3 ms·
Can we also tackle the general problem, by considering the snooping to be a diplomatic problem of the locale that does it? A lot of travel is discretionary, su
by neilv 4y ago
Can we also tackle the general problem, by considering the snooping to be a diplomatic problem of the locale that does it?
A lot of travel is discretionary, such as vacations. Academic and trade conferences can often choose where they're located. Business can often choose where they do business or expand.
A public interest Web site could publish a trustworthy database of incidents and report card grades of different locales, covering more concerns than the US State Dept. does.
Say, ExampleCon 2024 is announced to be in sunny Barlandia, and a bunch of members respond that they don't feel safe attending, because the database says that Barlandia Customs often clones the devices of visitors without apparent justifiable cause, and some alarming specific incidents. Some respond privately; some publicly announce not traveling to Barlandia, and why.
When planning ExampleCon 2025, organizers consider the convention center in Footopia but have learned to check the database, and find that Footopia has a totalitarian attitude towards privacy&security, as well as elevated incidence of harassment of LGBTQ+ and certain ethnic/racial identities. They don't tell the membership that Footopia was considered, but when they announce the choice of Bazland, they also link its favorable status page on the database Web site.
Meanwhile, the Blortcity government is taking note of this, and embarks on a intense campaign to make their status page numbers look great. A side effect -- besides their consequently growing tourism industry, and increasing tax base from new residents -- is that a lot of abusive/hostile behaviors are stopped for everyone living and visiting there.
- mattnewton 4y agoSerious question, are there locales with a consistently good track record on this? I have only seen news stories of when it goes wrong and it's difficult to calibrate %s for each region. Like the US is often good for rule of law, but there are a lot of notable counter examples. In this article, around the UK, it's difficult to get a sense of how often this sort of thing is happening especially relative to other western places. I suspect that virtually every country does this sort of thing regularly and the incentives to stop have got to be much more severe than tourism and conference hostings, there is just too long of a road from that to domestic voter outrage to actually endanger lawmakers jobs. We have to get people to care about it through arguing I think.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoThis seems like an unreasonably difficult project. If you're already aware that reviews on, e.g. Yelp and Amazon are difficult to police and discern the authentic ones, wait until you have positive and negative reports on literally your global state-level threat actors in action. You will be shut down in any less-than-free nation, and you will be under attack by astroturfing and misinformation campaigns like you wouldn't believe. Now how would you defend against that sort of thing and build a trustworthy database, when your very premise depends entirely on verbal descriptions and hearsay claims with no evidence available or required?
- neilv 4y agoGood point; if you have impact against sketchiness, you draw fire from the sketchy upon yourself. Maybe assemble some trustworthy network of local journalists who can get accurate info, and who can tell you when they cannot get accurate info? And when a place is too hostile to find trustworthy journalists, that alone might make that place a no-go? (You'd still be subject to high-touch compromise in some cases, but maybe not the current problem of automated LLM-powered botnet deluges.) Personally, I don't have the stomach for taking on state actors as adversaries (too lawless and scary), but this is the kind of thing someone who feels nigh-invincible could undertake to "change the world" in a positive and selfless way.