2 ms·
Not conflating, rather I don't think style is as relevant as genre to the discussion. The overall genre is more important, because it imposes more constraints
by coldtea 4y ago
Not conflating, rather I don't think style is as relevant as genre to the discussion.
The overall genre is more important, because it imposes more constraints to the songwriting. Style is basically just spice on top, nothing you can't change at will based on different playing, production, and orchestration.
The problem with tired bands isn't that they exhausted their style, but that they can't come up with decent new songs.
Other bands in the same genre (or even different genres) can and do however come up with new songs - and if the former band was able to write them (exactly the same as the second band has), then changing them to their own style would be super easy, barely an inconvenience.
For example, to take two bands in the same genre, if the Rolling Stones couldn't write decent songs in 1988-1998, and Black Crowes could (they put out a series of good records then), it was not because the Stones exhausted their style and Black Crowes still hadn't exhausted theirs.
It's just that the Stones had no inspiration, whereas the Crowes could still come up with good songs. The difference in style isn't really important, as the same same songs could trivially be turned to the style of the other band.
(Hell, even complete different style && genre songs can be turned into the genre and style of a band covering them, just need a different orchestration, production, and small stylistic flourishes - the core of the song, the chords, melody, lyrics remains the same).