2 ms·
Is this much different to a shop needing ID to sell a pornographic magazine, to avoid selling it to a minor?
by robertlagrant 4y ago
Is this much different to a shop needing ID to sell a pornographic magazine, to avoid selling it to a minor?
- jdiff 4y agoDon't need an ID to buy a tablet. Or a used phone. Or back in the day, a Nintendo DS or PSP even. I'm sure I still have a PSP Memory Stick around here someone with saucy pixel art stashed away in the bookmarks. This is a genie that hasn't been in a bottle since the internet was born and it won't be put back in one now. At least not like this.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI don't see how that relates to whether or not this is a maximalist approach.
- jdiff 4y agoIt relates to the question you asked, there's a difference between a physical store and a website, and the difference between uploading a copy of your ID to a porn website and letting a cashier glance at your ID for a moment is substantial. Porn is accessible on the open web. You can't plug all the leaks or even most of them, it's just not possible to put the genie back in its pre-internet bottle. Smut is out there and if sought, it will be found.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI'm not saying there's no difference. I'm saying it doesn't seem like a maximalist approach. Both a website and a cashier could choose to not record your ID.
- DoItToMe81 4y agoShowing your ID isn't something that can be stored and leaked later. It also doesn't have the same stifling effect on speech that a normalized internet ID would have. They're two fundamentally different things.
- Auracle 4y agoSure, but the store wouldn’t keep a database keeping track of exactly what porn you bought. It’s also like having stores check IDs when other porn is just floating by on the wind with regularity. Even if all of the major porn websites did checks there’s still Twitter, Telegram, Reddit, Google/Bing image search, torrents…
- robertlagrant 4y ago> It’s also like having stores check IDs when other porn is just floating by on the wind with regularity I suppose this does indeed happen, if you count the internet as the wind.