3 ms·
GeoIP tells you at best what city someone is in, and even then, for smaller towns, will usually report the nearest large city, which could be quite a ways a way
by kelnos 4y ago
GeoIP tells you at best what city someone is in, and even then, for smaller towns, will usually report the nearest large city, which could be quite a ways a way. Not to mention it's often even just flat-out wrong. VPNs and other things distort where you are. Sometimes a website might need (or at least think it needs) correct, fine-grained location information.
I do suspect that most websites that ask for location information could do fine with GeoIP, but that doesn't mean there isn't any use for more reliable, fine-grained location data.
- danielheath 4y agoOkay, but I never told Firefox my location, so what’s it doing that geoip can’t?
- ktosobcy 4y agolike Google and apple - they use exact locations of WiFi hotspots most of the time...
- saagarjha 4y agoThat’s not something a webpage can access.
- shmoe 4y agoIt's something a webpage can access on it's backend (the database of ssid/bssid and their locations) and something your computer uses(the access points its seeing) to locate you in the lack of a gps receiver and saying yes to the browser seeing your location.
- ktosobcy 4y agoBrowsers have geolocation api, webpage uses it. Then browser utilizes underlying OS capabilities to determine the location. On the phone it could use GPS, regular PC may relay on SSID of wifi networks, etc.
- u320 4y agoIn my experience, it will only reliably tell you what country you are in.