3 ms·
Australia to ban non-prescription vapes in biggest smoking reforms in a decade
- binarymax 4y agoThis is great to see and I hope other nations follow suit.
- superchroma 4y agoConventional cigarettes are of course untouched. By not banning them outright but instead taxing them outrageously, Australia has created a rich black market for cigarettes.
- Veliladon 4y agoThe black market is around 12% in Australia despite the high taxes because Australia is a country isolated on all sides by ocean. Compared to somewhere like New York where the taxes are equally punitive but smuggled cigs make up 50% of consumption. It's a problem in that Border Force (a ridiculous name for a border inspection agency) look for it but in general there's not an easy way to smuggle cigs like taking a uhaul full of them from NH to NYC.
- arcticbull 4y agoOr similarly by boat between the US and Canada. Especially through First Nations communities like in Akwesasne. [1] [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/akwesasne-irs-tobacco-smuggling-investigation-1.5253872 https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/akwesasne-irs-tobacco-smu...
- unmole 4y ago> Border Force (a ridiculous name for a border inspection agency) It's a uniformed service that enforces Australia's border controls. Far from being ridiculous, I can't think of a more appropriate name.
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoI think for me at least it's the "Force" part of the agency name. It sounds very militarized and American to me where something like "Border Control Agency" wouldn't sound as ridiculous
- bexsella 4y agoI would be all for a real push to follow in New Zealand's footsteps in enforcing a date of birth cut-off. Cigarettes, and nicotine generally, are horrendous and aside from having impacted me personally, put an unnecessary drain on public resources. They are wholly bad, and the rhetoric I've heard from people stating "you have to die of something" is, to me, entirely selfish thinking.
- DaveExeter 4y agoYeah, but smoking makes you look cool.
- missingdays 4y agoDoes it?
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoAre they a drain on public resources though? I’ve read that non-smokers have higher lifetime health cares costs because smokers on average die so much younger.
- superchroma 4y agoNo I'm in the "quit fucking around" camp. They need to be banned already. Rip the plaster off.
- AA-BA-94-2A-56 4y agoI am Australian, and I am skeptical that this is nothing more than protectionism for the large tobacco companies.
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoI am also Australian but I doubt it. Our governments have been pretty harsh on smoking for a while, hell a few years ago Tasmania wanted to ban it for anyone born after the year 2000 (I dunno if that actually passed/is still being looked at, but still) which definitely isn't a protectionist attitude to have towards the tobacco industry. Plus tobacco companies have actually tried to sell tobacco products that are classified as "e cigarettes" to avoid taxes in several jurisdictions. John Safran's book Puff Piece is quite interesting and covers that phenomenon (I recommend it).
- Andaith 4y agoThey're not banned outright because of the historic backlog of smokers. Tasmania is introducing a birth date cutoff, so younger generations are banned. Other states may follow. Also, they're not just taxed; they can't be advertised, they can't be displayed in shops, only one counter in a shop can sell them, they have gruesome images on the packets, and there's a LOT of support to quit smoking. The tobacco companies were using vaping as a way around all of these regulations, and an opportunity to once again market to younger generations, which is why i'm glad the govt is now doing something about vaping. I also doubt the black market is as large as you think. I'm sure it exists, but I just don't think it's as rich as you describe. We're "girt by ocean" on all sides, and if anybody has a successful smuggling route into Australia they likely want to maximise profit by smuggling higher value illegal substances.
- climb_stealth 4y agoFWIW, my experience has been that hardly anyone smokes in Australia compared to Europe. The policies must be working in some way.
- simiansays 4y agoAs a middle-aged long-time smoker who quit smoking immediately upon buying a vape several years ago, and having quite a number of friends who did the same thing, I'll point out a number of issues I have with this measure. - I do see a lot of kids vaping, just like you used to see a lot of underage kids smoking or drinking. The solution there was not to ban cigarettes and alcohol for adults, or require a prescription, it was suitable age-appropriate regulation. - I would not have seen a doctor to try out vapes. Under this regime, adult vapers like myself will now have to see a doctor, get a prescription which will likely need re-prescribing every 1-3 months, and most doctors won't renew prescriptions over the phone or without charge. My local GP charges me $80 a visit, that's now adding potentially $320-$1k/year to the cost of vaping, not to mention the additional fees that will be charged by pharmacists and whoever the approved vendors will be. (I also expect the approved products to kinda suck and certainly not include the only two flavours of vape that I enjoy.) - This thing about "big tobacco" somehow being the beneficiaries of Australian vaping seems like nonsense to me -- at least where I live (VIC), the overwhelming majority of vapers use dodgy off-brand imports of disposable vapes that are sold over-the-counter, with nicotine, by unethical tobacco shops (extremely common around my area). For more "sophisticated" vapers who use refillables with hand-mixed flavour and nicotine, the nicotine is imported from somewhere like NZ from a reputable nicotine supplier, the flavours are purchased locally, and the devices are mostly from quality Chinese manufacturers. I have seen maybe 1-2 Juul's in the past five years, but I live in regional Australia so maybe things are different in the city. Overall I think big tobacco seems to have a lot more to gain from vape prohibition here, as do the big pharma companies who sell OTC nic replacement products (e.g. J&J and GSK). - I have yet to see compelling evidence that vaping carries greater risk than other NRT products, modulo the Acetyl Acetate / "popcorn lung" issues that as far as I can tell originated almost entirely from dodgy THC vapes (very different product to nic vapes). Personally, I think the better solution here would have been to regulate vapes like cigarettes. They are beneficial to long-term adult smokers who have tried and failed to use other methods to quit. My wife literally tried everything including the crazy prescription anti-nic drugs and never was able to fully quit until switching to vapes. It's clear there is a huge under-enforcement problem right now (e.g. local shops selling OTC nicotine vapes, which is already illegal, and selling them to kids, also already illegal) but giving them the same regulatory framework as cigarettes, or maybe only allowing chemists to dispense them to 18+ users would have been preferable here. I love my vape and what it did for me and my friends. I don't really plan on quitting vaping any time soon because based on my readings of the mainstream medical papers, there isn't sufficient evidence of personal risk for me that comes even close to other legal risky things I do like eating fast food and drinking wine. I just dislike being in a position of now either needing to illegally import, or pay a huge effective tax to the medical/pharmacy industry, to keep vaping, as a responsible adult. That said, I would support a simultaneous "grandfather" ban on both cigarettes and ALL other nicotine products along the lines of cigarette bans where the products are banned for people 18 and younger, and that ban grows by one year per year. That's a better approach than what Australia is doing. I'm unsurprised it came to this, you could see the media coverage of vaping growing increasingly shrill / moral panicky over the past years, in contrast to the actual science on nicotine harm, where vapes may be on the "bad" side of other NRT products, but nowehere near the harm of cigarettes. It follows an eerily similar media narrative to what I've seen in other western countries (maybe other countries too, but I mainly read English media). I would not be surprised at all if both big tobacco and big pharma lobbyists are high-fiving themselves over this.
- villgax 4y agoWhat about conventional cigs? Too cushy to get rid of? Just like Alcohol I reckon