3 ms·
> So, we're at a point where we need to admit that mantra isn't true in the modern age, or admit that we've done a terrible job at preventing effective monopoli
by AnthonyMouse 4y ago
> So, we're at a point where we need to admit that mantra isn't true in the modern age, or admit that we've done a terrible job at preventing effective monopolies/duopolies from forming.
It's objectively obvious that the latter is true, but why?
One of the reasons is regulatory capture. But another is that people have stopped believing the former.
Suppose there is a market with an existing duopoly that charges high prices and you're a rich investor who likes to make money. Popular theory says that you shouldn't enter that market because they'll just undercut you until you go out of business and then go back to charging high prices.
But how does that work? Once you've invested the money to enter the market, you're committed. The incumbents have to deal with that. If you charge slightly less than they do, they have four options. One is to ignore you and keep doing what they were doing, which would allow you to take a disproportionate share of the market. Another is to match your price. But then you still get a third of the market where you previously had none and you now have goodwill with customers because you finally caused the market price to move in the direction they like, so that's quite profitable for you. The third is to buy you out, which is you turning a profit again.
The last is to undercut you and launch a price war. But by then you've already paid to build the infrastructure needed to compete with them. It exists. Even if you were to give up, you would still have that infrastructure to sell to anyone who wanted to give it a go. And if the expectation is that prices would return to profitable levels at any point in the foreseeable future, there would be returns in doing that for anyone with money to invest. Which mitigates your risk. And means the incumbents can't eliminate the competition by doing this. They can only torpedo their own profitability. Their real options are to lose some of their market share to you or buy you out, both of which are profitable to you.
So who taught investors that doing this is not profitable?
- doublespanner 4y agoOnly if the infrastructure is something tangible, often the startup costs are regulatory, and not necessarily transferable. There is also the problem that if the incumbents move to undercut, then any onlooker would assume that even if they bought the infrastructure they would also face the same undercutting; and would therefore have to remain solvent longer than an incumbant to make a return. I think this is why there is so much focus on tech or disruption; you need some way to compete against the scale efficiency of the incumbant.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoRegulatory costs aren't lost in acquisitions. You buy the whole company. > There is also the problem that if the incumbents move to undercut, then any onlooker would assume that even if they bought the infrastructure they would also face the same undercutting; and would therefore have to remain solvent longer than an incumbant to make a return But the incumbent has the same problem. If the unit cost is $1 and they're selling for $0.90 to undercut you, they're losing money too. Anybody can see that they won't be able to keep that up forever, and as soon as they stop, whoever invested in the competition is making money. > I think this is why there is so much focus on tech or disruption; you need some way to compete against the scale efficiency of the incumbant. Most markets have a minimum scale past which being larger provides no significant efficiency benefit and only creates diseconomies of scale from bureaucratic overhead and internal politics. This is why companies try to commit antitrust violations to keep barriers to entry high enough that others can't get a foothold. Because once they do, the incumbent has no advantage and is commonly outmaneuvered because monopolists typically become inefficient from lack of competitive pressure and existing customers tend to hate them.
- doublespanner 4y agoAgain, not all costs associated with regulatory compliance are transferable; this is by design to keep a barrier to entry. Many accreditations/certifications have a reset clause when something significant in a business changes (like owner), or have a not widely available cheaper streamlined version for long-standing businesses. This is even assuming that selling the whole businesses is the best way to exit; taking over the whole business rather than just the machinery (for example) is a restriction that might be detrimental. The thing you are not understanding, is that you have to be able to loose money for longer than the competition; it either requires an investment on the same scale as the total valuation of the incumbent, or a string of failed attempts from others to set the stage... And you can estimate ahead of time how long you can operate for, and how long the competition can, so you can likely tell before you start that you are going to be one of the failures.
- navane 4y agoit is only profitable if you are a big corp who made his money elsewhere, a significant amount of money compared to the money in the market you're trying to enter. We've always known that a big guy can come into a small guys party and squish them all. That's why microsoft wasn't allowed to push their browser (OS = big guy, browser market = small guys party). This is why amazon shouldn't be allowed to sell its own items in its own store, any supermarket really. With their power of scale, these market owners can squish anything they sell in their store, killing competition with it.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoIt's only profitable if you have enough to invest to meet the entry costs in that market. Which is where the regulatory capture is causing trouble by raising entry costs. But that only means you need more or bigger initial investors, not that they don't make money by investing. > We've always known that a big guy can come into a small guys party and squish them all. That's why microsoft wasn't allowed to push their browser (OS = big guy, browser market = small guys party). That was an antitrust issue for an entirely different reason. The browser market had the potential to disrupt Microsoft's control over the OS market, because web pages are platform-independent. That gives Microsoft the incentive to dominate the browser market by operating at a loss in order to make sure that web pages are tied to Microsoft Windows by using platform-specific ActiveX controls or web extensions specific to Microsoft's browser. The web reducing dependence on Windows is largely what happened in the intervening years outside of some specific app markets like gaming (where Microsoft has held on through similar dirty tricks with respect to DirectX and other APIs, and is finally starting to lose their grip).