2 ms·
I think perhaps you're reading things into earlier posts that are not there, and then attacking strawmen without realising it. My claims, as you put it, would
by Silhouette 15y ago
I think perhaps you're reading things into earlier posts that are not there, and then attacking strawmen without realising it.
My claims, as you put it, would be that:
(a) without some form of effective incentive for people to create and share works, you are necessarily reduced to volunteer efforts, and
(b) while volunteer effort does produce valuable works, there is little evidence to suggest that such efforts alone would produce a similar quantity and quality of work to what we enjoy today.
These points are relevant because if we're talking about a technology that potentially renders the current legal incentive scheme, copyright, unenforceable, then those who currently produce works using business models built around that scheme have a legitimate concern that they will no longer be able to exercise their legal rights in the that situation.
Since no-one has yet demonstrated a more productive system that is viable on the same scale, that will give Big Media lobbyists a very strong argument that copyright enforcement is necessary to protect the supply of new and high quality works and that all these draconian proposals they keep asking for are the only solution.
And that will lead to another round of SOPA/PIPA/ACTA, but with more politicians on-board. That is worrying because if we don't reach the point this time where serious international copyright reform is on the cards in a way that is both socially acceptable and economically credible, that could be game over for the free Internet as we know it for at least a generation. The wheels of legal systems turn slowly, particularly where international agreements are concerned, and once the lobbyists have got what they want and the popular revolt has died down, we'll be stuck with whatever was left.
- icebraining 15y agoIt seems to me that those claims implicitly rely on another claim: that the elimination of copyright would eliminate the incentive for people to create and share works. My post has three small examples of how the incentive (people paying for works) still exists without copyright. Since no-one has yet demonstrated a more productive system that is viable on the same scale Works that produce profit without relying on copyright have been demonstrated more than once, and are constantly dismissed as flukes. In any case, demonstration of a system without copyright at the same scale is impossible until you actually eliminate/suspend copyright. It's a common case with economics: you'd need multiple identical Earths to create the same conditions. Since no-one has yet demonstrated a more productive system that is viable on the same scale, that will give Big Media lobbyists a very strong argument that copyright enforcement is necessary to protect the supply of new and high quality works and that all these draconian proposals they keep asking for are the only solution. But whether those arguments are valid or not is irrelevant, because they're impossible to conclusively disprove (see above) and that's good enough for them, since what they really want is a decent excuse. And I'm of the opinion that most politicians are looking more for an excuse than for a real argument too.
- Silhouette 15y ago> Works that produce profit without relying on copyright have been demonstrated more than once, and are constantly dismissed as flukes. The thing is, when the same handful of high profile cases get trotted out every time this discussion comes up, they do look like flukes. > In any case, demonstration of a system without copyright at the same scale is impossible until you actually eliminate/suspend copyright. That's a bit of a stretch, though, isn't it? There is nothing in law today that would prevent anyone from building a more effective business model that doesn't depend on copyright, if they can find one. If it's as easy as the copyright opponents make out to produce works without relying on the copyright protections afforded by the law today, why is hardly anyone doing so? Right now, the only people who are making serious money from creative content using alternative business models tend to be keeping that content locked up via technical means so consumers can't just copy it, as with software-as-a-service, pay-per-view TV, and the like. Advertising also works, up to a point, but the serious money there isn't going to the content generators in most cases, it's going to the middlemen like Google and Facebook, and obviously ad-ridden content gives an inferior experience for consumers. > And I'm of the opinion that most politicians are looking more for an excuse than for a real argument too. Perhaps, but they're not all completely clueless, as the hesitation over PIPA/SOPA and ACTA in the face of widespread popular dissent has shown. My concern is that if we don't achieve a fundamental shift in perceptions and attitudes to content production/consumption among the political classes, building on those recent successes, then that will be game over because sooner or later the lobbying will result in the kind of crackdown Big Media wants. This issue needs to become politically toxic, so no-one who needs to be re-elected wants to touch anything associated with Big Media lobbying. That's hardly going to happen if the politicians start seeing lots of "how to avoid being done for copyright infringement" campaigns that convince them the protestors were just an isolated group of criminals anyway and Big Media was right all along.