3 ms·
> Your comment was about how rare deaths were for COVID-19 for the cohort you selected. Now do deaths from vaccines for the same cohort. The emphasized part is
by rayiner 4y ago
> Your comment was about how rare deaths were for COVID-19 for the cohort you selected. Now do deaths from vaccines for the same cohort.
The emphasized part is you moving the goalposts. If you want to assert that already low-risk individuals can further reduce their death rate using the vaccine (undoubtedly true), then it's entirely fair to ask whether doing so creates unknown, long-term risks.
For your younger people--who are unlikely to die from either COVID or the vaccine--the long-tail risks of a brand new category of vaccine are meaningful. My kids shrugged off COVID (before the vaccine was available) in half a day. We gave them the vaccines anyway, because we're sheeple. Hopefully, these new mRNA vaccines behave just like traditional vaccines and don't create any additional long-term risks. But let's not pretend we have decades of experience with these vaccines to prove that fact.
- baseballdork 4y ago> The emphasized part is you moving the goalposts. If you want to assert that already low-risk individuals can further reduce their death rate using the vaccine (undoubtedly true), then it's entirely fair to ask whether doing so creates unknown, long-term risks. Hard disagree. Unknown, long-term risks apply equally to both. However, I'd agree to mutually change the goal posts. Do deaths and long term damage for both vaccines and COVID-19 in the cohort. > But let's not pretend we have decades of experience with these vaccines to prove that fact. We also don't have decades of experience with COVID-19...
- rayiner 4y agoExcept since the vaccines don’t prevent you from getting covid, the long term risks you’re comparing are: risks from covid versus risks from covid plus risks from the vaccine.
- baseballdork 4y agoCitation needed.
- runsWphotons 4y agoYou need a citation for the claim the vaccines don't prevent covid or transmission of covid?
- baseballdork 4y agoYes? Do you just accept blanket claims like that without thought?
- JamesBarney 4y agoIt seems like your argument is [value of vaccine] = [reduction in death] - [unknown long term risks of vaccine] And if you're risk of death is low enough that swamps the third term. But I think you're modeling this incorrectly. It's actually [value of vaccine] = [reduction in death] - [unknown long term risks of vaccine] + [unknown long term risks of novel virus] And this case it almost always makes sense to take the vaccine.
- rayiner 4y agoYour equation assumes the vaccine prevents you from getting covid, which it doesn’t. Many people I know got covid multiple times after being vaccinated. So the risk of long term effects from covid are baked in. On top of that, you add any additional risks from the vaccine.
- JamesBarney 4y agoIt assumes that the vaccine greatly reduces your risk of sequelae from Covid because the infection is much milder.
- runsWphotons 4y agoThe vaccines are certainly more harmful for certain groups, like young men and more likely to cause certain conditions (like retinal occlusion).
- baseballdork 4y agoCitation needed.