3 ms·
Thank you for spelling this out in detail. I took a user interface design course a few years ago in college (good college, good lecturer, good students), and w
by jacobolus 15y ago
Thank you for spelling this out in detail.
I took a user interface design course a few years ago in college (good college, good lecturer, good students), and was frustrated by exactly the same problem.
The focus of the course was learning process rather than making things, but we only were able to touch each particular process step (paper prototyping, user testing, formal usability study, &c.) one time, for a week or two of an assignment about it, and so there was no great way to judge improved understanding after having done the exercise, or experiment with different methods to see what their faults were.
Because most of the actual effort in the course went into writing about what we had done, instead of doing it, I feel like we learned quite a bit more about (a) describing our group’s working habits and parroting back the theoretical benefits of particular processes than we did about either (b) performing those processes or (c) the actual project we were trying to build.
The only way to really make these meta-analyses of process and structure valuable is, as you say, to take them on after having tried doing the thing a few times. You can’t make a map in your head of ideas you’ve never experienced by just copying other maps. It’s like trying to design an API without knowing what the use cases are, or trying to pick a data structure before you have idea what the data looks like.
* * *
This type of instruction is far too common; pedagogical exercises are decontextualized and the means become the ends. Instead of learning languages by reading and speaking, with explanations of grammar and bilingual dictionaries as reinforcement and an ultimate goal of conversation/writing fluency, language classes help students to perfect their ability to learn and perform grammar drills. Instead of trying to write and discuss stories, using writing as a tool for clarifying thought and sharing ideas, English classes spend all their effort and attention on teaching narrow rather uninspiring process and rigid form. Instead of finding math and physics problems in the context of figuring out how something works, we put the problems in their own little boxes and pretend they’re discrete entities, and students are expected to just grok the patterns without having done the kinds of doodling and exploration that ever actually reveal their structure.
Unfortunately, without much smaller student:teacher ratios, it’s really hard for teachers to act as guides and mentors rather than lecturers.