7 ms·
Uncle Sam may do something about rampant visa H-1B fraud
- lsllc 4y agoDupe, discussed yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35778508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35778508
- boringuser2 4y agoReally? Companies are cynically using visa programs no native citizen ever asked for or wanted because they are nothing but an avenue for large corporations to enslave foreign workers with salaries that no American would ever tolerate? It should be reduced commensurrately for every tech layoff. Given that we're in the negatives, it's probably time to start cancelling some visas.
- flavius29663 4y agoyou don't want to cancel visas, it would wreak havoc on families and lives. But you can definitely reduce the number of new visas
- boringuser2 4y agoI'm sorry, but American citizens aren't to blame for this and don't need to shoulder this burden.
- piva00 4y agoAmerican citizens got, collectively, an advantage by exploiting these people. As much as you didn't want them there, they have been working and providing value to your society, and paying taxes. In the end they are not only exploited by the companies taking advantage of a broken system but also now some citizens (you) think they should be punished even more by being kicked out of a place they create roots at. The lack of empathy is, frankly, astounding...
- boringuser2 4y agoI like how you think empathy only exists when it isn't being directed towards people you like. It's just such a cynical and emotionally manipulative conceit to demand that your group (I've perused your history and am aware you're an immigrant) be treated with "empathy", which is something you reserve entirely for your own benefit. If other people thought like you, you wouldn't get any at all.
- piva00 4y agoI like how you only attacked me and not even tried to acknowledge you are lacking empathy by wanting to kick people out of a place due to some misplaced anger :) You are aware you can want the current immigration system to change without causing massive harm to some people, right? They are people, with lives, just like you, not some faceless cog in a machine that you can decide doesn't suit you anymore and be thrown out. It's not cynical and manipulative to remind yourself that these are lives, not a fucking number, we are talking about. Good luck with your anger, hopefully you can find healthier and more productive ways to express it.
- boringuser2 4y agoYou are incredibly emotionally manipulative. Perhaps you should remember yourself that the lives destroyed by companies outsourcing American wealth (both directly and indirectly via immigration) had a real cost on real people.
- piva00 4y agoYou are incredibly dim. Of course it had a real cost on real people, immigration to the USA causes a continuous brain drain in multiple countries that could use the skilled labour for their own benefits. I don't dispute that at all. Outsourcing American wealth causing these companies to become wealthier, maybe it's time you direct your anger somewhere else, somewhere which is actually causing this issue, no? Instead of punishing workers who immigrated and generated wealth for your society. I can give you a tip: point it towards corporations :) Good luck, mate.
- welshwelsh 4y ago"American citizens" are usually just people who, by no fault and no merit of their own, happen to have been born in the United States. Frankly, this shouldn't give them the right to decide who else gets to come to the US and on what terms. But putting that aside, when Americans issue a visa, they are forming a contract with another person that they are obligated to honor. When someone uproots their life to come to the US by following the rules created by Americans, it would be unconscionable to exploit them and then fail to honor the visa.
- flavius29663 4y ago> "American citizens" are usually just people who, by no fault and no merit of their own, happen to have been born in the United States. Frankly, this shouldn't give them the right to decide who else gets to come to the US and on what terms. As an immigrant to the US, I disagree, it's the right of existing Americans to decide how many and what type of new immigrants they accept in their own country. The same way a person born into a rich family -through no merit of their own- has the right to decide who they want to marry and benefit from the riches.
- pfannkuchen 4y ago> Frankly, this shouldn't give them the right to decide who else gets to come to the US and on what terms. Who should decide, then? This view is both undemocratic and anti self determination.
- localplume 4y agoYes that is how citizenship mostly works. That is life. Americans absolutely should have the right to decide who comes to work in the US and on what terms. Unbridled immigration and open borders would be a disaster for everyone involved. America isn't a welfare state for the world. Additionally, H-1B visas are nonimmigrant visas. Workers are aware of this. They are not permanent. If they treat it like its permanent, that is their own fault. Would it be better if USCIS was streamlined? Absolutely. Thats why fraud needs to be cut down and bureaucratic bloat needs to be reduced.
- blululu 4y agoSorry but I have to take a strong disagreement with the claim that anyone has just as much of a right to live in America. Maybe in some highly abstracted form you could say that is America is just job opportunity but for those of us who were born here, it is our home. Our families are here, our lives are here. I'm sure lots of people are more qualified to write Java apps than the native population of America, but America is more than a factory for Java apps. It is communities, cultures and people. Saying that those communities should please make room for anyone who wants a job is just really insensitive and entitled. You see the same thing play out at a local level with gentrification. The people who have built a functional community are squeezed out the moment a large tech company wants to take over the housing stock for a bunch of transplants. The locals are pushed to the margins and a bunch of yuppy tech workers puzzle over why everyone hates them. There is an element of fairness in thinking that we are all the same, but I think you would feel differently if it were your family and friends getting pushed out from the home they built up for a generation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- edgyquant 4y agoThis is always the excuse given, while no one seems to care about the Americans who are passed up by companies exploiting these programs.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoPunish visa holders because of corporate fraud? That does not make any sense.
- belltaco 4y agoIt does make sense in the context of what has been happening with low skill immigration from the south of the border. Punish the workers being abused and let companies doing that off the hook. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/08/09/workplace-raids-multiply-trump-administration-charges-few-companies/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/08/09/workplace...
- flavius29663 4y agoI explicitly called out "issuing fewer new visas" - how is that not protecting US workers? It seems like preconceived ideas stopped you from reading my comment. A lot of people on visas come and go, not all are establishing a new life in the US. Issuing less new visas will reduce the total number over time, without having to destroy the lives of the ones already established.
- amluto 4y agoI would rather see more visas issued, but I want them to be on better terms. A visa holder should be able to change jobs and even go through a period of unemployment without losing their visa. And, critically for citizens and permanent residents, they should be able to negotiate salaries as well as anyone else. As far as I can tell, importing a moderate amount of skilled labor is good for America and its people. But importing that same labor and underpaying for it is worse for all involved, including for citizens whose wages or opportunistic are depressed as a result.
- welshwelsh 4y agoBeing able to switch jobs is critical; the existence of workers who are unable to quit is devastating to worker's rights. I would prefer if we had better visas with higher salary requirements, designed to attract the world's best, but without making them jump through hoops. E.g. Someone making $250k = green card instantly. Someone making $80k = denied, try again when you are worth $250k.
- flavius29663 4y agoor just take the top N visas based on income (which is based on a solid work offer). Lottery makes no sense.
- amluto 4y agoThis sounds like an auction. That seems kind of sensible, but I'm concerned it would prevent any but the highest paying industries from using H-1B visas. In theory, the purpose is to import specific skills and expertise that is unavailable locally. So if US company needs, say, a plastic tooling engineer, and only China and Taiwan trains enough people with the relevant experience [0], then they should be able to hire someone from outside the US and help them get a visa. Making them outbid the tech giants who are in entirely different industries could drive the cost up to absurd levels and deny the US the benefit of getting plastic tooling expertise. [0] I made this up, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were true.
- Symmetry 4y agoI sort of wonder if it wouldn't be best to auction off the new visas to companies rather than assign them by lottery. Then they go to the companies their most valuable to and the government gets some revenue.
- belltaco 4y ago> Companies are cynically using visa programs no native citizen ever asked for or wanted because they are nothing but an avenue for large corporations to enslave foreign workers with salaries that no American would ever tolerate? Categorically false, go look at the public H1B salary data for large companies and you will see very competitive salaries. If anything, they're on the higher end, much less "no American would ever tolerate". If you just revoke visas, those workers in those jobs and the jobs will be nearshored to Canada/Mexico offices, and new jobs will either be offshored and nearshored. This means the money paid to the workers will go out of the US economy, hurting supporting non-tech jobs. Newer members of the team are likely to be recruited in those places rather than the US, hurting tech workers. This has already been happening. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/08/business/dealbook/h1b-visas-us-jobs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/08/business/dealbook/h1b-vis...
- droopyEyelids 4y agoLarge companies don't get many of the H1B visas overall, and they generally aren't the ones abusing the H1B visa process. Last I saw, something like 80%+ of H1Bs went to bodyshops like Infosys and TCS, which certainly don't pay well, and definitely do make their employees live somewhere where job swapping isn't easy.
- belltaco 4y agoIn the top 15 for 2022 I see Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Facebook/Meta, AWS, Apple, Intel, Walmart, JP Morgan Chase.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoThanks I stand corrected
- piva00 4y agoIsn't there a salary threshold requirement for H-1Bs? I thought it was a common practice to have a minimum threshold salary for high-skilled visas in developed countries, I know that at least Germany, Sweden, Netherlands and Denmark have such in place exactly to avoid the practice of depressing salaries in the local labour market.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blululu 4y agoYes but it was set in ~1990 and never adjusted for inflation. It is still about $60,000 a year which was a lot of money 30 years ago. The program was intended to enable companies to hire people with unique skills that are unavailable anywhere else. A salary that is below bottom quartile of entry level CS grads does not reflect that reality.
- hwbehrens 4y agoThis is misleading, because the Prevailing Wage also applies based on the average wage by geographic area. This means that Bay Area H1B workers have a minimum wage of something north of $125K/yr depending on their area of expertise. It's still a bit low, but it's not laughably low like the $60K absolute minimum. You can search the database here: https://flcdatacenter.com/OESWizardStart.aspx https://flcdatacenter.com/OESWizardStart.aspx
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI am extremely happy that this country allows people from around the world to come here and try to have a better life. It’s heartless that you’re against that and insulting that you think the rest of the country is too. Educated labor is what makes this country the innovation capital of the world.
- morsecodist 4y agoSo you are complaining that these workers are enslaved by the threat of not having visas and you are advocating for cancelling those visas, subjecting the holders to the penalty they are accepting low salaries to try to avoid?
- belltaco 4y agoYes, that's what they want and that's how it has been played out in the past for unskilled workers, while companies doing and profiting from the abuse and hurting both the immigrants and citizens go scot free. https://apnews.com/article/immigration-donald-trump-us-news-ap-top-news-arrests-e7113c50a6fd4d2688fc2f2b8a9a91cd https://apnews.com/article/immigration-donald-trump-us-news-...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI think companies should only be able to use H1-B workers for 10 years. 10 years is enough time to invest in recruiting training American workers for the roles. H1-B should be a temporary bandaid, not something permanent.
- rr808 4y agoTraining people sucks because people have no loyalty. I've trained up a bunch of people, six months later they quit to move somewhere else, unless they suck then they likely stick around.
- ElevenLathe 4y agoHave you tried offering a competitive salary in addition to the training?
- belltaco 4y agoThe company the already trained worker is jumping to doesn't have to bear the cost of the training or paying the salary for 6 months like their company already did, so they can always pay better.
- ElevenLathe 4y agoThe training company can pay below-market while they are doing the training, but will obviously need to up the pay to market rate once the worker is trained.
- belltaco 4y agoPaying below market is still a cost with no guarantee that the worker will stay on. It's more advantageous to hire someone who was already trained in such a manner at a different company.
- 4y ago
- manuelabeledo 4y agoEvery time this topic comes up, I see a bunch of comments here in HN claiming that H-1B should pretty much be abolished, and/or visa holders should be returning to their countries of origin and replaced by American workers. I became a permanent resident not that long ago. It's an arduous and complicated path. Navigating US bureaucracy is an extremely complex endeavor, and one requires the help of several, very specialized professionals, to get to their goal. Knowing all this, I want to ask, why should someone who has worked that hard to settle in the US, has contributed greatly to the economy, behaved properly and never had issues with law and authority, be expelled from the country? Isn't the US government targeting the companies committing fraud, a better and more just path forward?
- kapperchino 4y agoBetter way is probably to give a fast path to citizenship for existing h1b workers but then abolishing the system for new applicants
- manuelabeledo 4y agoI would agree if the proposal was to rebuild the system to make it more equitable and more resilient to fraud. I don't see how the US would remain competitive without a proper way in for skilled immigrants.
- kapperchino 4y agoFor sure need to rebuild the system, to make it more equitable. Currently the h1b visa holders are easier to exploit as they are sponsored by corporations, and they have a time limit before they get kicked out.
- kapperchino 4y agoSo what could be done is to make it a time system where a corporation needs to buy a minimum of 2 years let’s say of a person’s visa.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]
- genmud 4y agoI have always thought there should be a floor on salary that put these positions in the top 10%, plus a requirement that they fund a scholarship or training program in the same amount as the salary. With the 2 H1Bs that I have hired, it would still have been worth it and anything less is just a program to artificially reduce costs for companies.
- LinuxBender 4y agoThat might curtail some of the massage parlors in the bay area. They are all H1B in massage and acupuncture. There is a whole industry behind it, getting people citizenship by finding lonely men. They target lonely guys in the tech industry, marry them and in some cases drain their assets and sometimes also take corporate secrets. I used to think it was all about selling sex but it turned out that was just the way to get people in the door. I went down this rabbit hole when the parlors would get mad at me for wanting an actual massage.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoThis is patently untrue, and easily disproved because H-1B data is publicly available. Only six people got a H-1B visa under the premise of working as massage specialists, since 2012 [0] [0] https://www.h1bdata.org/jobs/31-901100/massage-therapists https://www.h1bdata.org/jobs/31-901100/massage-therapists
- LinuxBender 4y agoIt's a temp work visa specific to those trades. They said H1B but maybe they meant something else. There are thousands of them in the bay area alone. In each parlor only 1 person spoke english. It was hard enough to get them to use more force. Oh, I should share that lesson learned. Whatever you do, when trying to get the parlor owner to translate "harder", don't use the phase "make me cry".
- manuelabeledo 4y agoAgain, H-1B numbers are public, and do not back your comments.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- screye 4y agoEvery post about H1B misuse leads to people eventually talking about the validity of the H1B itself. So, I'll dive straight in. There is no good way to talk about H1-Bs without first talking about one's values around immigration. Do they they support immigration and what shapes their opinion about high skilled immigration. A majority of Americans are off-springs of a living immigrant ancestor (1st, 2nd and 3rd gen immigrants). A conservative extrapolation would put them at 66% of the population[1]. I have no empathy for any one from this majority that completely opposes immigration. It's 'I got mine' style hypocrisy. The other 33% have various reasons for opposing immigration. But, depending on the type immigration that is made legal, it's possible to address every type of concern. For example: 1. Poverty/crime/economy related complaints due to low skill immigration ---> enable high skill immigrants. Overwhelmingly low-crime & a huge net positive for the economy. 2. Culture related complaints ---> enable US education based immigration. Let them be explicitly indoctrinated into American-ness. 3. Low-wage / job stealing ---> set an income based lower bound. H1bs already require salaries to match the local median. But, I'd even support more aggressive percentile requirements. Do people not understand the around $20-30k/yr overhead that employing immigrants entails. (applications, lawyers, lottery risks, multiple rounds of secondary interviews for LCA) ? L1-visas are cheap. H1Bs are fairly expensive. There are many more such angles, but I have yet to hear a cohesive argument for a blanket ban on immigration that isn't a thinly veiled concern about demographic replacement of the descendants of earlier settlers. Now, I am mildly sympathetic to that argument too. In a dog-eat-dog world, their ancestors replaced the local population of the British Isles and then North America. The world is cruel, and only the paranoid survive. Would be a lot easier to then debate around those points, because the statistics on contributions to the economy and lack of social delinquency are in favor of H1Bs when compared to the descendants of the early settlers. I'll keep it at that. HN does not encourage culture-warring. I'll abide. [1] https://news.gallup.com/poll/4621/majority-americans-identify-themselves-third-generation-americans.aspx#:~:text=3-,SUMMARY%20TABLE,-Immigrant https://news.gallup.com/poll/4621/majority-americans-identif...