4 ms·
The socratic method has an awful failure mode: you can't teach facts, and you can't teach anything derived from empiric data. The periodic table of the element
by dsr_ 15y ago
The socratic method has an awful failure mode: you can't teach facts, and you can't teach anything derived from empiric data.
The periodic table of the elements has a lovely underlying theory based on the physical properties of electron orbitals. This cannot be elicited from students who don't know it.
Asking socratic questions about the effects of drugs on human bodies is useless.
Don't trust a socratic-trained engineer to build your skyscraper, or your pizza oven.
- m_for_monkey 15y agoIt is only one (very useful) tool in the toolbox.
- hythloday 15y ago> The periodic table of the elements has a lovely underlying theory based on the physical properties of electron orbitals. This cannot be elicited from students who don't know it. Of course you can't give students a periodic table and Socratically enquire how this came to be. What you can do is, through the Socratic method, elicit an understanding of the lovely underlying theory. That's far more valuable than being able to parrot the table from memory without understanding it. I'm not sure what you mean by not being able to teach from empiric data--experiments seem to me to be a practical implementation of the Socratic method.
- jmilloy 15y agoFacts are useful but not always the end goal; in Bloom's taxonomy, this is the first/base kind of understanding. Sometimes we can ask questions and elicit the gathering of facts, but not always. Once the information has been gathered, we can use the socratic method to aid in each of the other five types (comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation). So you're right, sometimes you can't teach the facts. But you can definitely teach anything derived from empiric data... how was it derived in the first place? I think you can provide the data (in class experiments, a trip to the library, real research papers, etc), and then elicit discussion about what it means.
- wisty 15y agoIt can be used to teach facts. Facts aren't just facts, they are the context around facts. You can't just learn that steel has a UTS of 500 MPa with a density of 7.8 g/cm^3, while aluminium has a UTS of 50 MPa with a density of 2.8 g/cm3. You could ask students which material is used to build planes, and then discuss which material would be better. At some point, you'll need to introduce the exact figures, but that's a small portion of the lesson. There's a reason why the back page of a textbook can hold most of the facts that the other 300 pages teaches - information and knowledge are mutually inclusive.