2 ms·
How is 5 years of security updates all that bad? Apple IIRC does around 7 years, and has the luxury of 100% control over their hardware and the firmware/softwa
by kelnos 4y ago
How is 5 years of security updates all that bad? Apple IIRC does around 7 years, and has the luxury of 100% control over their hardware and the firmware/software stack that runs on it.
I agree that 3 years of major OS upgrades is frustratingly short.
(Edit: See end of post for correction; following paragraphs are incorrect.)
But really, complain to Qualcomm. They're the ones who refuse to support their chipsets and keep moving on to the next new thing. It took years of negotiation for Google to even wring 5 years of security support out of them.
The only alternative is a new SoC vendor that can beat (or at least compete with) Qualcomm on price/performance/heat/power consumption. Good luck with that. For whatever reason, Samsung's Exynos seems to be constantly behind the competition, and Samsung even doesn't use it for all their phones. If Samsung can't do it, with all their resources, what chance does a new upstart have?
Really, I just wish, for the good of humanity, Apple would open up their chips to third-party buyers. Of course they never will, and I get why, but it's still frustrating.
Edit: didn't realize Google's Tensor was the main SoC for current-gen Pixels; for some reason I thought the Tensor chip was a co-processor paired with a Snapdragon. In that case: shame on Google for only offering 3 years of OS upgrades and 5 years of security upgrades, when they likely have the ability to do more.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoQualcomm don't make the Pixel SoC, mate. Google makes the Tensor, that's how they're now able to offer 3 years of OS updates and 5 years of security updates.
- kelnos 4y agoThank you for the correction; for some reason I thought the Tensor was a co-processor, paired with a Snapdragon chipset. In that case, there's really no excuse for Google not to offer longer support (well, aside from their own desire to spend less and push people to buy new phones), unless they've farmed out parts of the design and firmware to a third party who won't give them better terms.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoMost devices offer a 1 or 2 year warranty. 3 years of OS updates and 5 years of security updates sounds pretty decent. You'll no longer be able to fix it and get replacement parts for it before you stop getting updates for it. Pixel is 1 year warranty in the USA.
- mindslight 4y agoThe Linux kernel, GNU, et al have done decades of security updates, on hardware they don't control at all. > didn't realize Google's Tensor was the main SoC for current-gen Pixels; for some reason I thought the Tensor chip was a co-processor paired with a Snapdragon Hah. I thought the exact same until someone set me straight in an HN comment. Which is actually what led to me buying the Pixel 7 (I'm dead set against the probably-still-insecure Qualcomm baseband+application processor combo; my S7 is an Exynos). IMO, the Qualcomm software support problem could be fixed with sufficient right to repair legislation.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoThis isn't the same thing whatsoever. This frequently involves reverse engineering, see Asahi Linux for an example. That also doesn't mean that things work well or in their entirety, e.g., dock connectors on ThinkPads might not work. Google is a corp that is bound by the laws of the USA. If they were to reverse engineer a SoC by Qualcomm, they may infringe on their intellectual property rights amidst other issues. Not to mention, it's much easier to make their own chip, which they have done. Third-parties sometimes write alternatives like e/OS and LineageOS, but the devices they're written for are seldom functionally complete, just like Linux isn't in terms of hardware support a lot of the time.