4 ms·
What's nonsense is equating stories that are obviously mythological with factual, historical record. Yes, there are obviously some mythological stories about t
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
What's nonsense is equating stories that are obviously mythological with factual, historical record.
Yes, there are obviously some mythological stories about the US founding fathers (George Washington's cherry tree, for example). But there are also reams and reams of historical evidence for their true activities and true natures, and it's absurd to claim that they are somehow "complete fabrications".
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThe stories of the founding fathers have been heavily mythologized. Yes, we can refer back to the original sources, but we also have two centuries of historiography using those original sources to spin a variety of narratives. To the point where you can use their actions to tell basically any story you want. An example of this is "Hamilton." The musical and the book that inspired it tell a version of events different enough to what other sources say that it may as well be complete fiction.
- mustacheemperor 4y ago>and the book that inspired it Genuinely wondering - Where do those other sources differ, and why are they authoritative enough to mean the book Alexander Hamilton may as well be complete fiction? Looking online, I can't really find much contemporary criticism of its accuracy from the time of its release or afterwards, just general acclaim from book reviewers. I can't find much academic opinion of it either way, save for one review I don't have library access to but seems to have a positive first page.[0] I'm not really familiar with the musical, but I did find a few articles noting Ron Chernow consulted on its historical accuracy. I wouldn't really hold a musical theater production to the same standard of historic accuracy as a biography, though, so I am more curious why you describe the biography as "complete fiction." [0]https://www.jstor.org/stable/3542686 https://www.jstor.org/stable/3542686
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI will admit "complete fiction" was hyperbole. Events in it did happen, but it ignored many other events and his true rationale behind it. This is either what I read or inspired what I read about the issue, https://web.archive.org/web/20170313043444/http://bostonreview.net/hogeland-inventing-alexander-hamilton https://web.archive.org/web/20170313043444/http://bostonrevi...
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoObviously? Growing up, the "cherry tree" story was related to me as gospel truth and absolute fact. I do not know the point at which I discovered it was a legend/myth only, but it was far later than finding out about Santa Claus, I can tell you that.