6 ms·
Seems like a strawman to me. I've never heard anybody think setting "location services" to "off" prevented your cell service from detecting your location and p
by crazygringo 4y ago
Seems like a strawman to me.
I've never heard anybody think setting "location services" to "off" prevented your cell service from detecting your location and presence, which can then of course be shared with law enforcement.
The toggle is for not sharing your location with installed applications.
I think everybody knows that if it's important not to be tracked by law enforcement (e.g. attending an illegal protest), you don't take your phone in the first place. (And certainly everyone on HN already knows.)
So no, the location switch is not a lie.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoHello, article author here. I wrote the article to notify an audience a little bit broader than Hacker News. There are many people who seem to think that it's only Google or Apple or Facebook they need to worry about; or that if they get GrapheneOS they are now really-secure and really-private (which they are, from Google, but not really overall). The very idea that their cellphone carrier may have their location, even without their phone cooperating, is often a foreign idea they never thought of. This is, of course, a very long rabbit trail that never ends. Your license plate could get scanned. You could get picked up on cameras and run through facial recognition. But it's still important to call out areas that people may not have considered. Imagine a journalist - if nobody calls this out because "everyone knows," she might have installed GrapheneOS, signed up for ProtonMail, paid with cash for a SIM card, and gone off to cover some story without realizing this blind spot. > I think everybody knows that if it's important not to be tracked by law enforcement (e.g. attending an illegal protest), you don't take your phone in the first place. My home state would not have almost every police department armed to the teeth with IMSI Catchers if everybody just knew they weren't supposed to do that.
- megablast 4y ago[flagged]
- WheatMillington 4y agoHow is this a click bait title? Hacker News commenters often have a bad perspective on how non-tech people ought to see the world, and this is a great example. I'm not in tech, so I find it entirely reasonable to expect that if my phone has a "location tracking off" switch, it will disable location tracking. I honestly can't comprehend why you think this isn't a reasonable point of view.
- dendriti 4y agoThere's been a bizarre shift in discourse about privacy in the last 15 years. When most of these posters were young, they actually cared about keeping their personal information private. The idea that you would carry around a device with a location tracker that could only be turned off by deactivating the device, would have been horrifying. Now, at least on HN, these same people are saying This is Fine. Maybe their companies depend on exploiting the ignorant.
- nequo 4y agoCell phones 15 years ago still leaked location information via the cell tower they connected to, didn’t they? This doesn’t seem like a development from the past 15 years like you’re saying. So if you were privacy conscious to that extent 15 years ago, you didn’t carry a cell phone. That didn’t change.
- UncleMeat 4y agoI think a very important question is "what would you prefer this switch to say"?
- tinus_hn 4y agoAlso the accuracy of GPS is quite a bit higher than that of the accidental locating functionality of triangulating cell phone towers.
- cloudripper 4y agoI know of a few occasions [0] when missing persons were found stranded in the mountains due to the assistance of cell tower triangulation. That said, it's a pain to get any element of accuracy and in the US, it takes a lengthy legal process for law enforcement to obtain that data. [0]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64911138 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64911138
- j16sdiz 4y agoWasn't the "enhanced 911" thing supposed to give the law enforcement all the location information when you dial 911?
- HWR_14 4y agoThis just isn't the case with modern phones. 5G and 4G use active beam forming. It usually only takes a single tower to figure out bearing and signal strength can indicate range. With just one tower, a carrier knows where a 5G phone is within 10m. Combining multiple towers shrinks that rapidly.
- Spivak 4y ago> attending an illegal protest Otherwise known as a protest that isn't a 5k with signs and legally classified as a parade.
- asynchronous 4y agoSeriously. In the states you have to get permission beforehand to protest, which imo destroys the point of it.
- gowld 4y agoThere is a difference between "protest" and "civil disobedience".
- WoahNoun 4y agoI'm pretty sure most of the George Floyd protests didn't ask for permission beforehand.
- HWR_14 4y agoNo state requires permission to protest. States do require permission to block the streets. However, the courts force such permitting decisions to be neutral to the political message.
- asynchronous 4y agoNo, you need a permit in MANY states before ANY public “demonstration”. That is the same as asking permission.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoSource? As far as I'm aware no jurisdiction in U.S. has a blanket ban everywhere, only in certain downtown areas, roadways, etc...
- HWR_14 4y agoThat's just factually wrong in the US. ACLU: "If marchers stay on the sidewalks and obey traffic and pedestrian signals, their activity is constitutionally protected even without a permit." There are a few other things to avoid (blocking other pedestrians, using sound amplification devices) without a permit. And of course, private property owners can set their own rules.
- advisedwang 4y agoI think amongst the technically literate here on HN, probably 99% know what the switch does. But amongst the public at large there are ABSOLUTELY people that think the location button is magic. Non-technically literate people need protection just as much as us, and this the way this button is labelled fails them.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoArticle author here. This is exactly my point. This could be so much clearer. Think about when you open a private window in Chrome. There's a clear warning that your ISP or school or employer may know what websites you visit anyway. But there's no such warning for smartphones. It just says "Location: Off" and people don't know.
- gowld 4y agohttps://support.google.com/android/answer/3467281 https://support.google.com/android/answer/3467281 Linked from Location Setting. But it doesn't mention carrier tracking your location. That is fundamental to how cell phones work, though, unless you enable Airplane Mode.
- autoexec 4y agoAirplane mode is also a lie (https://old.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/9l57b6/my_phone_was_in_airplane_mode_and_i_still/ https://old.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/9l57b6/m...)
- circuit10 4y agoCould it be receiving signals but not sending them, or is that not how it works?
- autoexec 4y agoI think you'd have to be sending and receiving to stay connected to the towers at all. I haven't tried it, but if it's true that you can still call 911 while in airplane mode then you're certainly sending and receiving. What we need is a "No really, all radios off" switch, preferably a hardware switch, but if we had one maybe people would opt of being tracked all the time.
- gerdesj 4y agoDid you actually read the blog? The second para starts: "Well, that would be the case if we lived in an ideal world, but that switch is more of a polite “please don’t” than an actual deterrent." FFS this isn't /. 8)
- hoppyhoppy2 4y ago>Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that". https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gerdesj 4y agoI think it is important that a discussion about something should actually involve the original something. Informed discussion should be ... informed. I think it is facile to appear to actively encourage discussion that is demonstrably uninformed of the OP.
- laristine 4y agoYes, and you can do so by saying "the article mentions that..." like gp pointed out.
- gerdesj 4y agoYes, and I think that is debating semantics. I do understand that a site might have a house style or whatever but what exactly did I do wrong? Why can I not call out a comment for being misinformed at best because the commenter clearly didn't read the article that they are commenting on?
- jrockway 4y agoPresumably you're commenting to rectify the misinformation, and you can get to the meat of it one sentence sooner if you skip the personal attack. You already know the person you're replying to doesn't read everything in front of them. Why give them more to read? Why open with a personal attack? It never makes people like you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- croes 4y agoMore like we already know the switch is a lie
- dbtc 4y agoYeah but it should.
- snvzz 4y ago>I've never heard anybody think setting "location services" to "off" prevented your cell service from detecting your location and presence, which can then of course be shared with law enforcement. Notice the article authors' age. Unlike most of us, they likely never used a pre-internet-capable cellphone.
- nvr219 4y agoAgreed. The article talks about going to politically unpopular protests. Anyone who attends those is educated on not taking their phones with them when the stakes are that high.
- GuB-42 4y agoA bit like icognito/private mode in browsers. It is only private on your side, it changes nothing for the sites you visit or their partners, they can still track you, and your IP address is still visible. It is not a blocker like uBlock, though in the case of Firefox, turning on private mode also enables a builtin blocker. It is explained clearly when you open Incognito mode in Chrome, and people complained that it doesn't do what it says it doesn't.
- ProAm 4y agoPeople on here may be surprised that the off button also doesn't really turn it off.
- m463 4y ago"Find My" will find an iphone that is off. even with wifi/bluetooth/location services turned off, apple constantly connects to *.ls.apple.com. sigh.
- goodpoint 4y ago> I've never heard anybody think setting "location services" to "off" prevented your cell service from detecting your location Outside of the HN bubble, many. Besides, the point stands: the UI is misleading. A phone should clearly show to the user what data is sent, where and why, without any exception.
- goodpoint 4y agoReally?! Downvoted for this?
- coldtea 4y ago>I've never heard anybody think setting "location services" to "off" prevented your cell service from detecting your location and presence You'd be quite surprised at what people do believe.
- StrictDabbler 4y agoOn the original iPhone the location switch was basically real. Location services burned a ton of battery and law enforcement's ping capability was rudimentary. Back then turning the switch off made a smartphone as difficult to locate as a dumbphone. The phone had to exert a lot of energy to know where it was even within a city block. I'm not convinced this has changed much. Obviously if the Eye of Sauron chooses to focus on your location there's no way to avoid it but I would bet that mundane cell phone location logs are sharply limited by tower storage, CPU limits, and probably by software licensing. I'd be interested to hear from a cell tower software engineer.
- than3 4y agoYet the toggle is automatically on for a number of applications even when it says its turned off. That still makes its existence a misleading coercive lie giving you the illusion of control; for those that don't already know better. These dark patterns should be illegal (and in fact are if you take a strict constructional meaning from deceptive and unfair business practices already codified in law). Its just effective enforcement of antitrust, and FTC violations simply isn't occurring at these monoliths.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y ago>> if it's important not to be tracked by law enforcement (e.g. attending an illegal protest), you don't take your phone in the first place These days it won't help, thanks to our friends from the AI department. Anyone's identity is easily found from the cameras filming the illegal protest.
- NoPicklez 4y agoAs someone (like many of us) who had phones pre-smartphone, it's pretty obvious to me that switching location services off was only to prevent apps from doing so. Your carrier has in my mind, always been able to determine your location. We had movies doing triangulation based on phone calls to catch criminals. The guy who wrote the article was 21, so it's not a stretch to think they only grew up in the smartphone world and didn't have that base understanding.
- _8j50 4y agoNo, I fully expect GPS to be off even though cell provider can still triangulate my location. On airplane mode I expect both things to be off. Now, I would like to know what is stopping a class action suit on this subject.
- xnx 4y agoI'm guessing there's a big overlap in the population that thinks "locations services" set to "off" protects their location also thinks that "incognito" hides their identify even when they log in to a site.
- ComplexSystems 4y ago"I think everybody knows that if it's important not to be tracked by law enforcement (e.g. attending an illegal protest), you don't take your phone in the first place." This is because they know that the "location off" switch is a lie.
- webinvest 4y agoWhat about just turning your phone off?
- PaulHoule 4y agoThey gotta track you enough to pick the right tower to ring your phone.