4 ms·
AI chatbots used to create dozens of 'news' content farms
- yuliyp 4y agoThe trailing / on the URL causes it to 404 for me.
- anigbrowl 4y agoHN adds it automatically if it's not included, I don't know why it sometimes fails.
- jonny_eh 4y agoPoorly configured web servers
- jstanley 4y agoNot necessarily. "/foo/" and "/foo" are different URLs. In my view HN is wrong to add the trailing slash (if indeed it does do that). I guess it is an effort towards deduplication.
- chmod775 4y agoIt would even be less wrong to remove trailing slashes instead, because it's a path segment separator and there's no segment here after the last the slash. It's a rather odd choice to be adding slashes.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoBetting it was an attempt to change bare domain urls from 'www.example.com' to 'www.example.com/' which is reasonable, but not for something with more path than that.
- jonny_eh 4y agoThey should at least redirect to the correct url.
- timbit42 4y agoNormally a slash indicates a folder on the web site and the server will look for and serve an index.html or index.php file in that folder. Without the slash indicates a filename, even if it doesn't have an extension. That said, there are many sites that rewrite URLs allowing anything to be anything.
- greenyoda 4y agoArchive with full text of article: https://archive.ph/fpvTQ https://archive.ph/fpvTQ
- LeoPanthera 4y agoThis sucks, but it's not surprising. Generating large amounts of spam, quickly, is probably the obvious use for LLMs, and what they're best at.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoThat won't happen, we'll have fact-checking AI chatbots. And if we don't, it's on the user to do their own research and withstand every psychological trick thrown at them, or they deserve to be fooled. The Internet was full of fake news anyway, now there's just more of it. The confetti has left the cannon, this was inevitable, just get used to the new normal you luddites. Oh well. Did I miss any?
- ghaff 4y agoAlthough the most egregious examples are probably fake information, there will be no shortage of simply low signal to noise information that will use sheer quantity to drive out stuff more carefully crafted by people who aren't going for volume.
- kneebonian 4y agoThe problem will be the ability to fabricate digital evidence at scale. What does it mean to research if I can fabricate an entire university complete with domains, professor bios and students all that never existed. Then once I have that I can create a Wikipedia entry, and at that point it's basically fact already because of citogenesis. At this point all digital evidence should be suspect and.we should trust nothing online we don't experience for ourselves in meat space.
- kolinko 4y agoUnless you can steal an actual university's website, fabricating university website won't give you much - a good agent can have a list of sources of truth and proceed from there. Sure, some sources of truth can be compromised, but it will be diffult to breach them all.
- jruohonen 4y agoFaking universities is not a new thing. These have long been known to push fraud involved with paper and certificate mills. Furthermore, even some state authorities have faked universities: https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2019/12/10/who-went-fake-university-farmington-and-why https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2019/12/10/who-went-fake...
- ChuckMcM 4y agoYeah. One of the interesting things about running a search engine (Blekko) was when the crawler would discover web sites that are were "SEO[1] boosters." Under the .tv (Tuvalu the country, not television) domain our crawler found hundreds of "discussion boards" using off the shelf open source phPBB software and, at the time, a text generator based on markov chains, where the entire "discussions" were presumably supposed to look like users discussing the merits of products and recommending one over the competitors. ChatGPT makes this even easier and harder to spot algorithmically. Another of the 1000 cuts in "Internet advertising" that are whittling away at "search advertising" and reducing the margins on those ads. At some point we'll look back on the "age of Google" and trace out its genesis as it killed Alta Vista, to its amazing growth, to its self destruction by relying on network scale to do what it does without protecting itself from adversaries with equivalent scale. [1] SEO, aka Search Engine Optimization, aka the somewhat shady practice of employing tactics in order to get a search engine to rank your content high enough to appear in the organic results.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIt's not game over yet for search engines. There are clever tricks using the scarcity of IPv4 addresses to filter out spam. As well as the possibility of some kind of 'RealID' system.
- ChuckMcM 4y agoActually, I was involved in a project to create LLMs that would give the crawler a better basis for discriminating against spammy adversarial pages. There is a lot that could be done here that is being overlooked. I don't doubt that, had IBM followed up on the research Doug Smith and I started, they would have been a player in the current "AI revolution." That they didn't was an experience similar to one at Google where organizational dynamics rendered the collective group incapable of arriving at an optimal solution.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI take it there was no skunkworks team either?
- faeriechangling 4y agoYeah this was going on LONG before GPT4 or GPT3.5/ChatGPT or even GPT3. It's a huge reason why search engine queries against the general internet have become so unusable and people increasingly get their information from large moderated websites with anti-spam measures.
- jruohonen 4y agoSo it has started already.
- kneebonian 4y agoSo there's a show called leverage in which the idea of generating fake news sites and fake discussion is an important plot element in many episodes for pulling a con on a mark. I've even thought about spinning up a couple of fake news websites myself and populating them with news that I specifically want to push false events or create things that never existed. The way I look at it is you need 2-4 fake news websites, 1-2 fake university websites, and then you can get yourself a Wikipedia article, then a facebook and Twitter account, then for all intents and purposes as far as most people know you've created an entire fake town. Then you can make up whatever fake.nwws or outrage you want for your fake town. The only hard part up until now is producing enough other content to make it stand up to scrutiny, but now with GPT it will be trivial to do so. How long before our news feeds will be filled with fake tragedies that never happened? I can even deepfake news reporters and footage of the event. To illustrate my point how many people even knew east Palestine existed until the train got derailed. What if next week a train gets derailed delivering nuclear waste causing widespread scarring and death in Sesquhoya Wisconsin, complete with news coverage by the local Sesquhoya news channel and victims testimonials. But Sesquhoya never existed, how will that influence discourse and the reliability of the internet? If anyone is interested in discussing the idea more feel free to reach out to me.
- suddenclarity 4y agoHIMYM played with that idea back in 2009 and I'm sure someone tried it in real life. Nowadays when most news articles are ju rewrites, I think there's a decent chance to succeed with your idea. The most difficult step is probably to be credible enough to be picked up by the first newspaper. Once you're in, it will just continue by itself. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0MC55lU_L2E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0MC55lU_L2E
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]