3 ms·
> There was a time when the "Internet" could if you squinted right be defined as "the collection of people who make fun of that process and do the opposite" Ar
by pornel 15y ago
> There was a time when the "Internet" could if you squinted right be defined as "the collection of people who make fun of that process and do the opposite"
Are those the same guys who brought FTP upon us? BGP? 32-bit IP addresses?
There were few moments where it would be better if somebody said, wait a minute, we need to think first, then code.
- tptacek 15y agoYes, and this is the same shotgun process that managed to avoid congestion collapse. Not by spending 6 years fretting about it, but by writing the TCP stack in 4.3BSD-Tahoe. 32 bit addresses were a good idea. It's easy to look back on it now and say "they should have used 128 bit integers", but until recently, 32 bit addresses were the largest addresses that worked as scalars in all mainstream platforms.
- cbs 15y ago>FTP upon us? BGP? 32-bit IP addresses? Those are effectively entrenched de facto standards, but its not the fault of the creators, its the fault of the people unwilling to move with the times. I'm not cool enough to run an AS, but I know for the other two better alternatives are already here. As Vint Cerf has said, 32 bits was enough for an experiment, it just never ended. IPv6 and SFTP are here and _in use_ by anyone who isn't clinging on to old tech like people clung to IE6. >we need to think first, then code Thinking first, implementing and then improving is how technology advances. Iteration is mandatory, otherwise you're stuck in a waterfall-type scenario. Without it, I sure hope you enjoy riding your horse down to the local Gutenburg press to pick up this week's HackerNews and read my comment there.
- pornel 15y ago> its the fault of the people unwilling to move with the times. It's the network effect. Once something is "out there", it's really, really hard to get rid of it. If the first version that reaches critical mass has unfixable flaws, you'll be stuck with them forever. I don't blame Vint, he couldn't have idea how successful the experiment is going to be, but I can't read HN over IPv6. But now we know how web standards spread and stick around forever. HTML5 special-cases parsing of <XMP> element. CSS has quirks mode, almost standards mode and standards mode and two syntaxes for clip().