3 ms·
until about 20 years ago license plates were a reasonable compromise between privacy and accountability: they didn't have your name on them, and looking you up
by kragen 4y ago
until about 20 years ago license plates were a reasonable compromise between privacy and accountability: they didn't have your name on them, and looking you up from the number could only be done by the police, who would only do it when it seemed important, and then only if someone made a note of the plate
they couldn't, for example, make a list of everyone who was parked near a protest, and then search a database to see where they were parked over the next two weeks
modern computer vision has changed all that, giving rise to massive dragnet surveillance; we should figure out how to get back the privacy we've lost
i don't think taping dead leaves to your license plate is going to solve the problem
prohibiting police from using computer vision isn't it either; they'll just buy the data from a private vendor like ring
- jjtheblunt 4y agoYou made me realize the painful difficulty in defining a distinction between legit use by police (which is occasionally used catching stolen cars, etc, and which makes the news) and creepy Orwellian surveillance.
- Pet_Ant 4y agoSorry, but do the police actually use these powers to arrest thieves and return stolen vehicles? Or is it like when you can point to the house that your stolen iPhone is in and the police say they can't do anything.
- 20after4 4y agoExactly. No they do not use these powers to return stolen cars. Stolen cars only get returned very extremely rarely and only if it's convenient for the police. They don't lift an extra finger to recover stolen property.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoI used to have a neighbor who didn't even know that his car was stolen until he got a call from the police at 6AM. It's not like they towed it back to his house, but at least he was aware of where it was.
- 20after4 4y agoA friend had their car stolen in St. Louis. Police did nothing, even though the location of the vehicle was known and the person who stole it was identified. When police did nothing, eventually the owner recovered the car themself when they found it abandoned. They got it repaired and reported it not-stolen. 3 months later they got pulled over and dragged out of the car at gunpoint, handcuffed, arrested, etc. For stealing their own car. Edit: My point is, police will absolutely arrest someone driving a stolen car. They love to arrest people, that's their main business. Recovering property isn't their main business and they actively avoid it. Generally police will not go to a specific location to recover a vehicle that's been stolen but now is sitting in someone's driveway, for example. I'm sure there are exceptions but I am fairly confident that stolen car recovery is rare and generally happens only if they catch someone actively driving around with the stolen car and the same license plates which have been recorded as belonging to a stolen vehicle.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoIt's just an anecdote, but living in the same place where the incident I mentioned earlier happened, I was really surprised when I called in a report that I had seen my bicycle, reported stolen weeks before, being ridden in a certain neighborhood and not only did they send over a police officer to take a statement, he actually tracked it down and brought it back with suspect in the back of his car. Unfortunately, it turned out not to be my bike: just same make/model/color with a bike shop sticker in the same location as mine. And this in a city that at the time had a county-wide reputation for high crime.
- flangola7 4y agoNewer systems don't even need a license plate, they learn the overall appearance of the car.
- InCityDreams 4y agoIf only there were some way to then differentiate between the various models.
- aix1 4y ago> Newer systems don't even need a license plate, they learn the overall appearance of the car. I'm probably missing some context, but what do you mean by this? If you take two cars that are the same model/year/colour, how do you differentiate between them on the basis of appearance?
- mock-possum 4y agoScratches and bumps and scars, stickers and decor, stuff in the window or hanging from the rear view, maybe tires
- zamnos 4y agoTint of the windows. The appearance of the driver if the tint isn't very high.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoI would think the best way to counteract this is to use computer vision systems to detect cameras and shine lasers or bright point sources of light at them.
- prepend 4y agoThat seems like a mention in William Gibson’s next book- a dash mounted laser that tracks traffic cameras and targets a beam to block the recording as the car moves.
- gorbypark 4y agoI believe we need to move to e ink (or similar tech) based licence plates. The numbers would change every few minutes but still would be cryptographically tied to an owner if you both have a time stamp and a proper decryption key. The idea would be that if you had the proper authorization (police, DMV, etc) and a time stamp you could see the owner of a vehicle, but it would hinder 3rd party private alpr dragnet systems. It wouldn’t change much for entities like police, but it could put in place a system of accountability (ie: decryption rules set at the state level instead of local level, etc)
- CharlieDigital 4y agoLike the idea, but the failure rate and cost would be too high. Also, police would end up having blanket authorization just like they do now.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoSomeone was just shot for accidentally getting into the wrong car. It's not unusual around here to have a row of identical cars in, e.g., a Walmart parking lot. How do you propose people recognize their own vehicles if the license plate numbers are constantly changing?
- kragen 4y agobumper stickers, custom paint jobs, or just not buying identical cars in the first place? this seems like an absurdly self-inflicted problem if you're banging your head on the wall and it hurts, you could stop?
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoWell, that's a nicely dismissive answer! So your suggestion is that people avoid purchasing cars that happen to be very popular in their general area and if they can't (or won't) avoid that, paint it differently or affix bumper stickers?
- 4y ago
- arp242 4y ago> prohibiting police from using computer vision isn't it either; they'll just buy the data from a private vendor like ring The answer to this would be to legislate what data private vendors like ring can and can't collect. In the end I feel legislation is really the only option; some fancy stuff with crypto like one of the other commenters mentions sounds both complex and error-prone to implement and have it work well, and also risks being cracked either by reverse-engineering or just leaked decryption keys. And if $entity wants to track your car – or anything else – they can probably do so anyway one way or the other. The only real option without having to play whack-a-mole is decent legislation.
- dmm 4y agoNew cars don't even need license plates to be tracked. They transmit telemetry over 5G. The car companies sell this data to whoever they want, including law enforcement. Right now you can probably disable the cell radio by disconnecting the antenna but if that becomes popular I have no doubts that cars will be changed to refuse to operate without regular connections. The recent infrastructure bill (H.R. 3684) includes a requirement for cars to have anti-drunk driving tech included, which includes driver-facing cameras. All of this data will be sold to the highest bidder.