3 ms·
There's no such thing as "phonetically correct alphabet for English", because the diversity of English dialects (even if you only look at major ones) is such th
by int_19h 4y ago
There's no such thing as "phonetically correct alphabet for English", because the diversity of English dialects (even if you only look at major ones) is such that an alphabet that correctly reflects a phonemic distinction in one is redundant for another. Some examples:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cot%E2%80%93caught_merger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cot%E2%80%93caught_merger
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Father%E2%80%93bother_merger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Father%E2%80%93bother_merger
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap%E2%80%93bath_split https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap%E2%80%93bath_split
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lot%E2%80%93cloth_split https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lot%E2%80%93cloth_split
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phonological_history_of_English_diphthongs#Variation_in_present-day_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phonological_history_of_Englis...
That aside, it would make more sense to take the Latin alphabet as a base, and only add enough new letters to cover what's missing. And if you use diacritics to derive new letters, it's possible to come up with something that can reflect pronunciation accurately in different dialects (using different diacritics where the same words are pronounced differently) while remaining broadly readable across those dialects if diacritics are simply ignored.
- thesuperbigfrog 4y ago>> There's no such thing as "phonetically correct alphabet for English", because the diversity of English dialects As I stated in the comments below: "Most dialects could be considered separate languages with varying degrees of shared ancestry. For that reason, I am not including dialects in my generalization." So, to be more precise, the Deseret alphabet was phoenetically correct for the English spoken by the Utah settlers circa 1850 to 1870.
- feoren 4y agoOne of the main purposes of language -- especially written language -- is to communicate ideas as widely as possible. Excluding "dialects" is excluding the vast majority of English speakers, especially if you define a dialect as anything different from "English spoken by Utah settlers circa 1850 to 1870". There's a reason these conlangs don't catch on: they're rooted in false and frankly hubristic notions about language, such as: - Language never changes. Okay, well, it used to change constantly, but that stops starting now! - The way we talk is obviously correct and will always be correct, and everyone else is wrong. But this is a cool alphabet to know if you really need to write a message to a mid-19th-century Utah settler. Oh, wait, they wouldn't be able to read it either. But I'm sure it made Brigham Young feel superior to everyone else, which was its actual purpose all along.
- elliekelly 4y agoWhen I read Don Quixote I watched Professor González Echevarría’s lectures[1] on YouTube and one of the things he often repeats throughout the course is something along the lines of “the only difference between a different language and a different dialect is an army”. [1]https://oyc.yale.edu/spanish-and-portuguese/span-300 https://oyc.yale.edu/spanish-and-portuguese/span-300