually lanky teenagers growing into their bodies still. I’m also muscular and generally fit with a body fat percentage of about 13.3%. BMI of 21.8, no I’m no longer much of the athlete’s build I once was, but I’m holding on quite well. The data is out of date by a few years now, but I assume Americans have only gotten larger. Not thinner. I don’t exercise, I used to run often, but now I’m too busy running my firm and renovating a house that leaves me doing enough bodily work I’m not missing out. So my biggest variable is eating and at my weight any singular deviation from proper eating means that I gain weight fast. I weigh in daily. The article tells us things we’ve known I’m sure at least since the 70s so there aren’t any grand revelations here. It’s just that people suck at eating properly. And frankly, eating well is boring. That’s why people fail to do it. Most people I know already can’t cook, and if you have no culinary articulation nor come from a racial background of low weight individuals you’re fighting both a dietary and cultural problem at the same time. I noticed my weight gain in my 20s, and so I’ve always tracked it since then. My observations are that Americans eating whole foods get as close as possible to replicating other foreign cultures who are naturally thin peoples. Asians in particular come to mind. The inherent issue with most processed foods just simply that most processes combine ingredients that are high in calories, or refine ingredients into densities that mean you’re eating more simply because the process condenses them. That’s it. Processed foods make you eat more food. If you juiced one orange, you’d barely have any juice. If you ate one orange you’d receive all of the fiber of the fruit itself as well. In America, we just don’t have many recipes or cultural dishes that help you lose weight. But in Asian cultures, I can think of dish after dish that are whole ingredients and none of them are refined. To lose weight, you have to learn how to eat. I see it the same way you learn how to not smoke or drink. It’s just that junk food and sugar are so prevalent and we don’t assign it the same social stigma that people are such poor eaters.
- mikelago 4y agoMy advice is a bit more meta, short, and simple compared to what I'm reading in the comments so far. Rather than bullets, or steps, I'll go with ranking: 1. Follow the advice in the rest of these comments. Summary: Eat good food and exercise. This is actually obvious, often repeated and boring advice. 2. This is my real golden nugget: Stop eating. Take a step back from all of this constant debate on nutrition. Calorie in calorie out is actually true, but the real hack is the fact that you don't need to eat. Intermittent fasting is also common advice, but go ahead, go even further. *For either option, Drink water. Lots of it. Good quality water. Don't drink other stuff (some coffee, tea, okay). Water is love. Water is life. Often repeated but not stressed enough, and a major source of many issues.* Anorexia is a problem, but it is not a common problem and is not something that should be worth preventing people from acknowledging that fasting is okay, humans have uniquely evolved to do it, and in general it's a much easier solution. I think it's okay for young people to try out not eating, but absolutely they should be encouraged and taught to do #1 instead, with an emphasis on the downsides of bad nutrition and physical health. A bigger problem than anorexia is the historical political and corporate motivation to make us eat more and often and don't stop eating, which is probably a major contributor to the obesity epidemic (probably global pollution as well).
- zuuuuuh 4y agoSounds simple but for me I always find weight loss to be the most effortless when I am consistently getting lots of sunlight.
- getpost 4y agoThere is an ongoing debate about the causes of obesity and, consequently, the right strategy for losing weight. There is a new paper out last week[0],[1]. "The surprising conclusion is we spend less energy when resting now than individuals did 30-40 years ago! The magnitude of the effect is sufficient to explain the obesity epidemic." The hypothesis is that the reduction in metabolic rate is to due to the relative decrease in the consumption of saturated fat! [0] https://twitter.com/JohnSpeakman4/status/1651244232789598211 https://twitter.com/JohnSpeakman4/status/1651244232789598211 [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s42255-023-00782-2.epdf?sharing_token=fShuw6h1i65NATyZEw_DzNRgN0jAjWel9jnR3ZoTv0MED8sA9nv-pD4iGxoQakfuzJY5a9QfC_lkFrVW_8wTo7WO7eWX0u_LnTsEAd0rrfB0POPZy51XM033WdQA0I1l7V9T629Eg6kljSeQ3couENbBEkXvOEjS4UDcJWHxfiw%3D https://www.nature.com/articles/s42255-023-00782-2.epdf?shar... EDIT: Explainer video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNNxE-K06KA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNNxE-K06KA