3 ms·
You need to look at ratios. WW2 was such an unimaginably large scale war, that anecdotes don't really tell you anything. In WW2 the Allies lost 16,000,000 milit
by somenameforme 4y ago
You need to look at ratios. WW2 was such an unimaginably large scale war, that anecdotes don't really tell you anything. In WW2 the Allies lost 16,000,000 military and 45,000,000 civilians. The Axis powers lost 8,000,000 military and 4,000,000 civilians. Comparing this to e.g. Iraq is difficult due to a lack of reliable source of casualties, so we'll have to ballpark it. Leaked US figures (Iraq War documents) claim we killed 45,000 enemies, which is going to be a heavy overestimate. Civilian deaths in Iraq range from 110,000 to 1,0333,000. I'll pick a meet in the middle of 500,000. Using those figures we can measure this objectively:
Civilians deaths per combatant death:
---
WW2 Allied Forces = 2.8
WW2 Axis Powers = 0.5
Iraq War Iraqis = 12.7
---
Modern wars are smaller in scale (for now), but much worse on civilians as a ratio where they do happen. The reason is because of the nature of wars we get into. We invade countries which cannot competently defend themselves, and so it immediately transforms into an asymmetric Guerilla style defense against an occupying force. And in these scenarios its impossible for the invader to know who is an enemy and who is a civilian, so civilians suffer just terribly and over very long periods of time.
The final drone strike of Afghanistan [1] is quite a symbolic one that will certainly go down in history. The US military initially claimed they killed a group of Islamic State forces planning an attack on US forces, after observing an ISIS militant placing explosives in his trunk. In reality they killed 1 man, 2 adult members of his family, and 7 children from the local neighborhood (who ran out after he honked his horn when getting home). Those "explosives" were bottles of water, and the "ISIS militant" was a longterm humanitarian aid worker, who was working for a US NGO and applying for a US visa. If not for the excessive media attention on the final strike of the war, that would likely have just been marked up as another successful strike, with some unfortunate collateral damage. And that was one day in a 20 year occupation.
[1] - https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-kabul-taliban-strikes-islamic-state-group-b8bd9b0c805c610758bd1d3e20090c2c https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-kabul-taliban-strikes...
- neatze 4y agoThis is almost like arguing that ISIS inflicted civilian casualties are only due to US air strikes, because it reads to me like you are arguing that Iraqi civilian casualties are not due to unimaginable number of IED's in civilian population, and not due to using combat storage/staging ares in civilian population, in addition, to country as whole being in a civil war a like state of many years.
- somenameforme 4y agoThis is actually a pretty interesting issue, which I hadn't bothered to look up before. A large chunk of all violent deaths are directly attributed to the US Coalition. For instance here [1] is the Lancet study, which directly attributes 186,000 violent civilian deaths to the Coalition alone. That yields a 4.1 ratio due to direct violence from the Coalition alone, which is itself already far worse than even WW2. And that's extremely surprising to me. When you look at things like WW2 civilian deaths you're not only looking at violent deaths caused by the enemy. You're looking at deaths caused by all involved powers as well as indirect deaths caused by the nature of war - starvation, disease, despair, etc. The fact that one side, alone, in modern warfare can cause more violent civilian deaths (as a ratio) than all of those factors combined, in past wars, really emphasizes the notion that the concept of modern war being better for civilians is just exceptionally misguided. The history books of the future are going to look back on the present in a way I think few can imagine today. [1] - https://sci-hub.ru/https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(06)69491-9/fulltext https://sci-hub.ru/https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet...