3 ms·
I'm very confused. There's so much chatter over the pad being destroyed and I feel like I'm out of the loop. Why is it such a big deal? Silicosis is obviously b
by mrguyorama 4y ago
I'm very confused. There's so much chatter over the pad being destroyed and I feel like I'm out of the loop. Why is it such a big deal? Silicosis is obviously bad but how much silicosis did this issue cause?
- qayxc 4y agoThe main reason is that no heavy lift rocket in history (not a single one in the last 60 years) has been launched without mitigations that prevent a launch pad from being destroyed during a successful lift-off. SpaceX (or rather Musk in particular) decided against 60 years of worldwide experience and decided to forego such measures. The result was not just damage to the launch facility, but also debris being spread around at dangerous speeds in a significant radius around the pad. The latter should not have happened, especially considering that the launch site is partially surrounded by protected wildlife habitats. The fuss is primarily about the negligence and borderline incompetence. The icing on the cake was that they already had plans to avoid this, but deliberately decided not to implement those before any launch attempt. The excuse that "they didn't expect this" sounds a bit strange, given that Saturn V and the Soviet N1 had quite substantial protection systems for their launch pads while being only half as powerful as Starship/Super Heavy. It's really a culmination of many issues with the site, and this event is just the latest in a string of irregularities at Boca Chica. It started with a false license - the site was licenced to launch F9 and FH only; not experimental super heavy rockets - and included unlicenced launch activities that resulted in a major explosion (see https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/17/faa-defends-spacex-despite-unauthorized-starship-sn8-launch.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/17/faa-defends-spacex-despite-u...). It's not just about a destroyed launch pad, it's more about the entirety of SpaceX's activities at Boca Chica. It doesn't matter what one's personal opinion about the company as whole or its CEO is; there are some legitimate irregularities and in the end some parties decided sue.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- jiggawatts 4y agoLikely zero. This is a bunch of Greenpeace-types that would pat themselves on the back for stopping the construction of a nuclear power plant, while blithely ignoring the new coal power plant that had to be constructed in its place.
- tinus_hn 4y agoThe big deal is hurr durr Musk bad. Apart from that it’s a giant nothingburger.
- xodjmk 4y agoSpaceX are succeeding by strategically blowing up prototypes and learning by pushing materials up to and past the point of failure. I think the majority of people watching this are celebrating and appreciate the progression of never been done before reusable rocket technology. Then of course there are losers whining about dust and a broken concrete slab. There is great drama. Which side will prevail?
- jiggawatts 4y agoYou've got to wonder how many times per day nearly identical "environmental impacts" are occurring due to mundane causes such as the use of explosives in mining, building demolations, or whatever. This is a bunch of attention seekers latching on to a famous company like leeches.
- xodjmk 4y agoFor real. I am pro environment, so I do think there is some legitimate amount of environmental impact studies that should be done. But it is clear there is some emotional/ideological agenda attached to anything associated with Musk, now the SpaceX launch is just the target of the moment. The industries threatened by innovation hire PR who prey on easily emotionally swayed individuals, and the result is a flood of parroted opinions and hit-pieces propagated all over the internet.