3 ms·
There is one professor at my course that used the socratic method. Those are some of the best lectures I've been to. A lot of professors think they're using th
by Swizec 15y ago
There is one professor at my course that used the socratic method. Those are some of the best lectures I've been to.
A lot of professors think they're using the Socratic method, but their problem is they don't have the patience to wait for an answer. Posing questions rhetorically doesn't work, especially once the people you are teaching catch on and stop trying to come up with an answer.
I've tried doing the socratic method when tutoring people - it's extremely frustrating and most of the time I can't pull it off.
How does one gain the necessary patience for this?
- knieveltech 15y agoThis may not be simply an issue of patience. It's tough to put yourself so throughly in your audience's headspace that you can pull off the right kind of leading questions consistently. Sometimes you get an audience that you just can't seem to model effectively enough to pull this off with. Most of the time the biggest stumbling block is actually getting the audience to actively participate. A lot of (most?) people are used to the standard I'm-going-to-stand-here-and-spray-at-you method of lecturing so getting past that can take some work.
- jonsen 15y agoPosing questions rhetorically doesn't work, ... Well it works for me, even if there's only time to think: Now that's an interesting question, what would be the answer to that?
- spqr 15y agoWhat kind of an idiot are you, anyway?
- meric 15y agoI do like it when the lecturer asks a question genuinely expecting an answer from the class. When it does happen, however, the class takes so long to respond I can't wait to just throw out a likely wrong answer to move the lecture on.
- anigbrowl 15y agoIt's also very tough on the student if they don't know where something is going, and it's not suitable for every sort of learning. It's great for reasoning from first principles as in philosophy (where we want to wrestle with deep abstractions but don't need more than basic a priori knowledge to do so).And it's great for building on top of domain knowledge (as in law schools where students read the facts of a case and its procedural history in advance, and then the professor challenges students to explain why a case got decided a particular way). But as a means for acquiring domain knowledge - gathering facts rather than technique, and building those facts into a context - it's quite inefficient. Another problem is that it's not very responsive to the needs of weak students - teachers are likely to put most of their attention on the good students who can sustain long causal chains of reasoning rather than weak (or shy) ones who get stuck or intimidated, and the more advanced the exchange between the professor and a strong student, the harder it can be for bystanders to keep up. One way of testing a student is to bait them with what seems like an easy question that will lead them off point into a dead end; this is potentially humiliating for the student if the teacher is aggressive (which then dilutes the lesson somewhat with negative emotions, both for the student and possibly sympathetic onlookers). If the student is sharp enough to see the trap and deflect or decline a series of invitations to error, the chain of reasoning that links the points of a complex argument together gets 'stretched out' and onlookers may lose sight of the overall direction or (worse) fail to appreciate the potential pitfalls that the teacher is drawing attention to because they are being skillfully avoided.
- cruise02 15y agoWhen tutoring I use the Socratic method to find out where a student is stuck. If I ask them a question that they don't know the answer to, I back up a little and ask a different question that should help lead them to the answer to the first. (It helps a lot that I tutor math and programming, two subjects where topics build logically on simpler topics.)