3 ms·
The article has a rather retro take on this, which is usual. But not useful. If you view capitalism as a feedback control system, it's a system where there are
by Animats 4y ago
The article has a rather retro take on this, which is usual. But not useful.
If you view capitalism as a feedback control system, it's a system where there are many feedbacks with different lags. Such systems oscillate. They don't converge on some optimal point. That's well known.
US capitalism has so many monopolies and oligopolies that it doesn't act much like a free market any more. Three big banks, two big drugstore chains, three cellular providers... None of those look like a competitive market. The European Union did a study that concluded that price competition doesn't appear until there are at least four players of roughly comparable size. If you want a free market, you have to keep the players from becoming too big.
On the other hand, central planning within large companies is stronger than ever. WalMart and Amazon are very centrally controlled. This works much better than Gosplan ever did. The data is better and the lag is less. Gosplan had a monthly reporting cycle and an annual plan cycle. WalMart had a daily reporting cycle and a weekly plan cycle, and that was years ago.
China uses an opposite extreme - five-year plans. At one time they were mostly political statements.
That hasn't been true in years. The 13th Five Year Plan (2016-2020) was pretty much accomplished.[1]
The 14th Five Year Plan (2021-2025) is coming along reasonably well. Specific goals include 5G deployment to 56% of the population, and conversion to IPv6. Yes, IPv6 made it to the top level national strategy document.
How those get turned into lower level tasks I don't know.
[1] https://www.uscc.gov/sites/default/files/Research/The%2013th%20Five-Year%20Plan_Final_2.14.17_Updated%20%28002%29.pdf https://www.uscc.gov/sites/default/files/Research/The%2013th...
[2] https://cset.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/t0284_14th_Five_Year_Plan_EN.pdf https://cset.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/t0284_14th_Fi...
- revelio 4y agoArguably the big trend in recent decades has been the non centrally planned corporation. Google and Facebook are the poster boys for this approach in which managers see themselves primarily as enablers for the workers, in which those workers have a great deal of individual autonomy and there's relatively little central planning except in "wartime". Many other companies have adopted this style to a lesser degree. You can argue it has downsides, Google's brand dilution for example, but these are very rich and successful companies by any metric. The core problem with central planning is handling change. If the requirements placed on an institution never change, then central planning eventually takes over because the plan is so stable that it can be managed centrally, and that may even have economies of scale. Businesses like Walmart are basically giant factories. Supermarkets are not a business that experiences great or rapid change. Tech firms in contrast experience and create change at a much faster rate, so central planning is more harmful there. Economies as a whole are in near constant change. That's why centrally planned economies lose. They're always optimizing for yesterday's goals, like how many tonnes of steel can be produced per day, but can't react to changes like maybe now computers matter more than steel.
- ChadNauseam 4y ago> Three big banks, two big drugstore chains, three cellular providers Costs associated with banking, drugstore purchases, and cell service make up an tiny proportion of total spending. Compare that to housing, education, and healthcare, which are the main drivers of inflation despite having many more than four players of comparable size. People say healthcare and housing is expensive because you need it to live. You need food to live too, but food is so cheap as to be basically free in the US. (Food as in rice and beans, not Uber Eats.) I'm not saying central planning is bad necessarily, but can it be a coincidence that healthcare, housing, and education are so expensive and also hugely "centrally planned"? The government determines how many apartments get to be in your city (and they usually decide on a laughably small number). The government decides who gets to practice medicine (and they make sure that the number is not very high [0]). They even decide to not let doctors in countries like India do radiology work in the US, just to boost American radiologist's pay. As for education, most people go to public colleges where the government literally decides the prices! Not only that, but they generously offer "need-based scholarships" to people, after determining their willingness to pay by getting their family income. So maybe central planning is the move, but it would be more compelling if the biggest expenses of American life didn't all seem to be caused by at-best incompetent central planning. [0]: https://www.washingtonian.com/2020/04/13/were-short-on-healthcare-workers-why-doesnt-the-u-s-just-make-more-doctors/ https://www.washingtonian.com/2020/04/13/were-short-on-healt...
- csb6 4y ago> can it be a coincidence that healthcare, housing, and education are so expensive and also hugely "centrally planned"? How are you defining central planning? It seems like you mean “extensive government intervention and involvement”, which I don’t think is an accurate definition. Using that definition, then food is also a “centrally planned” industry, since governments heavily subsidize dairy producers and farmers, leading to cheaper food products. Governments also are deeply involved in regulating and intervening in the banking and telecommunications industries, which you seem to imply are not “centrally planned” and so are more affordable.
- hbrn 4y agoIf Amazon and Walmart are so great at being centrally controlled, why did both of them introduce third-party sellers to the platform?